Stuffed animals & Plush
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
Horse Teddy Bear $35Stickney, IL
53 Inch Giant Teddy Bear Plush $65Palatine, IL
Stuffed Animals $100Chicago, IL
🔥WWE Plushies 🔥$1Chicago, IL
Squishmallow Nightmare Before Christmas Barrel$11Roselle, IL
Build A Bear 2012 Peace and Sweetheart Bear McDonalds Happy Meal Toy - New/Sealed$13Spring Grove, IL
Build A Bear 2012 Endless Hugs & Friendship Teddy McDonalds Happy Meal Toy - New/Sealed $13Spring Grove, IL
Ty Beanie Babies$300Des Plaines, IL
NWT Squishmallows Plush Toy - Anya - 16"$20Chicago, IL
NWT Squishmallows Plush Toy - 16"$10Chicago, IL
Large New With Tags axolotl plushy stuffed animal$20Hoffman Estates, IL
Stuffed Animals Plush Toys $25Hoffman Estates, IL
Large Plush Easter Basket Like New Highland Cow$25Hoffman Estates, IL
NWT Squishmallows 8" Plush Toy Pyle Mushroom $8Chicago, IL
NWT Squishmallows 8" Plush Toy Erica The Chinchilla $10Chicago, IL
NWT Squishmallows 12" Plush Toy - Visconti - Macaron$15Chicago, IL
Talking Easter Bunny In Basket$20Schiller Park, IL
NEW 2025 Vanny FNAF Funko Security Breach Jumbo Plush 16 Inch Plush $60Wheeling, IL
Build A Bear Frozen Elsa$10Stickney, IL
Vintage 1970 "The Cat in the Hat" Hand Puppet $12Chicago, IL
Various Stuffed Animals$0Lake Zurich, IL
Giant EEVEE Plush 24 Inch$30Chicago, IL
Disney Mickey Mouse Donald Duck Sleeping Bag$10Arlington Heights, IL
Disney Winnie the Pooh / The Tigger Movie 1999/2000 McDonalds Happy Meal Toys (Lot of 6) - New/Sealed Tigger Roo Tigger Gopher Winnie the Pooh Owl$20Spring Grove, IL
Disney Winnie the Pooh / The Tigger Movie 1999/2000 McDonalds Happy Meal Toys (Lot of 8) - New/Sealed Tigger Roo Tigger Piglet Winnie the Pooh Owl $20Spring Grove, IL
Disney Shamrock Minnie Mouse At. Patrick Day Plush$39Mount Prospect, IL
Babar Elephant Plush 9" tall $5Arlington Heights, IL
Bing Bunny Talking Plush Toy $20Itasca, IL
Vintage 1990 BART Simpson Plush Toy$10Chicago, IL
Build-A-Bear Star Wars 17” Kylo Ren The Force Awakens Teddy Plush⚫️Read Full Description Below⚫️$15Hoffman Estates, IL
Build A Bear 2007 McDonalds Happy Meal Toys (Lot of 8) - New/Sealed Hearts For You Teddy Vanilla Fudge Bunny Fru Fru Poddle Curly Teddy Friendship D$35Spring Grove, IL
TY Beanie Baby 2004 McDonalds Happy Meal Toys (Lot of 12) - New/Sealed Happy Meal 25th Bear Burger The Bear Birdie The Bear Golden Arches The Bear $50Spring Grove, IL
Rocket Raccoon Funko Plush$15Ontarioville, IL
Daddy Bears $10Skokie, IL
Daddy Bears$10Skokie, IL
Stuffed Animals Lot$100West Chicago, IL
Squishmallows Lot $20West Chicago, IL
Stuffed Animals $25Melrose Park, IL
Four plush animal hand puppets - the giraffe lion and tiger mouths open and close And Elephant $12Stickney, IL
Snoopy$30Lake Forest, IL
Hello Kitty $30Chicago, IL
Stuffed Animal $4Arlington Heights, IL
2000 Baltimore Ravens Play Football Nanco Plush Bears w/ Tags Lot of 2$8Lake Villa, IL
Russ Bears of the Month November Birthstone Topaz Plush Brown 5.5" Sitting Bear$4Lake Villa, IL
Roses Teddy Bear $65Chicago, IL
Vintage Walt Disney Mickey Mouse And Donald Duck Stuffed Plush California Toys$35Arlington Heights, IL
Disney Plushes - various prices Minnie, Frog, Tinker Belle Cinderella Rabbit$5Arlington Heights, IL
Hello Kitty$25Chicago, IL
Winnie The Pooh Plush$8Westchester, IL
Care Bear Lot $280Chicago, IL