No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item.
Search
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Puzzle games

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Vintage Chicago 504 Pc Jigsaw Puzzle By Buffalo Games - Brand New SealedVintage Chicago 504 Pc Jigsaw Puzzle By Buffalo Games - Brand New Sealed$20Chicago, ILIn The Dark Garden Puzzle By Nathalie LeteIn The Dark Garden Puzzle By Nathalie Lete$10Deerfield, ILDark Souls The Board Game Base GamePromotedDark Souls The Board Game Base Game$100Gurnee, ILBrand New Classic JengaBrand New Classic Jenga$10Mount Prospect, IL*SEALED* Nintendo Amiibo Metroid Dread 2-Pack *TRADE IN YOUR OLD GAMES FOR CSH OR CREDIT HERE/WE FIX SYSTEMS**SEALED* Nintendo Amiibo Metroid Dread 2-Pack *TRADE IN YOUR OLD GAMES FOR CSH OR CREDIT HERE/WE FIX SYSTEMS*$29Montclair, CAPig Kumiki - 3D Brain Teaser Wooden Puzzle$11.95Pig Kumiki - 3D Brain Teaser Wooden PuzzleBrilliant PuzzlesAdPool Table BrunswickPool Table Brunswick$500Chicago, ILFoosball Table/Air HockeyFoosball Table/Air Hockey$250Round Lake Heights, ILDisney Mickey Mouse Clubhouse Puzzle PromotedDisney Mickey Mouse Clubhouse Puzzle $2Melrose Park, IL2005 Golden Tee Full Size Arcade Game MAKE OFFER2005 Golden Tee Full Size Arcade Game MAKE OFFER$1Carol Stream, ILShooter Game Lot Shooter Game Lot $840Des Plaines, ILTrivial Pursuit 90s Edition Trivial Pursuit 90s Edition $4Palatine, IL1 Puzzle - Interlocking Brainteaser Metal Puzzle$18.951 Puzzle - Interlocking Brainteaser Metal PuzzleBrilliant PuzzlesAdVintage Arcade Games, And Pinball Machine GREAT INVESTMENT!PromotedVintage Arcade Games, And Pinball Machine GREAT INVESTMENT!$1Beach Park, ILHockey Rink Boards and accessoriesHockey Rink Boards and accessories$150Wilmette, ILDramatic Play Center Dramatic Play Center $150Lake Zurich, ILAir Hockey TableAir Hockey Table$400Chicago, ILJapanese Tea Garden PuzzleJapanese Tea Garden Puzzle$5Deerfield, ILTuck Pointing PromotedTuck Pointing $1Hanover Park, ILBrain Busters - 8 Brain Teasers Puzzle Set$19.95Brain Busters - 8 Brain Teasers Puzzle SetBrilliant PuzzlesAdAvailable 🔻Adult Large Puzzles, Like New $5 EachAvailable 🔻Adult Large Puzzles, Like New $5 Each$5Wheeling, ILNew Pennsylvania Giant Checker Game Woven Rug, Checkers 3” (W)New Pennsylvania Giant Checker Game Woven Rug, Checkers 3” (W)$15Schiller Park, ILLarge Vintage Game Board Large Vintage Game Board $30Algonquin, ILPool Table (Billiards)PromotedPool Table (Billiards)$200Chicago, ILMelissa and Doug Puzzle Storage CaseMelissa and Doug Puzzle Storage Case$15Chicago, ILSlot MachineSlot Machine$300Round Lake Heights, ILPuzzle Master 3 Cd Rom Game$167.88Puzzle Master 3 Cd Rom GameeBayAdMovie GameMovie Game$10Schaumburg, ILSealed Cubone Surprise Attack Game!Sealed Cubone Surprise Attack Game!$8Chicago, ILNEW Sealed Box Jigsaw Puzzle NEW Sealed Box Jigsaw Puzzle $10Algonquin, ILArabic Alphabets Wooden Puzzle, 11.75" x 8.75"Arabic Alphabets Wooden Puzzle, 11.75" x 8.75"$7Palatine, ILStacker Game Stacker Game $2,000Trout Valley, ILJigsaw Puzzle Jigsaw Puzzle $15Buffalo Grove, ILOriginal + Ic4 Design Wooden Puzzle Jigsaw, Puzzle Board Game, Quezzle$426.99Original + Ic4 Design Wooden Puzzle Jigsaw, Puzzle Board Game, QuezzleeBayAdPikachu & Zekrom GX Tag Team (P&Z Card Slot Included)Pikachu & Zekrom GX Tag Team (P&Z Card Slot Included)$30Morton Grove, ILNew In Box, Board GameNew In Box, Board Game$7Chicago, IL3 "Zombie" Games. All There, Like New.See Description 3 "Zombie" Games. All There, Like New.See Description $3Chicago, ILAir Hockey TableAir Hockey Table$65Libertyville, ILTable Tennis Vintage Games Brand NewTable Tennis Vintage Games Brand New$20Schaumburg, IL$20 Cada Uno Presio Firme $20 Cada Uno Presio Firme $20Chicago, ILSummoners War Puzzle 500P$171.71Summoners War Puzzle 500PeBayAdDragon Ball $25 Cada Uno Dragon Ball $25 Cada Uno $25Chicago, ILCada Uno Está El Presio En Foto Cada Uno Está El Presio En Foto $30Chicago, ILScrabble Edición en Espanol SPANISH EDITIONScrabble Edición en Espanol SPANISH EDITION$20Los Angeles, CAThe Bible Is Funny gameThe Bible Is Funny game$10Lakemoor, ILBRAND NEW THE HUNGRY BEAR TARGET LAUNCHER GAMEBRAND NEW THE HUNGRY BEAR TARGET LAUNCHER GAME$27Palatine, ILEvanstonopoly board gameEvanstonopoly board game$10Lakemoor, ILLESONG Brain Teasers Metal And Wooden Puzzles For Kids And Adults 9 Pack, Mind, IQ, And Logic Test And Handheld Disentanglement Games, 3D Coil Cast$19.99LESONG Brain Teasers Metal And Wooden Puzzles For Kids And Adults 9 Pack, Mind, IQ, And Logic Test And Handheld Disentanglement Games, 3D Coil CastAmazon.comAdBoom Again board gameBoom Again board game$15Lakemoor, ILRollick Game brand new!Rollick Game brand new!$15Lakemoor, IL