No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item.
Search
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Barbie Dream House, Stuffed Animals, Bag Of ToysBarbie Dream House, Stuffed Animals, Bag Of Toys$50Morristown, NJLife Size White Tiger Stuffed AnimalLife Size White Tiger Stuffed Animal$60Brooklyn, NYDisney Mickey And Minnie Mouse Christmas 2019PromotedDisney Mickey And Minnie Mouse Christmas 2019$45Queens, NYLot of 38 Stuffed Animals including Several Build a BearsLot of 38 Stuffed Animals including Several Build a Bears$40Bergenfield, NJ6 stuff animals 6 stuff animals $18Hemet, CAJust Play Reindeer In Here 8-Inch Small Plush Stuffed Animal 2-Pack, Blizzard And Pinky, Soft Fur, Kids Toys For Ages 3 Up$11.67Just Play Reindeer In Here 8-Inch Small Plush Stuffed Animal 2-Pack, Blizzard And Pinky, Soft Fur, Kids Toys For Ages 3 UpAmazon.comAdTeddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Hand PuppetTeddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Hand Puppet$12Byram Township, NJBig Plush Stuffed Red Bull 46 Inch Huge Animal NICE GoffaBig Plush Stuffed Red Bull 46 Inch Huge Animal NICE Goffa$60Clifton, NJHalo The BearPromotedHalo The Bear$2,000Browns Mills, NJSea Otter and Starfish Stuffed Animal - Wild Republic - New York AquariumSea Otter and Starfish Stuffed Animal - Wild Republic - New York Aquarium$10Jersey City, NJStuffed AnimalStuffed Animal$15Lyndhurst, NJ3 stuffed animals3 stuffed animals$10Wood-ridge, NJWild Republic Mountain Goat Plush, Stuffed Animal, Plush Toy, Gifts For Kids, Cuddlekins 8 Inches$11.63Wild Republic Mountain Goat Plush, Stuffed Animal, Plush Toy, Gifts For Kids, Cuddlekins 8 InchesAmazon.comAdRare Vintage Beanie Baby “Glory” PromotedRare Vintage Beanie Baby “Glory” $1,000Cambria, CACute And Cuddly Octopus Stuffed AnimalCute And Cuddly Octopus Stuffed Animal$10Westwood, NJDouglas Dilly Dachshund Dog 8" Plush Stuffed Animal ToyDouglas Dilly Dachshund Dog 8" Plush Stuffed Animal Toy$12Hopatcong, NJAlpacasso Amuse Green Alpaca Llama Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 18 Inches TallAlpacasso Amuse Green Alpaca Llama Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 18 Inches Tall$15Hopatcong, NJPokemon Center x Van Gogh Museum: Pikachu Plush | IN-HAND & SHIPS FASTPokemon Center x Van Gogh Museum: Pikachu Plush | IN-HAND & SHIPS FAST$40The Bronx, NYCookie Monster Plush PromotedCookie Monster Plush $21North Chesterfield, VATAMMYFLYFLY Lifelike Hedgehog Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Desert Hedgehog Cute Animal Model (6 Inches) (6 In(Pack Of 4))$29.90TAMMYFLYFLY Lifelike Hedgehog Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Desert Hedgehog Cute Animal Model (6 Inches) (6 In(Pack Of 4))Amazon.comAdChuck E Cheese Mouse Plush 13 Inches Stuffed Animal Collectible 2013Chuck E Cheese Mouse Plush 13 Inches Stuffed Animal Collectible 2013$15Hopatcong, NJBrand New Trumpy BearBrand New Trumpy Bear$60Staten Island, NYThe Grinch Collection The Grinch Collection $300South River, NJStuff AnimalsPromotedStuff Animals$10Madera, CACute And Cuddle, Large Cat Stuffed Animal HomemadeCute And Cuddle, Large Cat Stuffed Animal Homemade$50Westwood, NJSquishmallows Maisha The Beaver Stuffed Plush Animal 8 InchesSquishmallows Maisha The Beaver Stuffed Plush Animal 8 Inches$10Hopatcong, NJVIAHART Seamus The Seagull - 12 Inch Stuffed Animal Plush - By Tiger Tale Toys$12.99VIAHART Seamus The Seagull - 12 Inch Stuffed Animal Plush - By Tiger Tale ToysAmazon.comAdSkip Hop Toddler Plush Dinosaur Zoo Animal Dakota Dino Stuffed Animal ToySkip Hop Toddler Plush Dinosaur Zoo Animal Dakota Dino Stuffed Animal Toy$12Floral Park, NYDan Dee Peter Rabbit The Movie 2021 Sitting Plush Stuffed Animal BunnyDan Dee Peter Rabbit The Movie 2021 Sitting Plush Stuffed Animal Bunny$15Floral Park, NY4 Child Stuffed Animals. 4 Child Stuffed Animals. $6Hoboken, NJAnimal Adventure Sqoosh 2 Poof Jumbo Cuddly Ultra Soft Plush Stuffed Animal DinoAnimal Adventure Sqoosh 2 Poof Jumbo Cuddly Ultra Soft Plush Stuffed Animal Dino$35Brooklyn, NYBrand new Stuffed Animal Net or Hammock Wall Hanging Net for Stuffed Animal Storage Macrame Toy Display Plush Toy Holder Soft Toy organizer for NureryBrand new Stuffed Animal Net or Hammock Wall Hanging Net for Stuffed Animal Storage Macrame Toy Display Plush Toy Holder Soft Toy organizer for Nurery$7Queens, NY50 Teddy bear Favor Shower Boxes50 Teddy bear Favor Shower Boxes$20Brooklyn, NYWild Republic Black Bear Plush, Stuffed Animal, Plush Toy, Gifts For Kids, Cuddlekins 12 Inches$17.99Wild Republic Black Bear Plush, Stuffed Animal, Plush Toy, Gifts For Kids, Cuddlekins 12 InchesAmazon.comAdIKEA Plush Panda Bear KRAMIG Plush Stuffed Animal Baby Toy FloppyIKEA Plush Panda Bear KRAMIG Plush Stuffed Animal Baby Toy Floppy$15Hopatcong, NJPlushiePlushie$30Brooklyn, NYKellytoy Giraffe Plush 10 Inches Stuffed Rattle Crinkle Ears Animal Toy 18” RAREKellytoy Giraffe Plush 10 Inches Stuffed Rattle Crinkle Ears Animal Toy 18” RARE$25Floral Park, NY3 Plush Animals 3 Plush Animals $10Woodbridge Township, NJDisney 16” Mickey Disney 16” Mickey $12Woodbridge Township, NJ51” Plush snake 51” Plush snake $10Woodbridge Township, NJTuko Stuffed Animal, Large Elephant Stuffed Animal, 24 Inches/Grey$25.99Tuko Stuffed Animal, Large Elephant Stuffed Animal, 24 Inches/GreyAmazon.comAdMind craft Squid Plush Mind craft Squid Plush $12Woodbridge Township, NJBig Plush Big Plush $10Woodbridge Township, NJLED star plushLED star plush$20Fort Worth, TXPrextex Green Dinosaur Plush Yellow Spots Stuffed Animal Toy BrachiosaurusPrextex Green Dinosaur Plush Yellow Spots Stuffed Animal Toy Brachiosaurus$8South Hackensack, NJGiant 3 FT Penguin PlushieGiant 3 FT Penguin Plushie$75Clifton, NJPokemon Pikachu 32” Giant PlushiePokemon Pikachu 32” Giant Plushie$120Clifton, NJAurora® Adorable Miyoni® Puffin Stuffed Animal - Lifelike Detail - Cherished Companionship - Black 10.5 Inches$18.90Aurora® Adorable Miyoni® Puffin Stuffed Animal - Lifelike Detail - Cherished Companionship - Black 10.5 InchesAmazon.comAdBig Teddy's 🧸 AllBig Teddy's 🧸 All$20Queens, NYMy Melody PlushMy Melody Plush$20Queens, NY