Stuffed animals & Plush
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
Large Amount Of Stuffed Animals Plush Toys Squishmellows $150Lake Barrington, IL
NWT Fine Toy Co ODIE Plush Toy VTG 1978 Jim Davis Paws Dog Garfield Cat Big Eyes$20Chicago Ridge, IL
Build A Bear Orange Striped Tabby Cat Stuffed Kitty Plush Retired 17”$15Chicago Ridge, IL
45 Disney Beanie Bag Plushies: Various Characters $245Mount Prospect, IL
Disney's Halloween Oversized Supersoft Printed Plush Throw by The Big One®$30Chicago, IL
Inside Out 2 Anxiety Plush Toys$10Lake Barrington, IL
Hello Kitty Plush Toy$5Chicago, IL
24 Ty Plush Stuffed Animal Toys New$120Carol Stream, IL
Labubus$50Chicago, IL
Gemmy Animated Boney Barney Halloween Decor Skeleton Dog, Talks, Eyes Light Up, Head and Mouth Move$55Palatine, IL
VTG 2000 Pouch Beanie Buddies Kangaroo With Baby Joey Plush Soft Toy 13”$20Downers Grove, IL
1998 Warner Bros. Wizard of Oz Plush Set – Complete 11 w/ Tags – $90$30Chicago, IL
USED TY BEANIE BABY EARS 1995$6Palos Hills, IL
USED TY BEANIE BABY POUCH 1996$6Oak Lawn, IL
Build-A-Bear Chicago Blackhawks Teddy $15Lisle, IL
3 VTG TY Beanie Babies 2001 Sizzle Kidd me & Signature Bear 9”$30Downers Grove, IL
Walt Disney World Maleficent Dragon Sleeping Beauty Stuffed Plush 14”$25Downers Grove, IL
2 VTG TY Beanie Babies America the Bear Plush Pops Bear Plush 2001 9”$20Downers Grove, IL
VTG Harley Davidson Teddy Bear Bean Bag Plushes Big Twin Roamer Motörhead 1997 6”$30Downers Grove, IL
VTG Harley Davidson Bean Bag Pig Plush 1997 Racer Rachet Punky 6”$30Downers Grove, IL
Paw Patrol Skye Plush Ride$50Chicago, IL
Squishmallow Spydey Hugmees New$12Bolingbrook, IL
Hello Kitty $15Round Lake Heights, IL
POP MART Exciting Macaron Labubu$50Crystal Lake, IL
Hello Kitty Jewerlries$15Chicago, IL
Sea Salt Coconut- Exciting Macaron Labubu$50Elgin, IL
Plushies $5$5Melrose Park, IL
Stuffed Animals Lot$5Chicago, IL
plush toys. $5Chicago, IL
Plushies $10Ontarioville, IL
Plushies Among Us $10Ontarioville, IL
Two 3.5" Cleary The Strawberry Cow and Bowie The Watermelon Hedgehog Squishmallow Clips - New no tags $15Stickney, IL
Highland Cow Plush 36” $50Bolingbrook, IL
Forest Fairy Tale Labubu $0Chicago, IL
Authentic Labubu Have A Seat Version$30Elgin, IL
Exciting Macaron Lychee Berry Labubu$55Chicago, IL
Stuffed Animals $25Elgin, IL
New Unicorn Dreamcatcher And Plushie$10Hinsdale, IL
Jellycat Grey Bunny$20Chicago Ridge, IL
Manhattan Toys Bunnies $40Chicago Ridge, IL
Peppa Pig Stuffed Animal $15Chicago Ridge, IL
PET SIMULATOR Roblox COOL BEANZ Mystery Plush with DLC Code Inside$14Buffalo Grove, IL
VINTAGE PEANUT’S PLUSH $20Oak Lawn, IL
NEW 2025 Phatmojo JUMBO 18" Poppy Playtime Smiling Critters DOGDAY Plush$60Buffalo Grove, IL
Creeper Minecraft 8” - 9” Plush Toy Factory Mojang 2022 Stuffed Toy$7Chicago Ridge, IL
Build A Bear MagicQuest Red Dragon Ellie 15” Plush Great Wolf Lodge Exclusive$10Chicago Ridge, IL
Wild Republic Cuddlekins Capybara Plush Stuffed Animal 12 Inch$15Chicago Ridge, IL
Totally Teddies Cute Plush Bear with Red White & Blue Bling TEXAS The RGU Group$8Chicago Ridge, IL
Plush Pillow$15Palatine, IL
Labubu - Toffee Exciting Macaron$35Gurnee, IL