No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Big Sloth Stuffed Animal Big Sloth Stuffed Animal $20Cheshire, CTBig Owl Stuffed AnimalBig Owl Stuffed Animal$20Cheshire, CTBig Dog Stuffed AnimalBig Dog Stuffed Animal$20Cheshire, CTBuild A Bear: "Happy Birthday" (2021 Edition) *TRADE IN YOUR OLD GAMES/TCG/COMICS/PHONES/VHS FOR CSH OR CREDIT HERE*Build A Bear: "Happy Birthday" (2021 Edition) *TRADE IN YOUR OLD GAMES/TCG/COMICS/PHONES/VHS FOR CSH OR CREDIT HERE*$14Montclair, CAStuffed AnimalsStuffed Animals$5Middle Island, NYVintage & Rare 1980 R Dakin Stuffed Dragon with Wings Plush Stuffed Animal 24”Vintage & Rare 1980 R Dakin Stuffed Dragon with Wings Plush Stuffed Animal 24”$18Middle Island, NYLarge Bin Of Miscellaneous Stuffed Animals And MoreLarge Bin Of Miscellaneous Stuffed Animals And More$1Holbrook, NYVintage Stuffed Animals (Disney, Marvel, SpongeBob, More)Vintage Stuffed Animals (Disney, Marvel, SpongeBob, More)$75Syosset, NY**Stuffed Animals**Stuffed Animals$10Wading River, NYHello Kitty x Care BearsHello Kitty x Care Bears$45Medford, NYGolden Bear Stand BagGolden Bear Stand Bag$40Port Jeff Sta, NYBearsBears$45Ridge, NYSquishmallow Squishmallow $5North Branford, CTCare Bear Sanrio Keychain Care Bear Sanrio Keychain $15Los Angeles, CASquishmallow NWTSquishmallow NWT$20North Branford, CTSquishmallow Corgis Squishmallow Corgis $10Commack, NYSquishmallow Flip Squishmallow Flip $9Commack, NYSquishmallow Husky DogSquishmallow Husky Dog$16Commack, NYSquishmallow Unicorn Squishmallow Unicorn $16Commack, NYSquishmallow YetiSquishmallow Yeti$25Commack, NYBeanie BabyBeanie Baby$115New Haven, CTSnoopy And Woodstock PlushSnoopy And Woodstock Plush$10Waterbury, CTHorror Film Pillow Horror Film Pillow $10Syosset, NYDisney Classics 14-Inch Mickey Mouse, Comfort Weighted Plush Animals for Kids SeDisney Classics 14-Inch Mickey Mouse, Comfort Weighted Plush Animals for Kids Se$17Pattison, TXBison Plush Eco Nation 5 In Plush Toy Mini SizeBison Plush Eco Nation 5 In Plush Toy Mini Size$9Ansonia, CTBenjamin Bear Stuffed Brown Bear 12 InBenjamin Bear Stuffed Brown Bear 12 In$11Ansonia, CTLeonardo Stuffed AnimalLeonardo Stuffed Animal$12Southbury, CTMichelangelo Stuffed AnimalMichelangelo Stuffed Animal$12Southbury, CTDonatello Stuffed AnimalDonatello Stuffed Animal$12Southbury, CTNew Pokemon PlushNew Pokemon Plush$30East Haven, CTDonkey Kong Bean Bag 6” Plush Mario Nintendo BD&A Vintage 1997Donkey Kong Bean Bag 6” Plush Mario Nintendo BD&A Vintage 1997$20Milford, CTPokémon Pikachu Plush 9” Fat Stuffed Plush Vintage No TagPokémon Pikachu Plush 9” Fat Stuffed Plush Vintage No Tag$41Milford, CTKiss PillowKiss Pillow$40Phoenix, AZScooby-doo Stuffed AnimalScooby-doo Stuffed Animal$12Southbury, CTLostBoys BeanieLostBoys Beanie$20Brentwood, NYPlush Turtle / Indoor Snowball Fight Plush Turtle / Indoor Snowball Fight $11West Haven, CTHOPE TY Beanie Baby Praying Bear WITH TAG ERRORSHOPE TY Beanie Baby Praying Bear WITH TAG ERRORS$400Bridgeport, CTWestcliff Collection Pink Standing Bunny Rabbit Plush Stuffed Animal Easter Westcliff Collection Pink Standing Bunny Rabbit Plush Stuffed Animal Easter $40New Haven, CTStuffed Animals Key Chains Stuffed Animals Key Chains $5Kings Park, NYVintage Swibco Puffkins Jules the FishVintage Swibco Puffkins Jules the Fish$7Selden, NYVintage Puffkins Danny the DinosaurVintage Puffkins Danny the Dinosaur$7Selden, NYVintage Swibco Puffkins Skylar the BearVintage Swibco Puffkins Skylar the Bear$7Selden, NYHello KittyHello Kitty$45San Bernardino, CAVintage Swibco Puffkins 2000 Mystic WizardVintage Swibco Puffkins 2000 Mystic Wizard$7Selden, NYVintage Puffkins Omar the OrangutanVintage Puffkins Omar the Orangutan$7Selden, NYVintage Puffkins Amber the MonkeyVintage Puffkins Amber the Monkey$7Selden, NYVTG Puffkins Jack the Jack-O-Lantern Limited EditionVTG Puffkins Jack the Jack-O-Lantern Limited Edition$7Selden, NYVTG (1999) Puffkins Limited Edition Patches the ScarecrowVTG (1999) Puffkins Limited Edition Patches the Scarecrow$7Selden, NY2 Emoji Plushies 2 Emoji Plushies $10Norwalk, CTI Love You White Bear PlushI Love You White Bear Plush$5Norwalk, CT