Stuffed animals & Plush
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
Squishmallow Disney Mickey Mouse Easter Bunny Plush $14Stickney, IL
Big Plushie Teddy Bear $30Romeoville, IL
Vintage Jumbo Care Bear Plush $10Chicago, IL
Original Steiff Animals $45Chicago, IL
Hand puppets$6Chicago, IL
Real vintage ty McDonalds Teenie Beanie Baby Mini ERIN the Bear 1(contact info removed) Tag$140Crystal Lake, IL
Marvel Stitch - Black Panther (Secret)$120Niles, IL
ELMO$12Chicago, IL
Taco Bell Dog$5Chicago, IL
TY McDonald's Complete set of 4 very rare Beanie babies.$35Chicago, IL
Red TY Birthday Beanie Baby with swing tag$4Chicago, IL
1999 TY Signature Beanie Baby$3Chicago, IL
Vintage 1999 Twinkle and Dreams Talking Barney Plush by Playskool – WORKS! 🟣Read Full Details Below🟣$20Hoffman Estates, IL
Disney Squishmallows$5Crystal Lake, IL
Hello Kitty Bat Greeter$50Chicago, IL
25 Pieces Of BAB. Build A Bear Clothing, Shoes, Etc$40Western Springs, IL
Huge Lot Of Stuffed Animals Plush Toys For Kids $5Lake Barrington, IL
Mini White Cat Plush $10Aurora, IL
Rainbow Sun Cloud Plush $10Aurora, IL
Gray Bunny Plush Stuffed Animal $15Aurora, IL
Cornhole Chicago Bears Theme For Kids Bean Bag Toss$20Chicago, IL
My Little Pony$6Lakemoor, IL
Lanky box Plush Toys Stuffed Animals $50Lake Barrington, IL
Fortnite Cuddle Team Leader Plush Toy Pink Bear Russ Epic Games 5" 2019 NEW$20Oak Lawn, IL
Pokemon Pikachu 8 inch Plush $25Chicago, IL
Ditto As Vaporeon Plush 6 ½ In. Pokemon Center Exclusive US Version$25Eola, IL
Beauteyrest Black Series Four Queen Size Plush $899 Only $899Chicago, IL
Sloth Plush Toy$10Glendale Heights, IL
Vintage Kansas Jayhawks Stuffed Animal Bear Red Bag Applause Plush Teddy Bear$35Chicago Ridge, IL
Random Animal Plushies $2Lyons, IL
Squishmallows$5Lyons, IL
Marvel Plushies$5Lyons, IL
Animal Plushies$3Lyons, IL
VTG TY Beanie Baby Prince the Frog Mint With Mint Tags DOB 7-3-2000$12Downers Grove, IL
VTG 2004 Pokémon Torchic Plush Nintendo Stuffed Animal 12”$15Downers Grove, IL
VTG K & M International Stuffed Goldfinch Plush Bird Yellow/Black 6”$15Downers Grove, IL
VTG 2003 K & M International Audubon Red Tailed Hawk Bird Plush 8” No Sound$15Downers Grove, IL
VTG The End Bear TY Beanie Baby Black Retired 2000 McDonalds New In Box$20Downers Grove, IL
Rare Large Princess Diana + Queen Elizabeth Celebrations Bear $10,000Oak Park, IL
VTG FAO Schwarz Collie Dog Plush Animal 13”$20Downers Grove, IL
VTG Mary Meyer Stuffed Pig Pink Plush Piglet 10”$20Downers Grove, IL
VTG TY Beanie Baby Rare Spangle The Bear McDonalds 1999 New In Box$20Downers Grove, IL
VTG TY Beanie Babies 2000 Millennium Bear Ronald McDonald House New In Pkg$15Downers Grove, IL
VTG Maple The Bear 1996?McDonalds TY Beanie Baby with Rare Errors 1993 Oakbrook$20Downers Grove, IL
Nommi $55Chicago, IL
IKEA Kattig Seal Plush Toy $20Oak Lawn, IL
Large Amount Of Stuffed Animals Plush Toys Squishmellows $150Lake Barrington, IL
NWT Fine Toy Co ODIE Plush Toy VTG 1978 Jim Davis Paws Dog Garfield Cat Big Eyes$20Chicago Ridge, IL
Build A Bear Orange Striped Tabby Cat Stuffed Kitty Plush Retired 17”$15Chicago Ridge, IL
45 Disney Beanie Bag Plushies: Various Characters $245Mount Prospect, IL