Stuffed animals
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
Anastasia 20in Squishmallow (WITH TAG)$20Hoffman Estates, IL
Vintage Cream White Cat Plush Limited Edition 9" Trading Lovable Huggable $10Chicago, IL
VTG Teddy Bear Angel Plush With Wings 7.5” Rare Collectible Toy Stuffed Animal $14Chicago, IL
Vintage Minnie Mouse Chicago Cubs Disney Pink Plush MLBP 17” Team 2014 Rare $25Chicago, IL
Vintage Mattel Disney Tigger Arcotoys RARE Plush 11”$20Chicago, IL
Vintage Chuck E Cheese Pizza Time Theatre Jasper T. Jowls Plush Dog 1980s 10” Orange Pink Super Rare $90Chicago, IL
Large 12" Vintage 1998 Painter Tweety Bird Plush - Looney Tunes Ace Play by Play$5Chicago, IL
TY Pillow Pal Baba the Purple & Yellow Plush Lamb 14" / 1998 $5Chicago, IL
Have A Good Run $45Melrose Park, IL
Vintage TY Pillow Pals Yellow 14" HUGGY the Bear Plush Toy Red Ears & Nose 1998$5Chicago, IL
Gund Barnabas Plush Teddy Bear James Fund 2006 / 46020 / 17”$15Chicago, IL
Snoopy Hallmark Valentines Kissing Bandit Animated Plush$15Palatine, IL
Unipak Plush Farm House Carrying Case with 5 Horses$20Lake Barrington, IL
Pet Simulator Dragon Plush $60Chicago, IL
Alter Egos Plush$20Chicago, IL
Five Nights At Freddy’s Black Heart Bonnie$50Chicago, IL
Five Nights At Freddy’s Easter, Bonnie$50Chicago, IL
Five Nights At Freddy’s Livewire Freddy$20Chicago, IL
Five Nights At Freddy’s Captain Foxy$25Chicago, IL
Freddy Frost, Bear Plushy$20Chicago, IL
Squishmellow $15Stickney, IL
Stitch$25Waukegan, IL
Disney Minnie Mouse and Friends Plush Animals Lot of 4 - Lion King, Goofy, Pluto$30Glendale Heights, IL
Hello Kitty Plush$30Chicago, IL
FA O Schwartz Bear Paid $1,000.00 Sacrifice $500.00$500Chicago, IL
NEW - 9" Fuzzy Dice Pillow - plush$7Chicago, IL
Large Pokémon Piplup Plush Toy 24” Brand New$50Chicago, IL
Chicago Bears Giant Teddy Bear $130Des Plaines, IL
AURORA TEDDY BEAR PLUSH NEW WITH TAG$25Streamwood, IL
EUROPEAN IMPORTS & GIFTS - GANZ GOLDEN RETRIEVER DOG TOY 14"×6"$15Chicago, IL
Disney and Pixar Inside Out 2 Flip-A-Mood Fear/Anxiety Reversible Character H$15Streamwood, IL
Pokemon Lot, Pokemon Center Exclusives, Vintage Pokemon , Pokemon Plushies, Pokemon Games, Pokemon Funko, Pokemon Collection Not Sold Separately !$600Highland Park, Illinois
Righty Beanie Baby 2000 Collection$30Chicago, IL
Wallace Beanie Baby Collection$12Chicago, IL
New Ty Chicago Bears Beanie baby $40Addison, IL
Hello Kitty Carpet$10Chicago, IL
Chicago Bears & Hockey Build A Bear Plushies $25Melrose Park, IL
Cheezer Beanie Baby 2000 Collection $16Chicago, IL
Lefty American Beanie Baby 2000 Collection$25Chicago, IL
Sonic Build a bear Plushes $300Chicago, IL
Labubu Combo$15Waukegan, IL
Vintage Disney 1998 Bouncing & Talking Tigger From Winnie The Pooh $15Gurnee, IL
Vermont Teddy Bear Panther$25Grayslake, IL
Vermont Teddy Bear$25Libertyville, IL
Canadian Bear$7,000Chicago, IL
Vintage 2002 Neopets Plush Bundle$158Lake Forest, IL
Super Mario Nintendo Bowser Jr. Plush – Used Like New$20Chicago, IL
Hello Kitty Squishmallow 20 Inches$25Chicago, IL
Hello kitty dinosaur plush$50Addison, IL
FNAF The Puppet/Marionette Plush 8” Jazwares 2025 NWT Five Nights at Freddy's$35Chicago, IL