No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Scan to download the app

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Stuffed Animal Puppy ToysStuffed Animal Puppy Toys$25Clifton, NJBag Of Plushies Stuffed Animals Bag Of Plushies Stuffed Animals $25Queens, NYDisney Mickey And Minnie Mouse Christmas 2019PromotedDisney Mickey And Minnie Mouse Christmas 2019$45Queens, NYTomy Pokemon Squirtle the Turtle Plush 7" Stuffed Animal 2017Tomy Pokemon Squirtle the Turtle Plush 7" Stuffed Animal 2017$12New York, NYNEW CLOUD ISLAND GREY ELEPHANT SOFT PLUSH TOY NEW CLOUD ISLAND GREY ELEPHANT SOFT PLUSH TOY $12Lynwood, CASymbolically Adopt A Giant Tortoise$60.00Symbolically Adopt A Giant TortoiseWWF GiftsAdStuffed Animals & ToysStuffed Animals & Toys$2The Bronx, NYPete the Cat Kewl Blue Guitar Pete 12" Plush Stuffed Animal ToyPete the Cat Kewl Blue Guitar Pete 12" Plush Stuffed Animal Toy$14Floral Park, NYHELLO KITTY /Dear Daniel Sweetheart Wedding 8" Plush Toy McDonalds RARE MINT 2000PromotedHELLO KITTY /Dear Daniel Sweetheart Wedding 8" Plush Toy McDonalds RARE MINT 2000$100Vacaville, CABig Plush Stuffed Red Bull 46 Inch Huge Animal NICE GoffaBig Plush Stuffed Red Bull 46 Inch Huge Animal NICE Goffa$60Clifton, NJDisney Store Moana Sitting Pua The Pig 9" Plush Authentic Stuffed Animal PiggieDisney Store Moana Sitting Pua The Pig 9" Plush Authentic Stuffed Animal Piggie$14Floral Park, NYDisney Parks Finding Nemo (Clown Fish) Orange White Plush Stuffed Animal 9.5"Disney Parks Finding Nemo (Clown Fish) Orange White Plush Stuffed Animal 9.5"$7New York, NYFree Elephant Baby Set With Donation$60.00Free Elephant Baby Set With DonationWWF GiftsAdRare Beanie BabysPromotedRare Beanie Babys$400Galesburg, ILStuffed Plush Animal Lot Assorted With TagsStuffed Plush Animal Lot Assorted With Tags$25Lynbrook, NYLot of 38 Stuffed Animals including Several Build a BearsLot of 38 Stuffed Animals including Several Build a Bears$40Bergenfield, NJPAW Patrol Cat Pack Plush SHADE Nickelodeon Cat Pack Stuffed AnimalPAW Patrol Cat Pack Plush SHADE Nickelodeon Cat Pack Stuffed Animal$15Floral Park, NYMerry Makers Pete the Cat By James Dean 12" Plush Stuffed AnimalMerry Makers Pete the Cat By James Dean 12" Plush Stuffed Animal$15Floral Park, NYTY PlushiesPromotedTY Plushies$40Costa Mesa, CASymbolically Adopt A Mouse Lemur$60.00Symbolically Adopt A Mouse LemurWWF GiftsAd2019 Hallmark Peanuts Snoopy Graduation 2019 Plush Stuffed Animal Graduate Gift2019 Hallmark Peanuts Snoopy Graduation 2019 Plush Stuffed Animal Graduate Gift$13Floral Park, NYMelissa & Doug Burrow Bunny Brown Rabbit Stuffed Animal Sitting 9” Toy NewMelissa & Doug Burrow Bunny Brown Rabbit Stuffed Animal Sitting 9” Toy New$20Floral Park, NYJellycat Perry Polar Bear Small 8" tall Plush Stuffed Animal NWTJellycat Perry Polar Bear Small 8" tall Plush Stuffed Animal NWT$33Floral Park, NYDisney Baymax Plush – Big Hero 6 – 12 ½ InchesPromotedDisney Baymax Plush – Big Hero 6 – 12 ½ Inches$25West Covina, CAWalt Disneryworld 14" Winnie the Pooh Bear Plush Stuffed Animal VVG ConditionWalt Disneryworld 14" Winnie the Pooh Bear Plush Stuffed Animal VVG Condition$10Staten Island, NYPrissy & Pop Mini Pig Plush GUND Stuffed Animal Blue Shirt Gift Farmhouse BarnPrissy & Pop Mini Pig Plush GUND Stuffed Animal Blue Shirt Gift Farmhouse Barn$13Floral Park, NYSymbolically Adopt A Grizzly Bear$60.00Symbolically Adopt A Grizzly BearWWF GiftsAdLots Of 8 Stuffed Animals And Plush Lots Of 8 Stuffed Animals And Plush $18The Bronx, NY1999 Ty Original Beanie Babies Brown 1999 SIGNATURE BEAR (9 inch)1999 Ty Original Beanie Babies Brown 1999 SIGNATURE BEAR (9 inch)$1,200Paterson, NJKohls Cares Woodstock Plush 12" Yellow Bird Stuffed Animal Peanuts Charlie BrownKohls Cares Woodstock Plush 12" Yellow Bird Stuffed Animal Peanuts Charlie Brown$12Floral Park, NYJellycat 12" Bashful Bunny Pink Plush Rabbit Floppy Stuffed Animal Jingle Jellycat 12" Bashful Bunny Pink Plush Rabbit Floppy Stuffed Animal Jingle $17Floral Park, NYKIDS PREFERRED Guess How Much I Love You My First Playset Cute Stuffed Animal Bunny Plush Storytime KIDS PREFERRED Guess How Much I Love You My First Playset Cute Stuffed Animal Bunny Plush Storytime $12Floral Park, NYBeanie BabyBeanie Baby$750New York, NYSymbolically Adopt An African Wild Dog Pup$60.00Symbolically Adopt An African Wild Dog PupWWF GiftsAdScentsy Buddy Eeyore Disney Stuffed Animal Plush Donkey Scarf Winter Crinkle ToyScentsy Buddy Eeyore Disney Stuffed Animal Plush Donkey Scarf Winter Crinkle Toy$17Floral Park, NYMonkey giraffe grey white plush stuffed animal Velcro arms soft lot of 2Monkey giraffe grey white plush stuffed animal Velcro arms soft lot of 2$10Floral Park, NYMickey Mouse and Vintage Pink Polka-Dot Minnie Mouse Stuffed AnimalsMickey Mouse and Vintage Pink Polka-Dot Minnie Mouse Stuffed Animals$20Bergenfield, NJNew Scooby Doo Shaggy Rogers Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 7" Cartoon Scoob! MovieNew Scooby Doo Shaggy Rogers Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 7" Cartoon Scoob! Movie$25Floral Park, NYTed dollTed doll$65New York, NYTY Beanie Babies Ballz "Iron Man" 2013 Plush 5" Red Stuffed Ball SuperheroTY Beanie Babies Ballz "Iron Man" 2013 Plush 5" Red Stuffed Ball Superhero$7Floral Park, NYSymbolically Adopt A Snowy Owl$60.00Symbolically Adopt A Snowy OwlWWF GiftsAdCarters Puppy Dog Pink Brown Spot Musical Crib Pull Plush Stuffed Animal Toy newCarters Puppy Dog Pink Brown Spot Musical Crib Pull Plush Stuffed Animal Toy new$44Floral Park, NYTy Pluffies Baby Bear Teddy Stuffed Plush Lovey Pink Pajamas PJ's 2010 AnimalTy Pluffies Baby Bear Teddy Stuffed Plush Lovey Pink Pajamas PJ's 2010 Animal$30Floral Park, NYOsitos Nuebos Ositos Nuebos $20Santa Ana, CAPokemon Pikachu 32” Giant PlushiePokemon Pikachu 32” Giant Plushie$100Clifton, NJGiant 3 FT Penguin PlushGiant 3 FT Penguin Plush$75Clifton, NJRed YoshiRed Yoshi$20Queens, NYSymbolically Adopt A Giant Elephant Plush$250.00Symbolically Adopt A Giant Elephant PlushWWF GiftsAdRilakkuma Plush Bear Rilakkuma Plush Bear $20Queens, NYRilakkuma Jumbo Plus BearRilakkuma Jumbo Plus Bear$150Queens, NY