Stuffed animals
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
Squishables Plushes Lot – $45 (for all | separate prices in description)$45Chicago, IL
Disney Lilo & Stitch Munchlings Plush - 18-Inch Medium Pineapple Upside-Down Cake$23Schaumburg, IL
Lot Of 10 TY Beanie Babies Assorted Birds Excellant Cond$30Downers Grove, IL
Lot of 10 Vtg TY Beanie Babies Assorted Dogs & Cats Excellant Cond$30Downers Grove, IL
SESAME STREET ELMO COOKIE MONSTER & BIG BIRD GUND NEW WITH TAGS$45Streamwood, IL
Lot of 10 Vtg TY Beanie Babies Assorted Animals Excellant Cond$30Downers Grove, IL
NEW Jazwares FNAF Five Nights at Freddy's Classic Freddy 8" Plush w/ GITD Eyes$25Buffalo Grove, IL
Microwavable Plush$40Palos Hills, IL
Disney Christmas Mickey Nutcracker Plush$25Downers Grove, IL
New! No Tag! Disney Lion Plushy! 14” Wide! $10Des Plaines, IL
Brick Bears $150Chicago, IL
JACK SKELLINGTON SQUISHMALLOW NEW$20Streamwood, IL
Hello Kitty Stepper$22Mount Prospect, IL
Hello Kitty Halloween Stepper$22Mount Prospect, IL
Jumbo Rilakkuma Plush$115Wood Dale, IL
Percy The Pug From Pocahontas NWT Disney Plush Vintage But Stored And In New Condition$20Naperville, IL
Vtg Marshall University Marco the Bison Plush Toy$15Downers Grove, IL
Teddy Bear$10Aurora, IL
Cubs Teddy Bear$15Aurora, IL
Teddy Bear Kenseth$18Aurora, IL
Spray ground Bear $90Evanston, IL
Kissy Missy Plush Toy$2Chicago, IL
Holiday Peep$10Chicago, IL
Wandavision Build A Bears$60Chicago, IL
Lot of 10 Vtg TY Beanie Babies Assorted Animals Excellant Cond$30Downers Grove, IL
Tickle me Elmo $100Glen Ellyn, IL
Care Bears Universal Monsters Dracula 9,"$30Chicago, IL
Lot of 10 Vtg McDonalds Teenie Beanie Babies Excellent Cond$15Downers Grove, IL
Lot Of 10 Vtg TY Beanie Babies Teddy Bears 6 With Tags 4 Without Excellent Condition$30Downers Grove, IL
HALLOWEEN 🎃 BUILD A BEAR$20Streamwood, IL
Melissa And Doug Stuffed Animals $30Arlington Heights, IL
5 Ft Bear$40Romeoville, IL
LABUBU $40Dundee Township, IL
NEW 2025 DC Sonic The Hedgehog 9” Plush Jakks Pacific NWT (SET OF 4)$80Buffalo Grove, IL
Hello Kitty And Care Bear Collab Set$100Chicago, IL
Vtg Handmade Gray Teddy Bear 1990 16” Mohair Artist Karen Rundlett Scooter$50Downers Grove, IL
American Girl Stuffed Animal Dog “Coconut” $10River Forest, IL
Skullpanda X Wednesday Plush POPMART $80Chicago, IL
Halloween Plush NEW$8Chicago, IL
Squishmallows $2Oak Lawn, IL
Squishmallows $10Oak Lawn, IL
Squishmallows $8Oak Lawn, IL
Squishmallow$10Oak Lawn, IL
Squishmallows$20Oak Lawn, IL
TY Beanie Baby The Beginning White Bear Silver Star$40Chicago, IL
Care Bears Universal Monsters Dracula $30Chicago, IL
White Sox Stuffed Animals $25Niles, IL
Skates Stuffed Animals. $15.00$15Niles, IL
Puppy & Panda Bear Toys$15Glenview, IL
Furreal Roaring Tiger$40Bensenville, IL