Stuffed animals
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
Dalmatian Stuff Animals Over 75+$100Chicago, IL
Joyward Plush Succulent Plant Dan Dee 6” Pink Pot 2026 NWT 3+$12Worth, IL
NWOT Build-A-Bear Workshop Espeon Purple 14" Plush Pokémon w/sound$50Geneva, IL
Cuddle Barn Mother Goose Nursery Rhyme Plush$20Elgin, IL
Lion Plush$5Chicago, IL
Squishmallows $10Addison, IL
Furby Interactive Plush Toy$10Melrose Park, IL
Pudgy Penguin Huggable Plush$8Glendale Heights, IL
Dog Veterinarian Activity Toy Set$15Glendale Heights, IL
TMNT Large Plush$20Glendale Heights, IL
Plush Yellow Chickie Easter basket - new no tag $5Stickney, IL
Large plush green dragon Easter basket - used once like new$10Stickney, IL
Star Wars large 11” Yoda plush easter basket - used once like new $10Stickney, IL
Sonic Plush Pillow$20Willowbrook, IL
Yoohoo & Friends - 5" Wannabe Bunny Rabbit Bush Baby with Blue Ears and Tail$10Oswego, IL
Hello Kitty 20in Squishmallows - NEW with Tags$50Clarendon Hills, IL
Joyward Plush Succulent Plant Dan Dee 6” Blue Pot 2026 NWT 3+$12Worth, IL
where applicable), plus shipping
Vintage 1987 Muppet Babies Baby Miss Piggy and Baby Kermit Stuffed Toy Plush Animals$25Homer Glen, IL
Plush Unicorn Rocking Horse$20Chicago, IL
Rudolph The Red Nose Reindeer $55Lisle, IL
Pokemon plush Happiny$15Chicago, IL
Doctor Simi Plushie Dressed As A Cow Pre Owned$28Chicago, IL
1992 Hasbro Cabbage Patch Kids Crimp N Curl Pet Puppy Dog Plush Bandana Collar$15Homer Glen, IL
Vintage Care Bear 80s Love A Lot Plush Original 13.5"$30Homer Glen, IL
Crochet plushies$50Chicago, IL
Hello Kitty Kidrobot Kaiju plush$40Bensenville, IL
Gojo and Yuji plush!$10Chicago, IL
Sesame Street Big Bird Plush Stuffed Animal GUND 075350 14.5" Vintage 2008$20Homer Glen, IL
Red panda squishmallow$10Willowbrook, IL
Blue Corduroy Like Teddy Bear w/ Bow, Unbranded, Movable limbs, 16 inches$17Naperville, IL
Soft kirby Licensed Plush Set$15Oswego, IL
XXL Boba Cup Cat Plush$30Oswego, IL
New - Snuggle Wumps Yak’s Stuffed Pink Plush 14”$7Bolingbrook, IL
Avocado plushies stuff animals aguacate$7Chicago, IL
NWT Happy Birthday plush teddy Bear 14” with Birthday Hat $8$8Chicago, IL
Stuffed animal dog in wicked basket for easter$15Palos Park, IL
Flintstones Dino The Dinosaur Plush Stuffed Animal TV Character Play By Play 12$12Homer Glen, IL
caesar's palace cleo stuffed animal 12”$26Oswego, IL
Three Plushies$15Chicago, IL
Squishmallows$10Franklin Park, IL
Fitz and Floyd teeny tiny tails “the big winner”$15Ontarioville, IL
Vintage Genie Plush Aladdin Stuffed Animal Poseable 16" Disney Mattel 1992 Doll$19Homer Glen, IL
TEDDY BEAR BEE HONEY POT SHALOM VINTAGE $25Streamwood, IL
Hello Kitty x Starbucks Plush$50Lombard, IL
Fortnite Loot Llama Plush Piñata Epic Games Russ Small Stuffed Animal 2018 7"$15Alsip, IL
Care Bear $99Naperville, IL
Vintage Garfield Plush Stuffed Zipper Pajama Bag with Cap & Slippers Dakin 1981$55Homer Glen, IL
Dragon Ball Z Son Goku Chibi Plush Figure Loop Hangable Soft Toy Anime Fun. 6”$25Alsip, IL
Dalmatian stuff dog with easter eggs and wicker basket included$15Palos Hills, IL
Beanie Babies/tag cases/collector cards$450Joliet, IL