Stuffed animals & Plush
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
Care Bears Tenderheart Bear Plush$30Chicago, IL
Vintage Mattel Blue's Clues Plush Interactive Blue Toy DOG 12"$30Chicago, IL
FIVE NIGHTS AT FREDDYS PLUSH$30Streamwood, IL
Stitch Bundle$15North Aurora, IL
HARLEY DAVIDSON CHRISTMAS PLUSH NEW$30Streamwood, IL
MISTLETOE & LITTLETOE PLUSH VINTAGE NEW W TAG$35Streamwood, IL
You Found Me SKULLPANDA Cerberus Confirmed Unopened$48Chicago, IL
Hello Kitty X Starbucks Collab Plush$55Chicago, IL
Hello Kitty Rubios Cube And Small Stuffed Animal$40Chicago, IL
Cute Panda Boba Plushie Keychain.$5Arlington Heights, IL
Head In The clouds Mickey Confirmed, NOT Rip$27Des Plaines, IL
Harry Potter Dolls (2017)$12Glen Ellyn, IL
SMURFS SET OF 2 PLUSH$30Streamwood, IL
Ty Beanie Kids Doll in Orange Outfit 10"$10Naperville, IL
Vibrant Ruby Red Russ Bear Plush 10"🧸$9Naperville, IL
Pokemon Plushies $12Oak Park, IL
Star Wars Pillow$5Glen Ellyn, IL
Weighted Elephant Plushie$15Chicago, IL
Bo Peep #524$10Bensenville, IL
Lunamira Panda Full Body Pillow$30Chicago, IL
Disney Minnie Mouse Plush$14Hanover Park, IL
Vintage Pickford Bears Lucy Teddy$20West Chicago, IL
NEW 2025 Jakks Pacific The Simpsons Itchy & Scratchy Jakks Pacific Plushies $50Buffalo Grove, IL
Large Elephant And Red Panda Stuffed Animals$10Hoffman Estates, IL
Feisty Pets Sammy Sucker Punch Husky Dog Puppy Cute Sweet Scary$20West Chicago, IL
🌟Lot Of Squishmallows Stuffed Animals 🌟 $20Lake Barrington, IL
Starbucks Hello Kitty Plush$70Chicago, IL
FIVE NIGHTS AT FREDDYS PLUSH$35Streamwood, IL
Hello Kitty $40Bedford Park, IL
Hello Kitty $13Bedford Park, IL
Handmade Teddy Bears$20Downers Grove, IL
Kipmik Alaska Sea Otter Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Realistic Fur Anchorage 11”$25Oak Lawn, IL
Bear Collection Beanie Babies $10 each$10Lake In The Hills, IL
Authentic Labubu Pin For Love Keychain$35Chicago, IL
Curious George$4Fox River Grove, IL
Vermont Teddy Bear $80Lemont, IL
The Elf On The Shelf Plushie Pal Blue Eyed Boy For Christmas New$14Buffalo Grove, IL
Two large beanbags $100Hinsdale, IL
Giraffe stuffed tall animal$15Posen, IL
Squishmallows 8” Gnome$5Naperville, IL
Squishmallows 10” Squish-Doos Dino pillow$8Naperville, IL
Marshmallows Slytherin 10” pillow$8Naperville, IL
Squishmallow Unai Cosmic Galaxy Purple Cap Mushroom 16"$10Bolingbrook, IL
Squishmallows 16” Rudolph Hermey Plush Figure$10Bolingbrook, IL
Squishmallows 8” Stitch Santa$5Naperville, IL
Squishmallows 5” Nick $4Naperville, IL
Squishmallows Squish-Doos 16” Massai Triceratops$10Naperville, IL
Squishmallows 12” Charles Pickle$10Naperville, IL
Squishmallows 16” Owl$10Bolingbrook, IL
FAO Schwartz Bear 92 Inches Paid $1,000.00 2 Christmas Ago Sacrifice $500.00$500Lincolnwood, IL