Stuffed animals
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
NWT Disney Store Chip & Dale Mini Bean Bag Plush Collectible Toy Beanie Set$15Chicago Ridge, IL
Labubu + Blind bags$20Oak Lawn, IL
Disney Store NWT A Bug’s Life Mini Bean Bag Plush Set of 4 Heimlich Francis Flea$25Chicago Ridge, IL
Vintage 90s Disney Store Kiara Lion King Hand Puppet 9" Plush Gold Club Cover$15Chicago Ridge, IL
Vintage ALF Born To Rock Hand Puppet Wears Shirt & Bandana ~ 1988 collectible toy$10Park Ridge, IL
Labubu macaron $45Hammond, IN
Small Brown Bear Plush$10Oak Lawn, IL
Beanie Babies ! $8Chicago, IL
Big Round Sloth$27Skokie, IL
Stuffed Animals$50Frankfort, IL
Hello Kitty Large Cup$5Des Plaines, IL
Gund Interactive Peekaboo Elephant $15River Forest, IL
Wayne. Gretzky. New. York. Rangers. Sweater.$75Niles, IL
Ty beanie babies original Collection $2,800Lincolnwood, IL
Build A Bear Tabby Cat with Blue Sweater Plush Approximately 17in Tall$80Chicago, IL
NEW Poppy Playtime Smiling Critters 8" Plush ALL 4 DOGDAY/HOPPY/CATNAP/CRAFTY$55Wheeling, IL
NEW 2025 Jazwares Squishmallows Knuckles with Blue Emerald Sonic The Hedgehog 8"$26Wheeling, IL
NEW 2025 Squishmallow Sonic the Hedgehog Sonic with Gold Ring 8"$26Wheeling, IL
NEW 2025 Squishmallows Sonic the Hedgehog SHADOW Holding GREEN GEM 8"$26Wheeling, IL
Labubu macaron’s 40 cases available $230Chicago, IL
Squishmallow Bundle (2) Dragon And Lime $9Downers Grove, IL
Squishmallow Disney Winnie The Pooh 8” $8Downers Grove, IL
Squishmallow “Amelie” Strawberry Milk Plush $16Stickney, IL
Labubu Checkmate King And Queen$250Chicago, IL
Fire Chief Dalmatian $16Stickney, IL
Beanie Babies $300Addison, IL
Ty Collection $0Skokie, IL
Ty Beanie Babies “TyPuff” Stuffed Octopus (Sheldon)$10Chicago, IL
Ty Beanie Baby “The Beanie Boo’s Collection” Bat Plush$10Chicago, IL
Pink/Purple Snail Carrying Dandelion Plush$10Chicago, IL
2003 Vintage Care Bear Plush$15Chicago, IL
Large Care Bear Plush$15Chicago, IL
Assorted Squishmallows (5 Total)$15Chicago, IL
Micromallows Bouquet$20Oak Lawn, IL
Squishmallows Cam the Cat Mini Backpack 11 Inch Purse Book bag for Girls..(#15)$22Chicago, IL
Squishmallows$15Wheeling, IL
Big Into Energy Labubu $1Chicago, IL
HELLO KITTY $10Oak Lawn, IL
Small Pikachu Plush$8Palatine, IL
Small Pikachu Plushie $8Palatine, IL
Raggedy Andy $20Stickney, IL
Energizer Bunny$13Stickney, IL
Little Plush Holder$10Chicago, IL
Darth Vader $13Stickney, IL
🔥 Sonic the hedgehog SILVER 54" Giant plush . ( not shadow tails robotnik metal knuckles eggman$180Chicago, IL
Littlest Pet Shop Stuffed Animals$25Romeoville, IL
Squishmallow Gigi the Cat 12"$15Des Plaines, IL
Melissa And Daug Plush Giraffe $50Arlington Heights, IL
Various Hand And Finger Puppets$12Willow Springs, IL
Krusty The Clown$15Stickney, IL