Stuffed animals & Plush
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
ty beanie babies mcdonalds international bears Osito, Spangle, and Germania$50Plainville, CT
Squishmallows Bigfoot collection$200New Britain, CT
Plushie B-Day Bundle $0New Haven, CT
Webkinz Zumbuddy 1st Edition New$18East Haven, CT
ET New From Disney Studios$22East Haven, CT
Vintage Steiff Suzanne Gibson 1984 Goldilocks 3 Bears. Limited Edition Set$300Coventry, CT
2005 SEGA Sonic The Hedgehog Plush$125Vernon Rockvl, CT
Dragonair Pokémon Plush$30Vernon Rockvl, CT
Giant Plush Dog (Dave & Buster’s Prize) – Huge & Great for Room Decor$60Naugatuck, CT
Sally Big Plush$8Meriden, CT
microwavable warming stuffed animal named “Toadie.”$15Southington, CT
Mickey Mouse Plush$20Vernon Rockvl, CT
Goofy Puppet$10Vernon Rockvl, CT
Like New Bluey Kids' 16" Plush Backpack$15North Branford, CT
Giant Teddy Bear $20$20New Britain, CT
Pokémon UMBREON & ESPEON Sleeping Plush Jazwares 2026 18" NWTs NEW$120Middletown, CT
Hatchimal Collectibles Deal$10Naugatuck, CT
Hatchimal Collectible$5Naugatuck, CT
Hatchimal Collectible $5Naugatuck, CT
Hatchimal Collectible $2Naugatuck, CT
Hatchimal Collectible$4Naugatuck, CT
New squishmallows basket$25East Hartford, CT
Hello kitty$30West Haven, CT
Maryland Crab Beanie $25West Haven, CT
Skye Stuffed Animal$15North Branford, CT
11 Plush Toy Mice for Sale$60Hartford, CT
HugMees by Original Squishmallows $10Hartford, CT
Authentic Aphmau "Under the Sea" red Lobster Cat plush.$15North Branford, CT
Disney Squishmallows 20" JUMBO Oogie Boogie - The Nightmare Before Christmas $45West Haven, CT
HELLO KITTY$15Waterbury, CT
Among us plushie$9Waterbury, CT
Fnaf plushie$10Waterbury, CT
Fnaf plushie$9Waterbury, CT
Fnaf plushie$13Waterbury, CT
Fnaf plushie$11Waterbury, CT
Demon slayer plushie$69Waterbury, CT
Anime plushie$14Waterbury, CT
Boyfriend fnf plushie$10Waterbury, CT
Bowser plushie$25Waterbury, CT
5ft Plush Giraffe$100North Haven, CT
Beanie Babies$30Cromwell, CT
Spangle Beanie Baby RARE !!!!$400Rocky Hill, CT
RARE BEANIE BABY KICKS BEAR $400Rocky Hill, CT
Twigs Beanie Baby $250Wethersfield, CT
Wooden Easter bunny$25Meriden, CT
Cinnamon Roll Plushie$25New Britain, CT
Plushies (different Kinds)$80Hartford, CT
Marshmallow Stuffie$10Avon, CT
Large Stuffed Animal Pillow- Kids $17Southington, CT
Large Gray Plush Elephant Pillow/Toy With Sound$17Southington, CT