No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Scan to download the app

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Stuffed AnimalsStuffed Animals$35Denville, NJGanz Webkins Rooster Plush Stuffed Animal No CodeGanz Webkins Rooster Plush Stuffed Animal No Code$14Hopatcong, NJLot of 38 Stuffed Animals including Several Build a BearsLot of 38 Stuffed Animals including Several Build a Bears$40Bergenfield, NJLots Of 4 Smiling Critter Plush Lots Of 4 Smiling Critter Plush $30Tinton Falls, NJPlush Stuffed Animal CatPlush Stuffed Animal Cat$5South Brunswick Township, NJBig Plush Stuffed Red Bull 46 Inch Huge Animal NICE GoffaBig Plush Stuffed Red Bull 46 Inch Huge Animal NICE Goffa$60Clifton, NJAdorable Pig Collection of 6 Stuffed Animals and One Pillow All in Very Nice ConditionAdorable Pig Collection of 6 Stuffed Animals and One Pillow All in Very Nice Condition$18Bergenfield, NJMake Believe Ideas Aqua Blue Rhinocorn Rhino Plush Stuffed Animal ToyMake Believe Ideas Aqua Blue Rhinocorn Rhino Plush Stuffed Animal Toy$12Hopatcong, NJWalt Disney World Stitch Stuffed Animal Plush 12 InchWalt Disney World Stitch Stuffed Animal Plush 12 Inch$10Greystone Park, NJSea Otter and Starfish Stuffed Animal - Wild Republic - New York AquariumSea Otter and Starfish Stuffed Animal - Wild Republic - New York Aquarium$10Jersey City, NJChewbacca Star Wars Plush Toy Stuffed Animal 22 Inches Felt Pouch TagsChewbacca Star Wars Plush Toy Stuffed Animal 22 Inches Felt Pouch Tags$24Hopatcong, NJBarbie Dream House, Stuffed Animals, Bag Of ToysBarbie Dream House, Stuffed Animals, Bag Of Toys$35Morristown, NJSuper Cute Like New Cream and Brown Colored Build a Bear Teddy Bear with BackpackSuper Cute Like New Cream and Brown Colored Build a Bear Teddy Bear with Backpack$15Bergenfield, NJPanda Plush With Zipper Pocket Panda Plush With Zipper Pocket $10Garden Grove, CALanie's Beach Hammock American Girl Retired 2010 For 18” Doll and American Girl Ice Cream Cart Lanie's Beach Hammock American Girl Retired 2010 For 18” Doll and American Girl Ice Cream Cart $40Belleville, NJCute And Cuddly Octopus Stuffed AnimalCute And Cuddly Octopus Stuffed Animal$10Westwood, NJ3 stuffed animals3 stuffed animals$10Wood-ridge, NJLife Size White Tiger Stuffed AnimalLife Size White Tiger Stuffed Animal$60Brooklyn, NYHello Kitty Care, Bear Target Exclusive Set Of 2.Hello Kitty Care, Bear Target Exclusive Set Of 2.$75Sayreville, NJHello Kitty Valentines Greeter Hello Kitty Valentines Greeter $35Brooklyn, NYCute And Cuddle, Large Cat Stuffed Animal HomemadeCute And Cuddle, Large Cat Stuffed Animal Homemade$50Westwood, NJWailord 57” Pokémon Plush - Sold Out OnlineWailord 57” Pokémon Plush - Sold Out Online$499Milltown, NJGiant PandaGiant Panda$20Queens, NYHomies Plushie Homies Plushie $15Vista, CAFoco New York Yankees, Teddy Bear Foco New York Yankees, Teddy Bear $15Brooklyn, NYDouglas Dilly Dachshund Dog 8" Plush Stuffed Animal ToyDouglas Dilly Dachshund Dog 8" Plush Stuffed Animal Toy$12Hopatcong, NJBeanie Babies With TagsBeanie Babies With Tags$100Secaucus, NJBambi Plush – Medium 13''Bambi Plush – Medium 13''$25Brooklyn, NYAlpacasso Amuse Green Alpaca Llama Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 18 Inches TallAlpacasso Amuse Green Alpaca Llama Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 18 Inches Tall$15Hopatcong, NJStitchStitch$20Bronx, NYHappy Stuffed Narwhal Happy Stuffed Narwhal $20Bronx, NYSmall Stuffed DogSmall Stuffed Dog$15Bronx, NYHello Kitty Hello Kitty $75Torrance, CASmall Stuffed Winnie The PoohSmall Stuffed Winnie The Pooh$15Bronx, NYGiant 3 FT Penguin PlushGiant 3 FT Penguin Plush$75Clifton, NJPokemon Pikachu 32” Giant PlushiePokemon Pikachu 32” Giant Plushie$100Clifton, NJChuck E Cheese Mouse Plush 13 Inches Stuffed Animal Collectible 2013Chuck E Cheese Mouse Plush 13 Inches Stuffed Animal Collectible 2013$15Hopatcong, NJLike New Build a Bear Puppy in a TutuLike New Build a Bear Puppy in a Tutu$10Bergenfield, NJSquishmallows Maisha The Beaver Stuffed Plush Animal 8 InchesSquishmallows Maisha The Beaver Stuffed Plush Animal 8 Inches$10Hopatcong, NJAnimal Adventure Sqoosh 2 Poof Jumbo Cuddly Ultra Soft Plush Stuffed Animal DinoAnimal Adventure Sqoosh 2 Poof Jumbo Cuddly Ultra Soft Plush Stuffed Animal Dino$35Brooklyn, NYSkip Hop Toddler Plush Dinosaur Zoo Animal Dakota Dino Stuffed Animal ToySkip Hop Toddler Plush Dinosaur Zoo Animal Dakota Dino Stuffed Animal Toy$12Floral Park, NYGanz Webkinz Zumbuddy Zed A Zippy Zum Plush First Edition No CodeGanz Webkinz Zumbuddy Zed A Zippy Zum Plush First Edition No Code$8Greystone Park, NJhello kitty cvs greeter bundlehello kitty cvs greeter bundle$60Antioch, CADan Dee Peter Rabbit The Movie 2021 Sitting Plush Stuffed Animal BunnyDan Dee Peter Rabbit The Movie 2021 Sitting Plush Stuffed Animal Bunny$15Floral Park, NYBrand new Stuffed Animal Net or Hammock Wall Hanging Net for Stuffed Animal Storage Macrame Toy Display Plush Toy Holder Soft Toy organizer for NureryBrand new Stuffed Animal Net or Hammock Wall Hanging Net for Stuffed Animal Storage Macrame Toy Display Plush Toy Holder Soft Toy organizer for Nurery$7Queens, NYTroll Beenie Plush TY Babies Troll Beenie Plush TY Babies $16New York, NYAngel Dear Giraffe Plush Lovey Knotted Ends Animal PrintAngel Dear Giraffe Plush Lovey Knotted Ends Animal Print$12Hopatcong, NJFluffster Plush 2017 Julias Bunny Sea World Busch Gardens Sesame Place Fluffster Plush 2017 Julias Bunny Sea World Busch Gardens Sesame Place $25Hopatcong, NJCute Plush Gorilla Cute Plush Gorilla $20Greystone Park, NJBearington Patty Praymore Bearington Patty Praymore $15New York, NY