No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Vintage 1983 HAPPY TALK SPRITES ROMEO Stuffed Animal TACO BELL PLUSH TOYVintage 1983 HAPPY TALK SPRITES ROMEO Stuffed Animal TACO BELL PLUSH TOY$18Arroyo Grande, CASpongeBob Plush Toy SpongeBob Plush Toy $12Grover Beach, CAHugging BunniesPromotedHugging Bunnies$60Murphy, NCSpongeBob Squarepants Plush SpongeBob Squarepants Plush $8Grover Beach, CADora The Explore Books And Plush BagDora The Explore Books And Plush Bag$20Tolleson, AZSymbolically Adopt A Giant Elephant Plush$250.00Symbolically Adopt A Giant Elephant PlushWWF GiftsAdVarious Christmas Stuffed AnimalsVarious Christmas Stuffed Animals$20Nipomo, CAWearable reindeerWearable reindeer$50Nipomo, CA Coach Stuffed Dog OBOPromoted Coach Stuffed Dog OBO$250Oak Harbor, WAEaster Vending Machine BasketsEaster Vending Machine Baskets$35Atascadero, CACinnamoroll Jumbo Fluffy Plush - 24"Cinnamoroll Jumbo Fluffy Plush - 24"$120San Luis Obispo, CAMy Melody Jumbo Fluffy Plush - 24"My Melody Jumbo Fluffy Plush - 24"$120San Luis Obispo, CASymbolically Adopt A Grizzly Bear$60.00Symbolically Adopt A Grizzly BearWWF GiftsAdTY International Bears IIPromotedTY International Bears II$300Vaucluse, SCSanrio Plushies (Individually Priced)Sanrio Plushies (Individually Priced)$60San Luis Obispo, CAAquatic Animals Aquatic Animals $15Nipomo, CARandom Plushies (Individually Priced)Random Plushies (Individually Priced)$120San Luis Obispo, CAGarfield Stuffed Animal Vintage 1980sGarfield Stuffed Animal Vintage 1980s$10Pismo Beach, CAJellyCat fox 🦊 PromotedJellyCat fox 🦊 $23Colorado Springs, COFree Infant Plush Cuddlers With Donation$60.00Free Infant Plush Cuddlers With DonationWWF GiftsAdSQUISHMALLOWS 16 Inch Mushroom “UNAI” Purple Polk-a-Dot New With Tags KellyToySQUISHMALLOWS 16 Inch Mushroom “UNAI” Purple Polk-a-Dot New With Tags KellyToy$25Arroyo Grande, CASun Point “Kiss” Puppy Dog Plush Stuffed Dachshund Weiner Dog Sun Point “Kiss” Puppy Dog Plush Stuffed Dachshund Weiner Dog $25Arroyo Grande, CAFinger Puppets Finger Puppets $5Nipomo, CAPikachu Plushy Backpack 🫶🏼PromotedPikachu Plushy Backpack 🫶🏼$12Claremont, CASquishmallow PillowSquishmallow Pillow$35Nipomo, CAValentine BearsValentine Bears$30Los Osos, CASymbolically Adopt A Snowy Owl$60.00Symbolically Adopt A Snowy OwlWWF GiftsAdpokemon squishmallow togepi and snorlax pokemon center exclusivespokemon squishmallow togepi and snorlax pokemon center exclusives$80Arroyo Grande, CASoft Fluffy Pumpkin Plush ToySoft Fluffy Pumpkin Plush Toy$16Arroyo Grande, CAHUGE 20" Squishmallow Grogu Yoda Star Wars The Child Plush Mandalorian JumboHUGE 20" Squishmallow Grogu Yoda Star Wars The Child Plush Mandalorian Jumbo$50Morro Bay, CASafari BuddiesSafari Buddies$10Nipomo, CASt Patrick's BearsSt Patrick's Bears$15Los Osos, CAHello Kitty PlushiesHello Kitty Plushies$20Nipomo, CASymbolically Adopt A Giraffe$60.00Symbolically Adopt A GiraffeWWF GiftsAdVintage Teddy Bear Happy Toys Reddish Brown Plush Rubber face 1950 Cubbi Gund Vintage Teddy Bear Happy Toys Reddish Brown Plush Rubber face 1950 Cubbi Gund $50San Luis Obispo, CATsum Tsum Holiday Collection 2017Tsum Tsum Holiday Collection 2017$35Atascadero, CAVintage Plush AnimalsVintage Plush Animals$5San Luis Obispo, CA24 Inch Ingred Giant Purple Cow Squishmallow24 Inch Ingred Giant Purple Cow Squishmallow$85Arroyo Grande, CAToddler Bear Toddler Bear $5Grover Beach, CAEaster BasketEaster Basket$20Nipomo, CARhino Art Plush With Your WWF Donation$60.00Rhino Art Plush With Your WWF DonationWWF GiftsAdTalking elfTalking elf$15Nipomo, CAGrogu Plush Grogu Plush $25San Luis Obispo, CACarebear Hoodie Collection Carebear Hoodie Collection $30Chicago, ILPokémon PlushiesPokémon Plushies$12Nipomo, CASleeping Flareon Poké Plush - 15 ½ InSleeping Flareon Poké Plush - 15 ½ In$50San Luis Obispo, CAVintage 1997 Star Wars Plush Toys And Beanies And More!Vintage 1997 Star Wars Plush Toys And Beanies And More!$10Nipomo, CAWarmies Lavender Scented Marshmallow Bear$24.99Warmies Lavender Scented Marshmallow BearPlay Therapy SupplyAdTeddy BearTeddy Bear$10Atascadero, CAMy Pal Scout My Pal Scout $30Arroyo Grande, CAVintage Avon talk to me teddy bearVintage Avon talk to me teddy bear$18Grover Beach, CATy Mcdonalds Beanie Monkey Millenium Edition 2000Ty Mcdonalds Beanie Monkey Millenium Edition 2000$20Pismo Beach, CAMellisa& Doug plush giraffeMellisa& Doug plush giraffe$45Atascadero, CANew Build A Bear Workshop Holloween Trick Or Treat Candy BagNew Build A Bear Workshop Holloween Trick Or Treat Candy Bag$8Atascadero, CAH A W A I I A N P U N C H Talking Plushie DollH A W A I I A N P U N C H Talking Plushie Doll$40Phoenix, AZToddler Bear Paw And Mitten SetToddler Bear Paw And Mitten Set$15San Luis Obispo, CA