No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Plushies

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Brand New Pikachu Plushie Brand New Pikachu Plushie $20Wolcott, CTBeanie Babies McDonald's "Hamburgler The Bear""Antsy The Anteater""Osito The Bear"Beanie Babies McDonald's "Hamburgler The Bear""Antsy The Anteater""Osito The Bear"$21Wolcott, CTPikachu Plushy Backpack 🫶🏼PromotedPikachu Plushy Backpack 🫶🏼$12Claremont, CATY Beanie Babies 2000's "Squirmy The Worm"TY Beanie Babies 2000's "Squirmy The Worm"$12Waterbury, CTNew Pikachu In A Rayquaza Costume Pokemon PlushNew Pikachu In A Rayquaza Costume Pokemon Plush$15Fillmore, CAChicago Cubs Wubbanub Bear Plush And Pacifier$19.99Chicago Cubs Wubbanub Bear Plush And PacifierMLB ShopAdGanz Webkinz Tie Dye Bean Plush with Tag ( New )Ganz Webkinz Tie Dye Bean Plush with Tag ( New )$11Waterbury, CTRare Aurora Cotton Candies Pink Plush Dog Toy Med Sized Stuffed Animal Soft 9"Rare Aurora Cotton Candies Pink Plush Dog Toy Med Sized Stuffed Animal Soft 9"$28New Haven, CTPurple Gengar Plushie PromotedPurple Gengar Plushie $60Santa Clarita, CASnorlax Plushie Snorlax Plushie $10Wolcott, CTNew Shadow plushie New Shadow plushie $10Wolcott, CTTy Beanie Boos - ROSETTE the Purple Unicorn (6 Inch) Stuffed Plush AnimalTy Beanie Boos - ROSETTE the Purple Unicorn (6 Inch) Stuffed Plush Animal$21New Haven, CTNew York Yankees Wubbanub Puppy Plush And Pacifier$19.99New York Yankees Wubbanub Puppy Plush And PacifierMLB ShopAdBeanie Babies Ty(includes Patti The Platypus And Chocolate The Moose)PromotedBeanie Babies Ty(includes Patti The Platypus And Chocolate The Moose)$499Buckeye, AZTY Beanie Babies "Iggy The Iguana 1993"-"Bushy The Lion 2000"-"L' Amore The Poodle 2002"TY Beanie Babies "Iggy The Iguana 1993"-"Bushy The Lion 2000"-"L' Amore The Poodle 2002"$19Waterbury, CTBeanie Babies McDonald's Fry The Bear 2004-Neon The Seahorse 1999Beanie Babies McDonald's Fry The Bear 2004-Neon The Seahorse 1999$24Waterbury, CTThe Petting Zoo Bean bag Plush Sea Turtle with Pocket (No Baby) 14” LongThe Petting Zoo Bean bag Plush Sea Turtle with Pocket (No Baby) 14” Long$29New Haven, CTDan Dee Plush Horse Beanbag Light Brown pony Stuffed Animal 7"Dan Dee Plush Horse Beanbag Light Brown pony Stuffed Animal 7"$15New Haven, CTIron Man Crochet PlushiePromotedIron Man Crochet Plushie$45San Diego, CABoston Red Sox Wubbanub Bear Plush And Pacifier$19.99Boston Red Sox Wubbanub Bear Plush And PacifierMLB ShopAdTy Beanie Jack the white bear with british flags all over himTy Beanie Jack the white bear with british flags all over him$25New Haven, CTAurora Farrah Brown Spotted Flopsie Deer Fawn Laying Down Beanie Plush Aurora Farrah Brown Spotted Flopsie Deer Fawn Laying Down Beanie Plush $38New Haven, CTCrochet Zoro PlushieCrochet Zoro Plushie$20Naugatuck, CTCrochet Sanji PlushieCrochet Sanji Plushie$20Naugatuck, CTCrochet One Piece Plushies Set of 3Crochet One Piece Plushies Set of 3$50New Haven, CTAnimeNYC Exclusive Set Of 4 One Piece PlushiesAnimeNYC Exclusive Set Of 4 One Piece Plushies$50New Haven, CTPlush Gear Buddy The Bulldog Plush Toy - 16-Inch Brown Bulldog, Soft & Huggable Gift For Kids, Baby Showers, Birthday$20.79Plush Gear Buddy The Bulldog Plush Toy - 16-Inch Brown Bulldog, Soft & Huggable Gift For Kids, Baby Showers, BirthdayAmazon.comAdBoba PlushieBoba Plushie$15Shelton, CTCrochet One Piece Nami And Robin Crochet One Piece Nami And Robin $30Naugatuck, CTTeeTurtle Reversible Plushies Black Gray Octopus Plushie Snowflake Cloud FidgetTeeTurtle Reversible Plushies Black Gray Octopus Plushie Snowflake Cloud Fidget$16New Haven, CTCrochet Cow Plushie (Choose Color) Crochet Cow Plushie (Choose Color) $15Naugatuck, CTBag Full Plushies Bag Full Plushies $10Ocean City, WAPlushies Plushies $7Durham, NCNasidear 32 Pack Mini Animal Plush Toy Party Favors,Small Plush Stuffed Animals For Birthday,Theme Party,Easter Basket Stuffers Fillers,Christmas$18.98Nasidear 32 Pack Mini Animal Plush Toy Party Favors,Small Plush Stuffed Animals For Birthday,Theme Party,Easter Basket Stuffers Fillers,ChristmasAmazon.comAdGiant Crochet Bunny Giant Crochet Bunny $50Naugatuck, CTTY Beanie Baby - OLAF the Snowman Sparkle With SANTA HAT (Frozen Movie) Medium 7" Plush TY Beanie Baby - OLAF the Snowman Sparkle With SANTA HAT (Frozen Movie) Medium 7" Plush $20New Haven, CT6 Rare Christmas Beanie Boos Plushies6 Rare Christmas Beanie Boos Plushies$40East Haven, CTCrochet One Piece Tony Tony Chopper PlushieCrochet One Piece Tony Tony Chopper Plushie$15Naugatuck, CTGiant 44” vintage Sylvester plushy Giant 44” vintage Sylvester plushy $200Orange, CTTy Beanie Boos - Fiona The Pink Cat bean bag Plush Big Wide Eyes (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 Inch) Ty Beanie Boos - Fiona The Pink Cat bean bag Plush Big Wide Eyes (Glitter Eyes)(Regular Size - 6 Inch) $12New Haven, CTMallo Mallo Mini Collectible 3-Inch Plush Stuffed Animals, Blind Collectible 3-Pack, Kids Toys For Ages 3 Up By Just Play$8.05Mallo Mallo Mini Collectible 3-Inch Plush Stuffed Animals, Blind Collectible 3-Pack, Kids Toys For Ages 3 Up By Just PlayAmazon.comAdHello Kitty plushHello Kitty plush$10New Haven, CTFNAF BundleFNAF Bundle$20West Haven, CTTY Whopper Elephant 5.5in Plush Toy Sparkle EyesTY Whopper Elephant 5.5in Plush Toy Sparkle Eyes$17New Haven, CTTY Beanie Baby 2.0 “Cricket” the Grey and White Cat bean bag Plush! *Rare* (6 inch) TY Beanie Baby 2.0 “Cricket” the Grey and White Cat bean bag Plush! *Rare* (6 inch) $21New Haven, CTDisney Store PLUSH 14" THUMPER with blue ribbon Rabbit Bambi Movie! RARE!!!Disney Store PLUSH 14" THUMPER with blue ribbon Rabbit Bambi Movie! RARE!!!$44New Haven, CTCrochet Small Iron Man PlushyCrochet Small Iron Man Plushy$10Naugatuck, CTSakuties Mini Collectible Stylized Plush Stuffed Animals, (Pack Of 3) Blind Collectible, Kids Toys For Ages 3 Up By Just Play$11.90Sakuties Mini Collectible Stylized Plush Stuffed Animals, (Pack Of 3) Blind Collectible, Kids Toys For Ages 3 Up By Just PlayAmazon.comAdCrochet Large Iron Man PlushyCrochet Large Iron Man Plushy$15Naugatuck, CTCrochet Axolotl (choose Color) Crochet Axolotl (choose Color) $10Naugatuck, CT