Stuffed animals
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
Ernie Muppet Cookie Jar 1986 Original $45Wauconda, IL
Hallmark Lil' Sweetheart Bear Valentine NWT$8Waukegan, IL
Little Tikes Shopping Cart With Doll Seat$11Glendale Heights, IL
BRAND NEW - 16 inch Squishmallows FuzzAMallow Official Woxie the Magenta Bigfoot$25Park Ridge, IL
Vintage Plush Dog w/ Bow And Lace Apron 9” / OOAK On Sale Staffed Animal / Rare $15Chicago, IL
Vintage D & L Imports Plush Teddy Bear 8” / Rare / # 91455 / OOAK On Sale$20Chicago, IL
Large Sulley Squishmallow$15Schaumburg, IL
Rainbow Plush Koala and Llama Stuffed Animals$5Schaumburg, IL
VTG Plush Teddy Bear 2nd Millennium Celebration 2000 w/ Suction Cup OOAK On Sale$20Chicago, IL
Lemon edition, Valentine’s Day plushy gift$0Chicago, IL
Kids Puppets $25Chicago, IL
Adorable Vintage Plush Staffed Cat w/ Baw Animal 6”x 8.5” One Of A Kind On Sale$25Chicago, IL
RARE Vintage 101 Dalmatian Dog Plush Stuffed Animal w/ Collar Eyes Look Up ~7x9”$40Chicago, IL
Harpers Fare Kids Jesus Loves Me Teddy Bear Heart Polka Dots 9" Rare$15Chicago, IL
Valentine Day Gifts$4Glen Ellyn, IL
Swiss Miss Doll. In New Condition$25Chicago Ridge, IL
14 in Yoshi plushie Nintendo$10Niles, IL
Puple Plush Queen Size Brand New$650Chicago, IL
Sizzle Red Hot Beanie Buddies ♥️ 🧸$7Naperville, IL
Disney Store Finding Nemo Plush Soft Toy Shiny Shimmer Glitter Fins Pixar 16”$25Oak Lawn, IL
4 Foot Tall Stuffed Animal Monkey (light Brown)$10Geneva, IL
Vintage Plush Frog in rapper hip hop Outfit - Unique Collectible$15Park Ridge, IL
Jellycat Prices In Description $26Chicago, IL
Jellycat Malachy Dragon NWT Retail $78Chicago, IL
Jellycat Prices In Description $32Chicago, IL
Jellycat Prices In Description $25Chicago, IL
Jellycat Prices In Description $32Chicago, IL
Peeps Hello Kitty & Friends Jumbo Activity Case$5South Elgin, IL
Care Bears Lot of 6$50Des Plaines, IL
Bear Silicon Squish Lamp$15Chicago, IL
100% Auth. KAWS x Uniqlo x Peanuts Snoopy Plush (M) White$220Chicago, IL
Toys $15Streamwood, IL
Exciting Macaron Sea Salt Coconut $25Skokie, IL
Have A Good Run - Great Wealth$35Evanston, IL
New With Tags XL Squishmallows $5Sycamore, IL
Baby Yoda Plush Mandalorian The Child 11”$15Chicago, IL
Plush in the shape of a baby carriage$10Melrose Park, IL
Tons and Tons of Kid’s Toys And Stuffed Animals$2Lake In The Hills, IL
Hello Kitty Squishmallow Easter Basket$5Chicago, IL
Husky Warmies Plush (Microwavable)$10Des Plaines, IL
The Child Lot - Star Wars Plush Grogu The One Pre Owned $9Chicago, IL
Chase Paw Patrol 15" Plush Good Condition $5Bedford Park, IL
Hello Kitty Starbucks Plush - 2025$30Melrose Park, IL
Troll Valentines Key Chain $5St. Charles, IL
Jellycat Amuseables Olives NWT$40Chicago, IL
Jellycat Amuseables Horatio Pistachio NWT$35Chicago, IL
Jellycat Amuseable Pickle NWT$35Chicago, IL
Chosun Heart To Heart Bear 11-in Dark Brown Teddy Bear Sears$10Chicago, IL
Plushies $5Chicago, IL
Authentic Labubus $30Melrose Park, IL