No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Crocheted Puppies, Customizable Crocheted Puppies, Customizable $50Delaware, OHLarge Sea Turtle Plush Large Sea Turtle Plush $25Dublin, OHHello Kitty Plush pillow Hello Kitty Plush pillow $6Blacklick, OHpokemon paired pikachu celebrations unova region plush setpokemon paired pikachu celebrations unova region plush set$100Los Angeles, CA15 Webkinz15 Webkinz$25Hilliard, OHBurger SquishmallowBurger Squishmallow$25Obetz, OHAssorted Stuffed Animals Assorted Stuffed Animals $5Hilliard, OHRare Erin Beanie BabyRare Erin Beanie Baby$50Lancaster, OHTwo Squishmallow Lot Two Squishmallow Lot $30Columbus, OHsquishmallows squishmallows $40Lancaster, OHsquishmallow lot squishmallow lot $60Lancaster, OHDaisy Duck House Of Mouse Vintage McDonald’s Plush Toy 2001Daisy Duck House Of Mouse Vintage McDonald’s Plush Toy 2001$5Dublin, OHGoofy House Of Mouse Vintage McDonald’s Plush Toy 2001Goofy House Of Mouse Vintage McDonald’s Plush Toy 2001$5Dublin, OHHello Kitty PlushieHello Kitty Plushie$50Gardena, CAPluto House Of Mouse Vintage McDonald’s Plush Toy 2001Pluto House Of Mouse Vintage McDonald’s Plush Toy 2001$5Dublin, OHMickey Mouse Vintage Applause 8” PlushMickey Mouse Vintage Applause 8” Plush$10Dublin, OHMickey Mouse I Love USA Vintage Plush Disney StoreMickey Mouse I Love USA Vintage Plush Disney Store$10Dublin, OHMickey Mouse Diving Vintage 9” Plush Walt Disney WorldMickey Mouse Diving Vintage 9” Plush Walt Disney World$15Dublin, OHMickey Mouse Racing Team #28 Vintage Plush Walt Disney WorldMickey Mouse Racing Team #28 Vintage Plush Walt Disney World$10Dublin, OHDisney’s Port Orleans Resort Bellhop Mickey Mouse Vintage 9” Plush Walt Disney WorldDisney’s Port Orleans Resort Bellhop Mickey Mouse Vintage 9” Plush Walt Disney World$15Dublin, OHFrontierland Mickey Mouse Vintage Plush Walt Disney WorldFrontierland Mickey Mouse Vintage Plush Walt Disney World$10Dublin, OHTomorrowland Mickey Mouse Vintage Plush Walt Disney WorldTomorrowland Mickey Mouse Vintage Plush Walt Disney World$25Dublin, OHMickey Mouse Animal Kingdom Construction Rare Vintage Plush Walt Disney World 1997Mickey Mouse Animal Kingdom Construction Rare Vintage Plush Walt Disney World 1997$40Dublin, OHDanDee Jumbo FROG Kiss Red Heart Prince Green Valentines Classics Plush AnimalDanDee Jumbo FROG Kiss Red Heart Prince Green Valentines Classics Plush Animal$19Portland, OR4 Vintage 1986 Wendy's Furskins Plush Bears Dudley, Hattie, Farrell, Boone4 Vintage 1986 Wendy's Furskins Plush Bears Dudley, Hattie, Farrell, Boone$50Amanda, OHKohls Care Disney 101 Dalmatians Spot Dog Puppy Plushie PlushKohls Care Disney 101 Dalmatians Spot Dog Puppy Plushie Plush$15Galloway, OHChocolate The MooseChocolate The Moose$15Delaware, OH2021 Raising Canes Peanuts Plush Puppy 2021 Raising Canes Peanuts Plush Puppy $15Galloway, OHVintage Disney Plush Lot Mickey Mouse & More! PLEASE READ DESCRIPTION! Vintage Disney Plush Lot Mickey Mouse & More! PLEASE READ DESCRIPTION! $120Dublin, OHAssorted Stuffed AnimalsAssorted Stuffed Animals$3Delaware, OHStuffed Animal Care Bear Cheer BearStuffed Animal Care Bear Cheer Bear$20Columbus, OHPINK/ Victoria's Secret Set Of Two Stuffed DogsPINK/ Victoria's Secret Set Of Two Stuffed Dogs$15Obetz, OHBuild A Bear Scooby Doo 14” Collectible PlushBuild A Bear Scooby Doo 14” Collectible Plush$45Jacksonville, FLBig White Goose Pillow Baby Doll Stuffed Animal Big White Goose Pillow Baby Doll Stuffed Animal $11Reynoldsburg, OHBuild A Bear Buddies Collectable 2015 Rainbow Cat With Dress 8"Build A Bear Buddies Collectable 2015 Rainbow Cat With Dress 8"$11Gahanna, OHBuild A Bear RETIRED The Loin King Young Nala 12" With Dress Build A Bear RETIRED The Loin King Young Nala 12" With Dress $12Gahanna, OHBulid A Bear Pawlette 15" Rabbit Bulid A Bear Pawlette 15" Rabbit $10Gahanna, OHStuffed AnimalStuffed Animal$5Commercial Point, OHPatrick Star - Ty Beanie Babies Patrick Star With Original TagsPatrick Star - Ty Beanie Babies Patrick Star With Original Tags$110Columbus, OHTy Teenie Beanies- 2004 Ronald Mcdonald The Bear Retired- Bag 6 of 12 Happy Meal 25 Year Anniversary Ty Teenie Beanies- 2004 Ronald Mcdonald The Bear Retired- Bag 6 of 12 Happy Meal 25 Year Anniversary $19Columbus, OHTy Beanie Babies Millennium The Bear Tag Errors-Limited Edition RareTy Beanie Babies Millennium The Bear Tag Errors-Limited Edition Rare$35Columbus, OHTy Beanie Babies Secret The Bear 2003 - Retired - Tag ErrorsTy Beanie Babies Secret The Bear 2003 - Retired - Tag Errors$10Columbus, OHKoropanda Big Plush White and Pink Fukuya ROUND 1 - Big - BRAND NEW NWTKoropanda Big Plush White and Pink Fukuya ROUND 1 - Big - BRAND NEW NWT$20Rosemead, CATy Beanie Babies Signature Bear 1999Ty Beanie Babies Signature Bear 1999$12Columbus, OHTy Beanie Babies Free The Eagle2004 Retired- Blue Chest- TY Storw Exclusive- Super Rare - 13 Generation Tush & SwingTag - one owner - MAke an OFFERTy Beanie Babies Free The Eagle2004 Retired- Blue Chest- TY Storw Exclusive- Super Rare - 13 Generation Tush & SwingTag - one owner - MAke an OFFER$55Columbus, OHTy Beanie Babies 2002 Champion The World Cup Bear Korea/Japan - United States BeTy Beanie Babies 2002 Champion The World Cup Bear Korea/Japan - United States Be$13Columbus, OHTy Beanie Babies 1999 Scaly The Monitor LizardTy Beanie Babies 1999 Scaly The Monitor Lizard$13Columbus, OHVintage Care Bear Wish Bear Shooting Star 2003 9” W Secret Velcro StashVintage Care Bear Wish Bear Shooting Star 2003 9” W Secret Velcro Stash$45Columbus, OHComplete NEW set of Ty Teenie Beanie Babies and Animal Kingdom.Complete NEW set of Ty Teenie Beanie Babies and Animal Kingdom.$12Columbus, OH