Stuffed animals
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
Kuromi Plushie$15Stickney, IL
PET SIMULATOR Roblox COOL BEANZ Mystery Plush with DLC Code Inside$14Buffalo Grove, IL
My Melody Plushie$15Stickney, IL
Hello Kitty Plushie$15Stickney, IL
Hello Kitty- Squishmellows$8Stickney, IL
10 Beanie Buddy’s Bigger Than Little Ones $60Hinsdale, IL
VINTAGE PEANUT’S PLUSH $20Oak Lawn, IL
NEW 2025 Phatmojo JUMBO 18" Poppy Playtime Smiling Critters DOGDAY Plush$60Buffalo Grove, IL
Creeper Minecraft 8” - 9” Plush Toy Factory Mojang 2022 Stuffed Toy$7Chicago Ridge, IL
Build A Bear MagicQuest Red Dragon Ellie 15” Plush Great Wolf Lodge Exclusive$10Chicago Ridge, IL
Wild Republic Cuddlekins Capybara Plush Stuffed Animal 12 Inch$15Chicago Ridge, IL
Totally Teddies Cute Plush Bear with Red White & Blue Bling TEXAS The RGU Group$8Chicago Ridge, IL
Plush Pillow$15Palatine, IL
VTG Stuffed Animal Dog Beige/Black 12” $15Downers Grove, IL
HARLEY-DAVIDSON BEAR$15Oak Lawn, IL
VINTAGE LASSIE PLUSH$20Oak Lawn, IL
Gengar 24” Plush$45Chicago, IL
Jumbo Plush Mario Bros$20Melrose Park, IL
Nickelodeon SpongeBob Squarepants Stuffed Plush 7”$10Chicago Ridge, IL
Nintendo Super Mario Broters 5" Fire Flower Stuffed Plush Red Fire Balls NES$5Chicago Ridge, IL
Texas Longhorn Bull Stuffed Plush Animal Toy wearing Texas Flag Bandanna 11”$10Chicago Ridge, IL
Baby GUND Plush Baby Toothpick Sloth Stuffed Animal 16” Taupe Brown$10Chicago Ridge, IL
Good Stuff Mario Kart Banana Peel Plush Stuffed Toy 10" Luigi Princess Peach$10Chicago Ridge, IL
Checkmate Queen $60Chicago, IL
Disney Country Bears Big Al Plush$40Homer Glen, IL
Secret Life Of Pets Gidget Talking Plush$5Homer Glen, IL
Build A Bear Bat$27Homer Glen, IL
Build A Bear Dragonite Pokemon$24Homer Glen, IL
Tanjiro Kamado$15Stickney, IL
Tanjiro Kamado$11Stickney, IL
Labubus (macaron / Big Into Energy)$300Carol Stream, IL
Plush Toys$5Naperville, IL
Disney Goofy Crew Neck$40Ontarioville, IL
Stuffed Animal Storage $35Gary, IN
Labubu$35Des Plaines, IL
Aurora Destination Nation Clown Fish Plush 17" Orange White Stuffed Animal Toy$6Chicago Ridge, IL
Windy City Oprah Brown Stuffed Bear Animal 7”$15Downers Grove, IL
Hot Parrat Repeat What You Say Stuffed Animal Plush Toy Electronic Record Toys 10”$25Downers Grove, IL
Cat Collection Plushies $35Summit, IL
LITTLE LIVE PETS 26222 Gotta Go Flamingo Singing Wiggling and Pooping Plush Toy$150Chicago, IL
VTG 1999 8th Edition Starbucks Bearista Snowman Bear Plush 11”$15Downers Grove, IL
Big Into Energy Labubus!$25Glendale Heights, IL
Build A Bear Workshop Stuffed Plush Brown Teddy Bear 16”$15Downers Grove, IL
Dr. Seuss Hop On Pop Bear Plush Brown Stuffed Animal Kohl's Cares For Kids 16" $12Chicago Ridge, IL
HELLO KITTY Frankie & Unicorn Greeters $65Schaumburg, IL
Build A Bear Blue Jurassic World$10Homer Glen, IL
Build A Bear Camo Wolf Great Wolf Lodge$16Homer Glen, IL
Build A Bear Mufasa Lion King$65Homer Glen, IL
Build A Bear Fox$32Homer Glen, IL
Benny “Halloween” Squishmellow$40Homer Glen, IL