No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Stuffed AnimalsStuffed Animals$35Denville, NJBig Plush Stuffed Red Bull 46 Inch Huge Animal NICE GoffaBig Plush Stuffed Red Bull 46 Inch Huge Animal NICE Goffa$60Clifton, NJDisney Mickey And Minnie Mouse Christmas 2019PromotedDisney Mickey And Minnie Mouse Christmas 2019$45Queens, NY13" Cloud B GRAY HUGGINZ BUNNY RABBIT Pull String Musical Stuffed Animal, Toy13" Cloud B GRAY HUGGINZ BUNNY RABBIT Pull String Musical Stuffed Animal, Toy$20Floral Park, NY2002 Chicago Cubs Good Stuff Plush Fan Teddy Bear Lot of 22002 Chicago Cubs Good Stuff Plush Fan Teddy Bear Lot of 2$13Lake Villa, IL4Pcs-Mini Animal Plush Toy Assortment,Bulk Stuffed Animals Party Favors , Small Animals Plush Keychain Decoration, Carnival Prizes, Valentine's Day Party Favors,Backpack Pendants, Graduation Gifts, Holiday Gifts,4Pcs$3.204Pcs-Mini Animal Plush Toy Assortment,Bulk Stuffed Animals Party Favors , Small Animals Plush Keychain Decoration, Carnival Prizes, Valentine's Day Party Favors,Backpack Pendants, Graduation Gifts, Holiday Gifts,4PcssheinAdLot of 38 Stuffed Animals including Several Build a BearsLot of 38 Stuffed Animals including Several Build a Bears$40Bergenfield, NJ24" Large Plush Christmas Rocky Bullwinkle Stuffed Animal Toy Moose 1996 Macy's24" Large Plush Christmas Rocky Bullwinkle Stuffed Animal Toy Moose 1996 Macy's$20Oceanside, NYHandmade crocheted dragon lampPromotedHandmade crocheted dragon lamp$180Placentia, CANew stuffed animal (pig) approx H14” W11”New stuffed animal (pig) approx H14” W11”$10Yonkers, NYNew Stuffed animal (dog) with tag approx H15”W9”New Stuffed animal (dog) with tag approx H15”W9”$10Yonkers, NYWalt Disney World Stitch Stuffed Animal Plush 12 InchWalt Disney World Stitch Stuffed Animal Plush 12 Inch$10Greystone Park, NJSet Of 5 Realistic-Looking Toy Plush Soft Stuffed 5" Honey Bees With Crinkle Wings$23.99Set Of 5 Realistic-Looking Toy Plush Soft Stuffed 5" Honey Bees With Crinkle WingsAmazon.comAdTY International Bears IIPromotedTY International Bears II$300Vaucluse, SCAdorable Pig Collection of 6 Stuffed Animals and One Pillow All in Very Nice ConditionAdorable Pig Collection of 6 Stuffed Animals and One Pillow All in Very Nice Condition$18Bergenfield, NJSea Otter and Starfish Stuffed Animal - Wild Republic - New York AquariumSea Otter and Starfish Stuffed Animal - Wild Republic - New York Aquarium$10Jersey City, NJBarbie Dream House, Stuffed Animals, Bag Of ToysBarbie Dream House, Stuffed Animals, Bag Of Toys$35Morristown, NJHallmark Itty Bittys Star Wars Rey Stuffed Plush Toy Hallmark Itty Bittys Star Wars Rey Stuffed Plush Toy $7Floral Park, NYPikachu Plushy Backpack 🫶🏼PromotedPikachu Plushy Backpack 🫶🏼$12Claremont, CAWild Republic Black Bear Plush, Stuffed Animal, Plush Toy, Gifts For Kids, Cuddlekins 8$13.40Wild Republic Black Bear Plush, Stuffed Animal, Plush Toy, Gifts For Kids, Cuddlekins 8Amazon.comAdPokemon Pikachu 32” Giant PlushiePokemon Pikachu 32” Giant Plushie$100Clifton, NJGiant 3 FT Penguin PlushGiant 3 FT Penguin Plush$75Clifton, NJTeddy Ruxpin Answer BoxTeddy Ruxpin Answer Box$10Brooklyn, NYjumbo dragonfly squishmallow Promotedjumbo dragonfly squishmallow $30Laveen Village, AZBuild A Bear 16" Gingerbread Girl Plush Holiday Red Bow Hearts Christmas BABWBuild A Bear 16" Gingerbread Girl Plush Holiday Red Bow Hearts Christmas BABW$22Floral Park, NYDragon Tales 15" Hungry Talking ORD Stuffed Toy W/3 Cookies 1999 Playskool RareDragon Tales 15" Hungry Talking ORD Stuffed Toy W/3 Cookies 1999 Playskool Rare$43Floral Park, NYVIAHART Ola The Ostrich - 12 Inch Stuffed Animal Plush - By Tiger Tale Toys$15.99VIAHART Ola The Ostrich - 12 Inch Stuffed Animal Plush - By Tiger Tale ToysAmazon.comAdPops Collection Make Offer! Chuck Norris & More!Pops Collection Make Offer! Chuck Norris & More!$60Lyndhurst, NJOfficial Sanrio Vintage SugarBunnies Mintusa Heartland Small PlushOfficial Sanrio Vintage SugarBunnies Mintusa Heartland Small Plush$60Oceanside, NYPlay Right Corgi Pet Puppy New In BoxPlay Right Corgi Pet Puppy New In Box$14Levittown, NYTim Burton Nightmare Before Christmas Jack Skellington and Sally Plush DuoTim Burton Nightmare Before Christmas Jack Skellington and Sally Plush Duo$13Oceanside, NYGenshin Impact Fanmade Fanart Kpop Doll PlushGenshin Impact Fanmade Fanart Kpop Doll Plush$70Oceanside, NYBoku No Hero Academia My Hero Academia Izuku Midoriya Deku Kimi to Friends School Uniform PlushBoku No Hero Academia My Hero Academia Izuku Midoriya Deku Kimi to Friends School Uniform Plush$10Oceanside, NYWild Republic Okapi Plush, Stuffed Animal, Plush Toy, Gifts For Kids, Cuddlekins 12 Inches$35.93Wild Republic Okapi Plush, Stuffed Animal, Plush Toy, Gifts For Kids, Cuddlekins 12 InchesAmazon.comAdBoku no Hero Academia My Hero Academia Ochako Uraraka Medium Mochi Mascot PlushBoku no Hero Academia My Hero Academia Ochako Uraraka Medium Mochi Mascot Plush$10Oceanside, NYUsed Paw Petrol Plush ToyUsed Paw Petrol Plush Toy$6New York, NYCute And Cuddly Octopus Stuffed AnimalCute And Cuddly Octopus Stuffed Animal$10Westwood, NJ4 mario plushies4 mario plushies$60Queens, NYStuff For SellStuff For Sell$1Passaic, NJLife Size White Tiger Stuffed AnimalLife Size White Tiger Stuffed Animal$60Brooklyn, NYPrextex Plush Dinosaur Stuffed Animal, 4Pk, 10'' Cute Dinosaur Plush Toys For Boys & Girls Ages 3+, Stuffed Dinosaurs For Boys, Soft Dino Plush$25.99Prextex Plush Dinosaur Stuffed Animal, 4Pk, 10'' Cute Dinosaur Plush Toys For Boys & Girls Ages 3+, Stuffed Dinosaurs For Boys, Soft Dino PlushAmazon.comAdSuper Cute Like New Cream and Brown Colored Build a Bear Teddy Bear with BackpackSuper Cute Like New Cream and Brown Colored Build a Bear Teddy Bear with Backpack$15Bergenfield, NJLanie's Beach Hammock American Girl Retired 2010 For 18” Doll and American Girl Ice Cream Cart Lanie's Beach Hammock American Girl Retired 2010 For 18” Doll and American Girl Ice Cream Cart $40Belleville, NJFurry Key Chain CatFurry Key Chain Cat$15Tigard, ORStuffed Plushy Toys Stuffed Plushy Toys $15Bronx, NYHello Kitty Care, Bear Target Exclusive Set Of 2.Hello Kitty Care, Bear Target Exclusive Set Of 2.$75Sayreville, NJMelissa And Doug Stuffed Sting Ray Melissa And Doug Stuffed Sting Ray $10Merrick, NYBearington Henny Plush White Hen Stuffed Animal, 9 Inches$13.49Bearington Henny Plush White Hen Stuffed Animal, 9 InchesAmazon.comAdLarge Stuffed Hammerhead Shark Large Stuffed Hammerhead Shark $10Merrick, NYDisney Store Christmas Carol Minnie Mouse Animated Plush And Mickey Mouse Holiday Christmas Caroler Plush Toy Disney Store Christmas Carol Minnie Mouse Animated Plush And Mickey Mouse Holiday Christmas Caroler Plush Toy $15Oceanside, NY