No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Licensed stuffed animalsLicensed stuffed animals$50Chicago, ILStuffed Animal/characters Stuffed Animal/characters $10Chicago, ILNessie Crochet Stuffed AnimalNessie Crochet Stuffed Animal$300Skokie, ILJOHNNY THE GORILLA FROM SING! 9 INCH MADE BY TYJOHNNY THE GORILLA FROM SING! 9 INCH MADE BY TY$5Modesto, CAStuffed Animal BearStuffed Animal Bear$1Chicago, ILLamb Stuffed Animal MiniLamb Stuffed Animal Mini$1Chicago, ILWinnie The Pooh Stuffed AnimalWinnie The Pooh Stuffed Animal$1Chicago, ILVintage 1999 TY Osito the Mexico Mexican Flag Red Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Vintage 1999 TY Osito the Mexico Mexican Flag Red Bear Plush Stuffed Animal $15Chicago, ILPlush LION Stuffed Animal Toy w/hair-like Mane SoftPlush LION Stuffed Animal Toy w/hair-like Mane Soft$20Chicago, ILHugFun Tan Bear Plush 21 Inch Red Plaid Ears Bow Paws Stuffed Animal ToyHugFun Tan Bear Plush 21 Inch Red Plaid Ears Bow Paws Stuffed Animal Toy$20Chicago, ILStuffed AnimalsStuffed Animals$5Aurora, ILInteractive Stuffed AnimalInteractive Stuffed Animal$2Evanston, ILVintage 90s Talking Dog Plush Stuffed Animal ToyVintage 90s Talking Dog Plush Stuffed Animal Toy$20Chicago, ILTy Beanie Baby Pinata the Bear DOB 2003 (black nose)Ty Beanie Baby Pinata the Bear DOB 2003 (black nose)$15Chicago, ILThe Child/Baby Yoda Stuffed AnimalThe Child/Baby Yoda Stuffed Animal$8Melrose Park, ILDisney Goofy Plush Stuffed Animal Adult Hat CapDisney Goofy Plush Stuffed Animal Adult Hat Cap$20Chicago, ILStuffed AnimalStuffed Animal$10Schaumburg, ILBEE HAPPY KIDS BROWN LEMUR SLOTH TABLET-IPAD-BOOK STAND HOLDER STUFFED ANIMALBEE HAPPY KIDS BROWN LEMUR SLOTH TABLET-IPAD-BOOK STAND HOLDER STUFFED ANIMAL$16Wheeling, ILTy Beanie Baby Pinata the Bear DOB 2003 (black nose)Ty Beanie Baby Pinata the Bear DOB 2003 (black nose)$15Chicago, ILTy Beanie Babies - Deutschland The Germany Bear - Black Nose Mint Plush Toy (9in)Ty Beanie Babies - Deutschland The Germany Bear - Black Nose Mint Plush Toy (9in)$14Chicago, ILTy Beanie Baby “Sam” the Blue American Bear with Patriotic Hat! (8.5 inch)Ty Beanie Baby “Sam” the Blue American Bear with Patriotic Hat! (8.5 inch)$15Chicago, ILHarley Davidson Body Gaming PillowHarley Davidson Body Gaming Pillow$35Des Plaines, ILHello Kitty X Care BearHello Kitty X Care Bear$55Chicago, ILCorlas Reef Corlas Reef $70Portland, ORBison and goofy stuffed animalsBison and goofy stuffed animals$5Aurora, ILTY Pops Beanie Baby Plush Toy, Retired Collection TY Beany, Blue Maple Teddy Bear ToyTY Pops Beanie Baby Plush Toy, Retired Collection TY Beany, Blue Maple Teddy Bear Toy$11Chicago, ILnew vintage flintstones plush 90's with tagnew vintage flintstones plush 90's with tag$20Schaumburg, ILTY Beanie Baby - LEFTY 2004 the Donkey (6 inch)TY Beanie Baby - LEFTY 2004 the Donkey (6 inch)$12Chicago, ILElmo Stuffed Animals Elmo Stuffed Animals $15Hoffman Estates, ILVintage Mystic white unicorn Ty beanie baby with white yarn mane and tailVintage Mystic white unicorn Ty beanie baby with white yarn mane and tail$19Chicago, ILTy Beanie Babies Eggs III The BearTy Beanie Babies Eggs III The Bear$7Chicago, ILCuddle Barn Mother Goose Animated Talking Musical Plush Toy, 14" Super Soft Cuddly Stuffed Animal Cuddle Barn Mother Goose Animated Talking Musical Plush Toy, 14" Super Soft Cuddly Stuffed Animal $20Schiller Park, IL1 Bluey & Friends Bluey Bingo. Small Plush Set 1 Bluey & Friends Bluey Bingo. Small Plush Set $9Wildomar, CA2003 Ty beanie babies Cure2003 Ty beanie babies Cure$9Chicago, ILZURU Rainbocorns Bunny Rabbit Unicorn Plush Stuffed Animal W/ Sound - Works!ZURU Rainbocorns Bunny Rabbit Unicorn Plush Stuffed Animal W/ Sound - Works!$10Brookfield, ILTy Stuffed Animals Ty Stuffed Animals $5Buffalo Grove, ILSafari Animals Plush and Book Set - Stuffed Animals of 3 Savanna Animals Storybook- 12” Set Includes Lion, Giraffe and Elephant Colorful Children 📖Safari Animals Plush and Book Set - Stuffed Animals of 3 Savanna Animals Storybook- 12” Set Includes Lion, Giraffe and Elephant Colorful Children 📖$14Aurora, ILCollectible Anime Japan Plush Stuffed Animal ToyCollectible Anime Japan Plush Stuffed Animal Toy$20Chicago, ILRare TY BEANIERare TY BEANIE$5,000Naperville, ILPlush Toys For DonationPlush Toys For Donation$0Brookfield, ILMacaw Plush Stuffed Animal Bird Parrot LargeMacaw Plush Stuffed Animal Bird Parrot Large$25Hoffman Estates, ILChow Time BeanieChow Time Beanie$10Evanston, ILMiraculous Ladybug Zag Chibi Plush ToysMiraculous Ladybug Zag Chibi Plush Toys$24Riverside, CAMelissa And Doug Big Llama Plush Stuffed AnimalMelissa And Doug Big Llama Plush Stuffed Animal$20Brookfield, ILTickle Me ElmoTickle Me Elmo$30Chicago, ILBears Plush Stuffed Animal Toy CollectionBears Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Collection$20Chicago, ILTheSmurfs Stuffed Animal Plushie Plush ToyTheSmurfs Stuffed Animal Plushie Plush Toy$30Chicago, ILRare Disney Goofy Dog Plush Stuffed Animal ToyRare Disney Goofy Dog Plush Stuffed Animal Toy$15Chicago, ILCute Stuffed BunniesCute Stuffed Bunnies$10Lake In The Hills, ILBeanie Babies. $2ea Or 3/$5 5/$8Beanie Babies. $2ea Or 3/$5 5/$8$2Chicago, IL