No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Aurora World Destination Nation Frosted Pink Penguin Plush 12” Stuffed AnimalAurora World Destination Nation Frosted Pink Penguin Plush 12” Stuffed Animal$22S Harrisn Township, NJGorilla Plush Destination Nation Aurora 2022 Black Realistic Looking Stuffed Animal 11"Gorilla Plush Destination Nation Aurora 2022 Black Realistic Looking Stuffed Animal 11"$20S Harrisn Township, NJSafari Stuffed AnimalsPromotedSafari Stuffed Animals$20Bellflower, CAPlush Gund Jungle Wonders Elephant stuffed Animal Plush Gund Jungle Wonders Elephant stuffed Animal $21S Harrisn Township, NJTy Beanie Babies Kingston 1993 Vintage Plush King of Hearts Ty Beanie Babies Kingston 1993 Vintage Plush King of Hearts $49Portland, ORSymbolically Adopt A Giant Elephant Plush$250.00Symbolically Adopt A Giant Elephant PlushWWF GiftsAdVintage Mary Meyer Ponytail the Horse Stuffed Animal PlushVintage Mary Meyer Ponytail the Horse Stuffed Animal Plush$32S Harrisn Township, NJVintage Build A Bear Plush White Bear Pink Nose Stuffed Animal 1990sVintage Build A Bear Plush White Bear Pink Nose Stuffed Animal 1990s$22S Harrisn Township, NJCare Bears 9" Bean Plush (Glitter Belly) - Birthday Bear - Soft Huggable Material! No original boxPromotedCare Bears 9" Bean Plush (Glitter Belly) - Birthday Bear - Soft Huggable Material! No original box$15Orange, CAAurora World 14" Plush Cream Colored LlamaAurora World 14" Plush Cream Colored Llama$22S Harrisn Township, NJCarters Just One You Target Grey Shaggy Hippo Plush Stuffed Animal Baby Toy NWTCarters Just One You Target Grey Shaggy Hippo Plush Stuffed Animal Baby Toy NWT$70S Harrisn Township, NJVintage Build A Bear Smiley Monkey Chimp 18" Brown Tan Plush Stuffed AnimalVintage Build A Bear Smiley Monkey Chimp 18" Brown Tan Plush Stuffed Animal$13S Harrisn Township, NJBoston Red Sox Wubbanub Bear Plush And Pacifier$19.99Boston Red Sox Wubbanub Bear Plush And PacifierMLB ShopAdDisney Mickey And Minnie Mouse Christmas 2019PromotedDisney Mickey And Minnie Mouse Christmas 2019$45Queens, NYVintage Fisher Price Rabbit Stuffed Animal Plush Pink Hearts Fleece Bunny 1997Vintage Fisher Price Rabbit Stuffed Animal Plush Pink Hearts Fleece Bunny 1997$45S Harrisn Township, NJAnimal Adventure Pink Unicorn - 13" Plush Stuffed Animal Gold Horn 2021Animal Adventure Pink Unicorn - 13" Plush Stuffed Animal Gold Horn 2021$22S Harrisn Township, NJBuild-A-Bear White Blue Snowflake Teddy Bear 17" Winter Stuffed AnimalBuild-A-Bear White Blue Snowflake Teddy Bear 17" Winter Stuffed Animal$15S Harrisn Township, NJTy Classic Buckshot The Horse 12” Plush Stuffed Animal Tan/Brown/GrayTy Classic Buckshot The Horse 12” Plush Stuffed Animal Tan/Brown/Gray$18S Harrisn Township, NJValentine's Gift!!! USB LED Teddy Bear - NewPromotedValentine's Gift!!! USB LED Teddy Bear - New$45Houston, TXLos Angeles Dodgers Wubbanub Bear Plush And Pacifier$19.99Los Angeles Dodgers Wubbanub Bear Plush And PacifierMLB ShopAdFAO Schwarz 15" Pink Unicorn Plush Stuffed Animal with LED Lights & SoundsFAO Schwarz 15" Pink Unicorn Plush Stuffed Animal with LED Lights & Sounds$18S Harrisn Township, NJNala 8" Talking Plush Disney the Lion King Stuffed Animal with TagsNala 8" Talking Plush Disney the Lion King Stuffed Animal with Tags$18S Harrisn Township, NJGolden Retriever plush - Pre-owned by a collector Golden Retriever plush - Pre-owned by a collector $37S Harrisn Township, NJHugging BunniesPromotedHugging Bunnies$60Murphy, NCDisney-Pixar Talking Ducky Plush Stuffed Animal Pal - From Toy Story 4Disney-Pixar Talking Ducky Plush Stuffed Animal Pal - From Toy Story 4$13S Harrisn Township, NJThe Petting Zoo Alpaca Stuffed Animal Plushie, Gifts for Kids, Wild Onez Zoo Animals, Alpaca Plush ToyThe Petting Zoo Alpaca Stuffed Animal Plushie, Gifts for Kids, Wild Onez Zoo Animals, Alpaca Plush Toy$22S Harrisn Township, NJSymbolically Adopt A Giant Tortoise$60.00Symbolically Adopt A Giant TortoiseWWF GiftsAdDan Dee Collectors Choice Plush Black Poodle Puppy Dog Stuffed Animal Red BowsDan Dee Collectors Choice Plush Black Poodle Puppy Dog Stuffed Animal Red Bows$23S Harrisn Township, NJBedtime Originals Lavender Woods Plush Fox Stuffed Animal - Sly NWTBedtime Originals Lavender Woods Plush Fox Stuffed Animal - Sly NWT$24S Harrisn Township, NJPhiladelphia Phillies - Phillie Phanatic Plush Stuffed Animal Philadelphia Phillies - Phillie Phanatic Plush Stuffed Animal $28Drexel Hill, PA2010 Build-A-Bear BAB Lil' COCONUT CUB Cream 16" Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal BAB2010 Build-A-Bear BAB Lil' COCONUT CUB Cream 16" Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal BAB$22S Harrisn Township, NJDisneyland Walt Disney World 8" Chip & Dale Plush Chipmunk BrownDisneyland Walt Disney World 8" Chip & Dale Plush Chipmunk Brown$14Mickleton, NJTummy Stuffers Shark Clean-up Companion Snuggly Plush W/ Puppet Action - Large 18” oneTummy Stuffers Shark Clean-up Companion Snuggly Plush W/ Puppet Action - Large 18” one$48Mickleton, NJNew York Yankees Wubbanub Puppy Plush And Pacifier$19.99New York Yankees Wubbanub Puppy Plush And PacifierMLB ShopAdPokemon holiday Squirtle plush with ear muffs NWT 8 inchesPokemon holiday Squirtle plush with ear muffs NWT 8 inches$35Mickleton, NJBuild A Bear brown curly fur plush bear stuffed animal toyBuild A Bear brown curly fur plush bear stuffed animal toy$22S Harrisn Township, NJTy Teenie Beanie Babies International Bears 2Ty Teenie Beanie Babies International Bears 2$40Elsmere, DETY Teenie Beanie Babies TY Teenie Beanie Babies $20Elsmere, DETeenie Beanie Babies Dinosaur TrioTeenie Beanie Babies Dinosaur Trio$50Elsmere, DEVintage Jim Henson Muppets NWT Gonzo Chili Pepper Tie & Drummer Animal NancoVintage Jim Henson Muppets NWT Gonzo Chili Pepper Tie & Drummer Animal Nanco$75S Harrisn Township, NJ4Pcs-Mini Animal Plush Toy Assortment,Bulk Stuffed Animals Party Favors , Small Animals Plush Keychain Decoration, Carnival Prizes, Valentine's Day Party Favors,Backpack Pendants, Graduation Gifts, Holiday Gifts,4Pcs$1.924Pcs-Mini Animal Plush Toy Assortment,Bulk Stuffed Animals Party Favors , Small Animals Plush Keychain Decoration, Carnival Prizes, Valentine's Day Party Favors,Backpack Pendants, Graduation Gifts, Holiday Gifts,4PcssheinAdScentsy Buddy 15'' Patches St Bernard Dog Puppy Stuffed Plush Animal RetiredScentsy Buddy 15'' Patches St Bernard Dog Puppy Stuffed Plush Animal Retired$25S Harrisn Township, NJCarter’s Just One You White Fluffy Unicorn 12" Plush Stuffed Toy Sparkle HornCarter’s Just One You White Fluffy Unicorn 12" Plush Stuffed Toy Sparkle Horn$28S Harrisn Township, NJToy Factory Dorothy Wizard Of Oz Plush Toy Factory Dorothy Wizard Of Oz Plush $5Quartz Hill, CABuild A Bear Magic Quest Red Dragon Ellie 15" Plush Great Wolf Lodge ExclusiveBuild A Bear Magic Quest Red Dragon Ellie 15" Plush Great Wolf Lodge Exclusive$14S Harrisn Township, NJDouglas Toys Plush Tyson Wolf Lexington Hotels, BandanaDouglas Toys Plush Tyson Wolf Lexington Hotels, Bandana$75S Harrisn Township, NJBuild a Bear Fire Breathing Dragon Retired - Gold WingsBuild a Bear Fire Breathing Dragon Retired - Gold Wings$17S Harrisn Township, NJGiant Teddy Bear Stuffed Animals Plush Toy Cute Life Size Big Plush Teddy Bear For Kids Girlfriend, Soft Stuffed Bear Animals,Grey,All-New,By Temu$50.49Giant Teddy Bear Stuffed Animals Plush Toy Cute Life Size Big Plush Teddy Bear For Kids Girlfriend, Soft Stuffed Bear Animals,Grey,All-New,By TemuTemu-US-LocalAdDisney Tsum Tsum Star Wars Yoda 12" Plush - Displayed OnlyDisney Tsum Tsum Star Wars Yoda 12" Plush - Displayed Only$10S Harrisn Township, NJGalerie Devil Costume Plush Bear with Original Paper TagsGalerie Devil Costume Plush Bear with Original Paper Tags$12S Harrisn Township, NJ