No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Scan to download the app

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Ninja Turtle Stuff AnimalNinja Turtle Stuff Animal$12Trafford, PALounge & Co Crash Foam PillowLounge & Co Crash Foam Pillow$75Pittsburgh, PAHandmade crocheted dragon lampPromotedHandmade crocheted dragon lamp$180Placentia, CALarge stuffed spiderLarge stuffed spider$12Plum, PANEW CLOUD ISLAND GREY ELEPHANT SOFT PLUSH TOY NEW CLOUD ISLAND GREY ELEPHANT SOFT PLUSH TOY $12Lynwood, CASymbolically Adopt A Giant Tortoise$60.00Symbolically Adopt A Giant TortoiseWWF GiftsAdBeanie Baby LotBeanie Baby Lot$40Cedarhurst, PABeanie BabiesBeanie Babies$100Finleyville, PAHELLO KITTY /Dear Daniel Sweetheart Wedding 8" Plush Toy McDonalds RARE MINT 2000PromotedHELLO KITTY /Dear Daniel Sweetheart Wedding 8" Plush Toy McDonalds RARE MINT 2000$100Vacaville, CAStuffed Animals LotStuffed Animals Lot$345Pittsburgh, PAWebkinz Stuffed Animal LotWebkinz Stuffed Animal Lot$22Heidelberg, PA2 Vintage Dole cranston cranberry plush 7" Stuffed animal Plush Toy 1999 Advertisement 2 Vintage Dole cranston cranberry plush 7" Stuffed animal Plush Toy 1999 Advertisement $14Glenshaw, PAFree Elephant Baby Set With Donation$60.00Free Elephant Baby Set With DonationWWF GiftsAdRare Beanie BabysPromotedRare Beanie Babys$400Galesburg, ILStitch Pillow pet Stitch Pillow pet $21Moon Township, PAStuffed AnimalsStuffed Animals$75Manor, PAMimikyu PlushMimikyu Plush$10Moon Township, PATY beanie Babies TY beanie Babies $20Pittsburgh, PASuper Mario’s Plush PromotedSuper Mario’s Plush $75Tolleson, AZSymbolically Adopt A Grizzly Bear$60.00Symbolically Adopt A Grizzly BearWWF GiftsAdThumper Animated Stuffed ToyThumper Animated Stuffed Toy$20Allison Park, PAVintage Mickey Mouse PlushVintage Mickey Mouse Plush$150East Liberty, PAVintage Kellytoy Plush Siberian Tiger Stuffed White Toy Animal Blue-Eyed 56”Vintage Kellytoy Plush Siberian Tiger Stuffed White Toy Animal Blue-Eyed 56”$50Moon Township, PA CatnapPromoted Catnap$18Chico, CABeanie babiesBeanie babies$0Aliquippa, PARARE Squishmallow Kwame The Walrus 18” Plush Toy NWTRARE Squishmallow Kwame The Walrus 18” Plush Toy NWT$20Clairton, PASymbolically Adopt A Mouse Lemur$60.00Symbolically Adopt A Mouse LemurWWF GiftsAdSquishmallow Banks the Badger 18” Plush Toy NWTSquishmallow Banks the Badger 18” Plush Toy NWT$20Clairton, PABeanie BabiesBeanie Babies$5Pittsburgh, PAStuffed Snowman Stuffed Snowman $20Pittsburgh, PAVintage 1986 AmToy My Pet Football Monster 26" Plush with Jersey, Helmet, CuffsVintage 1986 AmToy My Pet Football Monster 26" Plush with Jersey, Helmet, Cuffs$400Pittsburgh, PAPink Squishy Plushy Heart Themed Stuffed FriendPink Squishy Plushy Heart Themed Stuffed Friend$8Pittsburgh, PABeanie Baby LotBeanie Baby Lot$60Cedarhurst, PASymbolically Adopt An African Wild Dog Pup$60.00Symbolically Adopt An African Wild Dog PupWWF GiftsAdCherries Jubilee: My Little Pony 1984 PlushCherries Jubilee: My Little Pony 1984 Plush$30Hazelwood, PACute BUILD-A-BEAR Panda Stuffed toy animal + a pink sleeveless vest!Cute BUILD-A-BEAR Panda Stuffed toy animal + a pink sleeveless vest!$11Canonsburg, PANanco Care Bears Plush Wish Bear Shooting Star 9” 2003 Teal Stuffed ToyNanco Care Bears Plush Wish Bear Shooting Star 9” 2003 Teal Stuffed Toy$20Pittsburgh, PASquishmallowsSquishmallows$60Glassport, PABaby Shark PlushBaby Shark Plush$15Glassport, PAFao Schwatz Solider BearFao Schwatz Solider Bear$12Glassport, PASymbolically Adopt A Snowy Owl$60.00Symbolically Adopt A Snowy OwlWWF GiftsAdHallmark Wizard Of Oz Itty BittysHallmark Wizard Of Oz Itty Bittys$35Glassport, PASquishmallow Disney 100th Anniversary Minnie Mouse And TinkerbellSquishmallow Disney 100th Anniversary Minnie Mouse And Tinkerbell$30Glassport, PAOsitos Nuebos Ositos Nuebos $20Santa Ana, CAStitch Stitch $20Glassport, PATy Lot Ty Lot $38Glassport, PATickle Me Elmo Tickle Me Elmo $45Wilmerding, PASymbolically Adopt A Giant Elephant Plush$250.00Symbolically Adopt A Giant Elephant PlushWWF GiftsAdDisney Minnie Mouse Stuffed Animals Disney Minnie Mouse Stuffed Animals $50Pittsburgh, PANew Stuffed Animals Only $10 EachNew Stuffed Animals Only $10 Each$10No Huntingdon, PA