No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Scan to download the app

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Big Dog Stuffed AnimalBig Dog Stuffed Animal$10Cheshire, CTBig Owl Stuffed AnimalBig Owl Stuffed Animal$10Cheshire, CTBig Sloth Stuffed Animal Big Sloth Stuffed Animal $10Cheshire, CTFive nights at Freddy plushie Five nights at Freddy plushie $40Vista, CAStuffed Animal Wall DecorationStuffed Animal Wall Decoration$20Bethel, CTBoyds Bears Eloise Willoughby 918402 Small Plush Stuffed Animal Retired Red Hat Boyds Bears Eloise Willoughby 918402 Small Plush Stuffed Animal Retired Red Hat $9East Haven, CTThree Minions Stuffed Plush Animals.Three Minions Stuffed Plush Animals.$13Rocky Hill, CTstuffed animals for sale!stuffed animals for sale!$20New Haven, CTLarge Stuffed Animal Pillow Large Stuffed Animal Pillow $17Southington, CTNew Pokemon PlushNew Pokemon Plush$40East Haven, CTStuff Animals Stuff Animals $5Waterbury, CTBearsBears$0Orange, CT"Justice" Pet Shop Stuffed Animal Toy"Justice" Pet Shop Stuffed Animal Toy$18Southington, CTAmong Us Plushies Among Us Plushies $20Vista, CAStar From Disney’s Wish movieStar From Disney’s Wish movie$15Meriden, CTLittle BearLittle Bear$7Berlin, CTTY Beanie Babies Spunky The Cocker Spaniel Dog TY Beanie Babies Spunky The Cocker Spaniel Dog $18Berlin, CTTy Beanie Babies Lot of 3Ty Beanie Babies Lot of 3$125Wolcott, CTunicorn plushunicorn plush$40New Haven, CTBee Stuffed Animal (Stuffie)Bee Stuffed Animal (Stuffie)$2New Britain, CTHello Kitty PlushHello Kitty Plush$10Meriden, CTHello Kitty JibitsHello Kitty Jibits$0Meriden, CTLIV MORGAN PLUSHLIV MORGAN PLUSH$5Meriden, CTMonster Jam Jumbo Grave Digger Plush Stuffed Wicked Cool Toys Truck SoftMonster Jam Jumbo Grave Digger Plush Stuffed Wicked Cool Toys Truck Soft$27Vancouver, WASmokie The BearSmokie The Bear$11East Haven, CT5" Baby Yoda Grogu Playing With Ball Plush With Hanger5" Baby Yoda Grogu Playing With Ball Plush With Hanger$10Southington, CT**Stuffed Animals**Stuffed Animals$10Wading River, NYOriginal Gengar Squishmellow 10 InchOriginal Gengar Squishmellow 10 Inch$30Waterbury, CT3 Build A Bear With 5 Outfits3 Build A Bear With 5 Outfits$65Middletown, CTPlushy Stuffed Animals. Logo ..Harley Davidson Motorcycle Logo Bulldogs. $4-&9 Each . Plushy Stuffed Animals. Logo ..Harley Davidson Motorcycle Logo Bulldogs. $4-&9 Each . $9Wolcott, CTSpider Man Pillow Spider Man Pillow $7North Branford, CTPaw Patrol Pillow Paw Patrol Pillow $7North Branford, CTSquid game plushSquid game plush$7Vista, CATy Beanie Baby - LEFTY 2000 the Donkey (6 Inch) MINT with MINT TAGSTy Beanie Baby - LEFTY 2000 the Donkey (6 Inch) MINT with MINT TAGS$8Waterbury, CTVarious TY Beanie Boos/BabiesVarious TY Beanie Boos/Babies$5Portland, CTLIKE NEW Justice League plush charactersLIKE NEW Justice League plush characters$4Meriden, CTHello Kitty Hello Kitty $15Bridgeport, CTWestcliff Collection Pink Standing Bunny Rabbit Plush Stuffed Animal Easter Westcliff Collection Pink Standing Bunny Rabbit Plush Stuffed Animal Easter $40New Haven, CTSquishmallow Squishmallow $5North Branford, CTSquishmallow NWTSquishmallow NWT$20North Branford, CTTY BEANIE BABY WOODPECKER & FRIENDSTY BEANIE BABY WOODPECKER & FRIENDS$450Brookfield, CTHoliday Stuffed Animal Plushies Christmas Gift New Vintage(large Is Singing Dog)$4-$9 Each Holiday Stuffed Animal Plushies Christmas Gift New Vintage(large Is Singing Dog)$4-$9 Each $9Wolcott, CTSpider-Man plushSpider-Man plush$10Vista, CAPlush Animal Toys (8)Plush Animal Toys (8)$15Southington, CTGray Plush Elephant- with sounds- toyGray Plush Elephant- with sounds- toy$15Southington, CTShopkins Miss Pressy Pillow- toyShopkins Miss Pressy Pillow- toy$14Southington, CTDream Lites Pillow PetDream Lites Pillow Pet$16Southington, CTGIANT PENGUIN🐧🐧GIANT PENGUIN🐧🐧$50New Haven, CTSquishmallows for sale!!Squishmallows for sale!!$15New Haven, CTSnoopy And Woodstock PlushSnoopy And Woodstock Plush$10Waterbury, CT