No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item.
Search
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Interactive Stuffed AnimalInteractive Stuffed Animal$2Evanston, ILPanda Stuffed Animals Panda Stuffed Animals $10Alsip, ILbeanie original babyPromotedbeanie original baby$1,234,567Palatine, ILBison and goofy stuffed animalsBison and goofy stuffed animals$5Aurora, ILTy The Attic Treasures Fairbanks Plush Jointed Bear in a sweater 9" . Ty The Attic Treasures Fairbanks Plush Jointed Bear in a sweater 9" . $9South Zanesville, OHShaimi Pikachu Stuffed Animals$658.00Shaimi Pikachu Stuffed AnimalseBayAdStuffed AnimalsStuffed Animals$5Aurora, ILStuffed AnimalStuffed Animal$10Schaumburg, ILHello Kitty PlushPromotedHello Kitty Plush$50Chicago, ILThe Child/Baby Yoda Stuffed AnimalThe Child/Baby Yoda Stuffed Animal$8Melrose Park, ILBlack Dog Stuffed Animal Lifelike Size Cool Unique Lab Rot ToyBlack Dog Stuffed Animal Lifelike Size Cool Unique Lab Rot Toy$33Blue Island, ILGUND P.Lushes Designer Fashion Pets Madame Purrnel Cat Premium Stuffed Animal Stylish Soft Plush Kitty with Glitter Sparkle, for Ages 3 and Up, Pink aGUND P.Lushes Designer Fashion Pets Madame Purrnel Cat Premium Stuffed Animal Stylish Soft Plush Kitty with Glitter Sparkle, for Ages 3 and Up, Pink a$16Oswego, ILJust Play Reindeer In Here 8-Inch Small Plush Stuffed Animal 2-Pack, Blizzard And Pinky, Soft Fur, Kids Toys For Ages 3 Up$11.67Just Play Reindeer In Here 8-Inch Small Plush Stuffed Animal 2-Pack, Blizzard And Pinky, Soft Fur, Kids Toys For Ages 3 UpAmazon.comAd1996 Mint Mel Bennie Baby OBOPromoted1996 Mint Mel Bennie Baby OBO$345Downers Grove, ILSafari Animals Plush and Book Set - Stuffed Animals of 3 Savanna Animals Storybook- 12” Set Includes Lion, Giraffe and Elephant Colorful Children 📖Safari Animals Plush and Book Set - Stuffed Animals of 3 Savanna Animals Storybook- 12” Set Includes Lion, Giraffe and Elephant Colorful Children 📖$14Aurora, ILVintage 90s Talking Dog Plush Stuffed Animal ToyVintage 90s Talking Dog Plush Stuffed Animal Toy$20Chicago, ILElmo Stuffed Animals Elmo Stuffed Animals $15Hoffman Estates, ILDisney Goofy Plush Stuffed Animal Adult Hat CapDisney Goofy Plush Stuffed Animal Adult Hat Cap$20Chicago, ILTy Beanie Legs (2nd Gen)PromotedTy Beanie Legs (2nd Gen)$150Prospect Heights, ILYardon Life-Size Stuffed Animals$679.50Yardon Life-Size Stuffed AnimalseBayAdStuffed AnimalStuffed Animal$4Lombard, ILStuffed AnimalStuffed Animal$4Lombard, ILStuffed AnimalStuffed Animal$4Lombard, ILRare Vintage Beanie Baby “Glory” PromotedRare Vintage Beanie Baby “Glory” $1,000Cambria, CAStuffed AnimalStuffed Animal$3Lombard, ILMelissa And Doug Big Llama Plush Stuffed AnimalMelissa And Doug Big Llama Plush Stuffed Animal$20Brookfield, IL1/2/3/4/5/6/10Pcs, Giant Teddy Bear Stuffed Animals Plush Toy Cute Life Size Big Plush Teddy Bear For Kids Girlfriend, Soft,Blue,Trending,By Temu$129.491/2/3/4/5/6/10Pcs, Giant Teddy Bear Stuffed Animals Plush Toy Cute Life Size Big Plush Teddy Bear For Kids Girlfriend, Soft,Blue,Trending,By TemuTemu-US-LocalAdHarley Davidson Cycles Hog Plush Biker Pig Stuffed Animal Play By Play 1993 Tag NewHarley Davidson Cycles Hog Plush Biker Pig Stuffed Animal Play By Play 1993 Tag New$20Streamwood, ILSquishmallows Disney 14-Inch Abu Plush - Add Abu to Your Squad, Ultrasoft Stuffed Animal Large Plush Toy, Official Kellytoy PlushSquishmallows Disney 14-Inch Abu Plush - Add Abu to Your Squad, Ultrasoft Stuffed Animal Large Plush Toy, Official Kellytoy Plush$24Oswego, ILDisney Stuffed Animals Monsters Inc Mike And Misc Disney Stuffed Animals Monsters Inc Mike And Misc $5Hoffman Estates, ILDisney Little Mermaid Flounder Plush Yellow Fish Walt Disney World Stuffed AnimalDisney Little Mermaid Flounder Plush Yellow Fish Walt Disney World Stuffed Animal$10Park Ridge, ILMacaw Plush Stuffed Animal Bird Parrot LargeMacaw Plush Stuffed Animal Bird Parrot Large$25Hoffman Estates, ILPokemon Gengar 24" Plush, NewPokemon Gengar 24" Plush, New$40Streamwood, ILWarmies Lavender Scented Marshmallow Bear$24.99Warmies Lavender Scented Marshmallow BearPlay Therapy SupplyAdPokemon 24" Plush - PikachuPokemon 24" Plush - Pikachu$40Streamwood, ILGund Disney Classic Pooh Piglet Plush Stuffed AnimalGund Disney Classic Pooh Piglet Plush Stuffed Animal$6Batavia, ILPurple Floppy Care Bear Sweat Dreams Purple Floppy Care Bear Sweat Dreams $75Alsip, ILNational Geographic Brand Jumbo White Polar Bear Plush Stuffed AnimalNational Geographic Brand Jumbo White Polar Bear Plush Stuffed Animal$20Ind Head Park, ILNEW Care Bears Besties DARE TO CARE BEAR 14in Stuffed Animal Plush ToyNEW Care Bears Besties DARE TO CARE BEAR 14in Stuffed Animal Plush Toy$19Hanover Park, ILSonic The Hedgehog yellow double Tails Plush Doll Stuffed Animal Toy SEGA Genesis video game Sonic The Hedgehog yellow double Tails Plush Doll Stuffed Animal Toy SEGA Genesis video game $10Park Ridge, ILVintage Lot 19 Small Animal Fair Henry Plush Collector Stuffed Animals$226.99Vintage Lot 19 Small Animal Fair Henry Plush Collector Stuffed AnimalseBayAdPokemon Pikachu Plush Van Gogh Museum 7 3/4” inch Stuffed Animal Plushie StuffiePokemon Pikachu Plush Van Gogh Museum 7 3/4” inch Stuffed Animal Plushie Stuffie$60Vernon Hills, ILPlush Mermaid ‘Pillow’Plush Mermaid ‘Pillow’$10Aurora, ILBoba Calico Cat Plush Boba Calico Cat Plush $10Monterey Park, CAGraduation Teddy's Graduation Teddy's $8Carol Stream, ILBrenda the Butterfly SquishmallowBrenda the Butterfly Squishmallow$10Romeoville, ILRosie the Pig Squishmallow Rosie the Pig Squishmallow $8Romeoville, ILWild Republic Koala Plush, Stuffed Animal, Plush Toy, Gifts For Kids, Cuddlekins 12"$29.00Wild Republic Koala Plush, Stuffed Animal, Plush Toy, Gifts For Kids, Cuddlekins 12"Amazon.comAdCarol the Christmas Tree SquishmallowCarol the Christmas Tree Squishmallow$11Romeoville, ILSnake SquishmallowSnake Squishmallow$10Romeoville, IL