Stuffed animals & Plush
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
Disney Christmas Mickey Nutcracker Plush$25Downers Grove, IL
New! No Tag! Disney Lion Plushy! 14” Wide! $10Des Plaines, IL
Brick Bears $150Chicago, IL
JACK SKELLINGTON SQUISHMALLOW NEW$20Streamwood, IL
Hello Kitty Stepper$22Mount Prospect, IL
Hello Kitty Halloween Stepper$22Mount Prospect, IL
Percy The Pug From Pocahontas NWT Disney Plush Vintage But Stored And In New Condition$20Naperville, IL
Vtg Marshall University Marco the Bison Plush Toy$15Downers Grove, IL
Teddy Bear$10Aurora, IL
Cubs Teddy Bear$15Aurora, IL
Teddy Bear Kenseth$18Aurora, IL
Lot of 10 Vtg TY Beanie Babies Assorted Animals Excellant Cond$30Downers Grove, IL
Tickle me Elmo $100Glen Ellyn, IL
Care Bears Universal Monsters Dracula 9,"$30Chicago, IL
Lot of 10 Vtg McDonalds Teenie Beanie Babies Excellent Cond$15Downers Grove, IL
Lot Of 10 Vtg TY Beanie Babies Teddy Bears 6 With Tags 4 Without Excellent Condition$30Downers Grove, IL
HALLOWEEN 🎃 BUILD A BEAR$20Streamwood, IL
Melissa And Doug Stuffed Animals $30Arlington Heights, IL
5 Ft Bear$40Romeoville, IL
LABUBU $40Dundee Township, IL
NEW 2025 DC Sonic The Hedgehog 9” Plush Jakks Pacific NWT (SET OF 4)$80Buffalo Grove, IL
Hello Kitty And Care Bear Collab Set$100Chicago, IL
Vtg Handmade Gray Teddy Bear 1990 16” Mohair Artist Karen Rundlett Scooter$50Downers Grove, IL
TY Beanie Baby The Beginning White Bear Silver Star$40Chicago, IL
Care Bears Universal Monsters Dracula $30Chicago, IL
White Sox Stuffed Animals $20Niles, IL
Skates Stuffed Animals. $10Niles, IL
Puppy & Panda Bear Toys$15Glenview, IL
Furreal Roaring Tiger$40Bensenville, IL
NEW 2024 Sonic The Hedgehog 3 Movie Sonic Plush Jakks Pacific 9” (SET OF 4)$75Buffalo Grove, IL
NEW 2025 Sonic The Hedgehog Squishmallows Plush Halloween Theme Vampire 8”$20Buffalo Grove, IL
NEW 2024 Original Squishmallow Wicked Elphaba 3" Keychain Clip-On$9Buffalo Grove, IL
Build A Bear Bunny With Girl Scout Dress$8Plainfield, IL
Dr Seuss Sneetches Yellow Green Star Belly Plush 17 Inch Stuffed Animal Toy$10Naperville, IL
Corduroy Vintage 1996 stuffed Animal $20Naperville, IL
Legally Blonde 2 Bruiser Woods Dog & Carrying Bag$22Naperville, IL
Olivia the Pug Plush Gund Toy 11 Inch $20Naperville, IL
Squishmallow / Stuffed Animal / Gift Set Lot$200Prospect Heights, IL
SALE!!!$40Elmhurst, IL
Big into Energy Labubu $34Des Plaines, IL
Why So Serious Dimoo $40Chicago, IL
Peeps Collectors $15Winfield, IL
Dragon Plush $8Naperville, IL
Spike Ghost Beanie Baby$3North Riverside, IL
Ghoulie Boo Boo TY Large & Small$7Summit, IL
PinkyS Beanie Baby$10Chicago, IL
Collectors Dan Dee’s Sock Monkey$10Chicago, IL
Sock Monkey Plushie$15Chicago, IL
Cinnamoroll Outfit$10Elgin, IL
My Melody Outfit$10Elgin, IL