Stuffed animals
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
Vintage Audi 1983 Dakin Posh Stuffed Animal 10.5” Tall From The Garfield Cartoon$16Commack, NY
Emrad Creations, Inc. Plush Tiger Seasonal Sensations Kiss Me, 13” Tall$15Smithtown, NY
Ty Beanie, Boo Named Brutus, A Plus Toy Dog Resembling A Boxer8” Tall New$20Smithtown, NY
Avon 2015 Holiday Plush Teddy Bear Still Sealed In Its Original Plastic Packaging$20Smithtown, NY
Giraffe Stuffed Animal Almost 5 Ft$35The Bronx, NY
Fun 2 play Toys POO-NICORNS 14" PLUSH EMOJI POO UNICORN HORN WITH RAINBOW HAIR NEON BLUE, Cute!$14New Haven, CT
NO-FRILLS 6” BEAR in Original Packaging $25Peekskill, NY
1987 ABEARHAM & STRAUS THE MOUSE PLUSH TEDDY BEAR A&S VINTAGE EXCLUSIVE CHRISTMAS$50East Meadow, NY
Pokemon Plush $500Great Nck Plz, NY
Ty Beanie Baby Wise The Owl 1997 With Tag Class of 1998$20Bridgeport, CT
Ty Beanie Baby Seaweed The Otter With Tags $15Bridgeport, CT
Ty Beanie Babies Lizzy The Lizard 1995 $15Bridgeport, CT
Ty Beanie Baby Rover the Red Dog With Tags 1996$15Bridgeport, CT
WRINKLES Ty Beanie Baby in case $90Bridgeport, CT
ET Stuffed Animal Handmade In Korea 1982$25Milford, CT
Millennial BEAR with Vest$20Milford, CT
Easter Mint Green Bashful Bunny Rabbit Floppy Ears With Brown Polka Dot Bow 9in$21New Haven, CT
TY TyLux Pluffies TipTop Giraffe 8in Beanbag Plush Toy Cuddly Lovey Stuffed Animal 2012 $25New Haven, CT
Peeps Bunny Rabbit Blue Easter Plush Stuffed Animal Large 17”$32New Haven, CT
Kawaii Alpaca Lama Arpakasso Plush Doll Gifts Nice Child Stuffed Animal 9.5in$25New Haven, CT
2015 Dreamworks TROLLS Hasbro 11.5" plush long neck Cooper stuffed toy$35New Haven, CT
Paw Patrol Marshall $5Valhalla, NY
TY MAJESTIC the Pink SEAHORSE BEANIE BABY no tag$15New Haven, CT
Squeezamals “Nellie The Narwhal” Around Plush Stuffed Animal Squish Stress Ball 3.5in$19New Haven, CT
Ty millenium The Bear $5Milford, CT
Black Skeleton Bear Bag / back pack 14 inch$20Bridgeport, CT
Ross Barrie Clip On Bride Groom 3.5 Inch$5Smithtown, NY
Emotional Support Strawberries by Relatable, Cuddly Stuffed Animals and Toys, Squishy Toys and Plushies, Great Gift Ideas for Loved Ones of All Ages, $15Garden City P, NY
2003 Plushland, Waddles The Duck March Of Dime Plush Toy With Tags$9Saint James, NY
Beanie Babies$10Trumbull, CT
mty international 18" Large Floppy Frog Valentine Plush Green Stuffed Animal$38New Haven, CT
Wild Republic white arctic wolf Christmas Holiday beanie Soft Stuffed Animal 16"$28New Haven, CT
Disney The Lion King Simba Cub Plush 11”Jointed move Stuffed Toy Broadway Musical.$75New Haven, CT
Beanie Babies $5Copiague, NY
Plush Toy Musical Bunny with Chicks$3Garden City South, NY
TY Flippables Sequin Plush - PIXY the Unicorn $20Holtsville, NY
The Toy Factory Brown Monkey Smooshimals Plush 5.5"$16The Bronx, NY
It’s a Boy Bear & My First Puppy$10Holtsville, NY
LIKE NEW!!! Yasmin the Hedgehog Squish doo$18Holtsville, NY
Just Play Disney Standard Pride Goofy & Pluto Plush Stuffed Animal $10Holtsville, NY
Dinosaur Large Plushie $7Saint James, NY
Teddy Bear NY Yankees $25Yonkers, NY
TY Beanie Babies ~ Loosy The Canadian Goose ~1998 no tag
9in$21New Haven, CT
DanDee Cuddle Toys fluffy Brown Puppy Dog Plush floppy ear Stuffed Animal 12in$21New Haven, CT
1987 The Fabulous Talking, Teddy, Yellow Teddy Bear With Light Up Heart Made By Emson Tested And Works$25Smithtown, NY
Huge Hello Kitty$15Woodbury, NY
Kohl's Cares 11" Plush Unicorn Pink & Purple Blue Horn.Lovey fairy core
$15New Haven, CT
Paw Patrol Nickelodeon, Plush Rubble 7in Bull Dog Stuffed Animal$15New Haven, CT
PEZ Valentine's Day Candy Love Teddy Bear Plush 7in$15New Haven, CT
Vintage 1999 Disney Store Winnie the Pooh and Piglet Friendship Day bean bag plush set$15Alpine, NJ