No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Disney Mickey Mouse 90th Anniversary Plush KeychainDisney Mickey Mouse 90th Anniversary Plush Keychain$16Williamsville, NYDisney Toy Story Lotso 5” PlushDisney Toy Story Lotso 5” Plush$12Williamsville, NYA Cute Teddy Bear For SaleA Cute Teddy Bear For Sale$4Cheektowaga, NYGitzy Christmas BearGitzy Christmas Bear$10North Canton, OHA Owl Teddy Bear For SaleA Owl Teddy Bear For Sale$3Buffalo, NYDokiDoki Dinosaur Era Triceratops PlushDokiDoki Dinosaur Era Triceratops Plush$18Williamsville, NYDisney Nemo 5” PlushDisney Nemo 5” Plush$12Williamsville, NYDisney Cars Lightning McQueen 5” PlushDisney Cars Lightning McQueen 5” Plush$14Williamsville, NYSuper Mario All Star Collection 8" Blue Toad PlushSuper Mario All Star Collection 8" Blue Toad Plush$18Williamsville, NYTy Beanie BabiesTy Beanie Babies$40Buffalo, NYTons Of Ty Beanie Babies STons Of Ty Beanie Babies S$40Buffalo, NYTy Beanie BabiesTy Beanie Babies$40Buffalo, NYLambchop Hand PuppetLambchop Hand Puppet$25Orchard Park, NYStuffed plushiesStuffed plushies$25Donna, TXBrand New With Tags Astronaut PlushBrand New With Tags Astronaut Plush$15Buffalo, NYEaster StuffEaster Stuff$25Buffalo, NYDisney Luca Machiavelli Small PlushDisney Luca Machiavelli Small Plush$30Williamsville, NYSSSS.Gridman Alexis Kerib Small PlushSSSS.Gridman Alexis Kerib Small Plush$22Williamsville, NYWeighted stuffed Animal 10lbsWeighted stuffed Animal 10lbs$25Hamburg, NYDisney Luca Giulia Small PlushDisney Luca Giulia Small Plush$22Williamsville, NYDisney Minnie Mouse 2022 Easter Bunny PlushDisney Minnie Mouse 2022 Easter Bunny Plush$20Williamsville, NYPokémon Manphy PlushPokémon Manphy Plush$26Williamsville, NYHandmade Crochet Bumblebee Handmade Crochet Bumblebee $10West Seneca, NYRARE TY McDonalds Teenie Beanie Baby Mini ERIN the Bear 1997 RETIRED WITH ERRORS RARE TY McDonalds Teenie Beanie Baby Mini ERIN the Bear 1997 RETIRED WITH ERRORS $1,500Miami Beach, FLCare Bears Care Bears $25Buffalo, NYGund Peek A Boo BearGund Peek A Boo Bear$28Hamburg, NYStar Twinkle PreCure Keychain Pretty Cure Fuwa PlushStar Twinkle PreCure Keychain Pretty Cure Fuwa Plush$16Williamsville, NYPokémon Spinda All Star PlushPokémon Spinda All Star Plush$30Williamsville, NYGund “Tracker” Grizzly BearGund “Tracker” Grizzly Bear$10Hamburg, NYBrand New With Tags Disney Pluto Tsum TsumBrand New With Tags Disney Pluto Tsum Tsum$7Buffalo, NY24k Polar Puff “Hubie” Bear24k Polar Puff “Hubie” Bear$9Hamburg, NYStill Looks New Bear Still Looks New Bear $25West Seneca, NYDISNEY “TSUM TSUM” MICKEY MOUSE & MINNIIE MOUSE PLUSH SETDISNEY “TSUM TSUM” MICKEY MOUSE & MINNIIE MOUSE PLUSH SET$6Bakersfield, CAIce Kirby plush With TagIce Kirby plush With Tag$10Williamsville, NYStitch Stuffed AnimalStitch Stuffed Animal$45Buffalo, NYDisney Rainbow Collection Stitch Plush Backpack Keychain Clip-OnDisney Rainbow Collection Stitch Plush Backpack Keychain Clip-On$10Williamsville, NYBeanie Babies $5 Ea Or A Bundle Deal For All Located In BlasdellBeanie Babies $5 Ea Or A Bundle Deal For All Located In Blasdell$5Blasdell, NYCurious, George Curious, George $15Buffalo, NYWebkinz FrogWebkinz Frog$5Niagara Falls, NYPokemon Growlithe 6" PlushPokemon Growlithe 6" Plush$18Williamsville, NYDisney The Little Mermaid Keychain Sebastian PlushDisney The Little Mermaid Keychain Sebastian Plush$16Williamsville, NYMy Little Pony 7” Izzy Moonbow PlushMy Little Pony 7” Izzy Moonbow Plush$8Williamsville, NYBuild A Bear StuffBuild A Bear Stuff$100Bellmawr, NJHomies Stuffed animalHomies Stuffed animal$15West Seneca, NYOld Stuffed AnimalsOld Stuffed Animals$35West Seneca, NYStuffed animalsStuffed animals$30West Seneca, NYTom and Jerry Angry Tom Toreba PlushTom and Jerry Angry Tom Toreba Plush$40Williamsville, NYPokemon Moltres 6" PlushPokemon Moltres 6" Plush$22Williamsville, NYBrand New With Tags Hallmark All Decked Out PenguinBrand New With Tags Hallmark All Decked Out Penguin$29Buffalo, NY100 Anniversary Of The Teddy Bear100 Anniversary Of The Teddy Bear$20Niagara Falls, NY