No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Scan to download the app

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Disney Mickey & Minnie Mouse Plush Easter 2020 Limited EditionDisney Mickey & Minnie Mouse Plush Easter 2020 Limited Edition$35Albany, NYPikachu Easter PeepPikachu Easter Peep$20Menands, NYNessie Crochet Stuffed AnimalPromotedNessie Crochet Stuffed Animal$275Skokie, ILPersonalized Easter Peeps Personalized Easter Peeps $15Menands, NYTeddy Bear BagTeddy Bear Bag$15Hacienda Heights, CA1-800-Flowers Gifts Delivery Sea Sparkle Mermaid Sea Sparkles Mermaid$19.991-800-Flowers Gifts Delivery Sea Sparkle Mermaid Sea Sparkles Mermaid1800Flowers.comAdCrochet Stuffed Animal And Stuff Crochet Stuffed Animal And Stuff $50Pittsfield, MATurtle Stuffed AnimalTurtle Stuffed Animal$20Kingston, NYSafari Stuffed AnimalsPromotedSafari Stuffed Animals$20Bellflower, CATY Inc. Disney 2013 Mickey Mouse Soft Plush Ball Shaped Stuffed Toy CollectibleTY Inc. Disney 2013 Mickey Mouse Soft Plush Ball Shaped Stuffed Toy Collectible$12Slingerlands, NY1999 TY McDonalds Teenie Beanie Britannia Bear Bundle Of 31999 TY McDonalds Teenie Beanie Britannia Bear Bundle Of 3$15Rhinebeck, NYPrincess Diana Bennie Babies Princess Diana Bennie Babies $8,800Canaan, NYNew York Yankees Wubbanub Bear Plush And Pacifier$19.99New York Yankees Wubbanub Bear Plush And PacifierMLB ShopAdFuzz Beanie Baby Misprinted PromotedFuzz Beanie Baby Misprinted $60Horn Lake, MSGlory The BearGlory The Bear$28Canaan, NYTy Beanie BabiesTy Beanie Babies$120Rensselaer, NYAnimal Stuffed AnimalAnimal Stuffed Animal$2Albany, NYLarge Stuffed AnimalLarge Stuffed Animal$5Hudson, NYTANGY Tan Cat 2006 Ty Classic Stuffed Animal Plush Toy w/ Tags TySilk Great 12”PromotedTANGY Tan Cat 2006 Ty Classic Stuffed Animal Plush Toy w/ Tags TySilk Great 12”$55Biscayne Park, FLBoston Red Sox Wubbanub Bear Plush And Pacifier$19.99Boston Red Sox Wubbanub Bear Plush And PacifierMLB ShopAd1999 McDonalds Beanie Babies Legends Trio1999 McDonalds Beanie Babies Legends Trio$200Pittsfield, MA1999 McDonalds Beanie Babies American Trio1999 McDonalds Beanie Babies American Trio$200Pittsfield, MA1999 McDonalds Beanie Babies Dinosaur Trio1999 McDonalds Beanie Babies Dinosaur Trio$200Pittsfield, MAAssorted stuffed animalsPromotedAssorted stuffed animals$40Miami, FL1999 McDonalds Beanie Babies International Bears 21999 McDonalds Beanie Babies International Bears 2$200Pittsfield, MAStuffed animalStuffed animal$9STUYVSNT PLZ, NYPlush Bunny Stuffed Animals & Plush Toys, Plushies, Soft Toys,Brown,All-New,Temu$8.99Plush Bunny Stuffed Animals & Plush Toys, Plushies, Soft Toys,Brown,All-New,TemuTemuAdEeyore stuffed animalsEeyore stuffed animals$5Coeymans Hollow, NYEeyore stuffed animalsEeyore stuffed animals$5Coeymans Hollow, NYStuffed Animal-Thanksgiving And Christmas Stuffed Animal-Thanksgiving And Christmas $4Albany, NYSven From FrozenSven From Frozen$25Kingston, NYMacy's Holiday 2010 Smurf Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Santa Hat Scarf #CMacy's Holiday 2010 Smurf Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Santa Hat Scarf #C$15Albany, NYToy Felt Pizza Toy Felt Pizza $12East Greenbush, NY4Pcs-Mini Animal Plush Toy Assortment,Bulk Stuffed Animals Party Favors , Small Animals Plush Keychain Decoration, Carnival Prizes, Valentine's Day Party Favors,Backpack Pendants, Graduation Gifts, Holiday Gifts,4Pcs$3.204Pcs-Mini Animal Plush Toy Assortment,Bulk Stuffed Animals Party Favors , Small Animals Plush Keychain Decoration, Carnival Prizes, Valentine's Day Party Favors,Backpack Pendants, Graduation Gifts, Holiday Gifts,4PcssheinAdNew Teddy BearNew Teddy Bear$20Catskill, NYTeddy Bear Teddy Bear $25Catskill, NY(Like New)[Rare] Twin Spotted Rattlesnake Plush(Like New)[Rare] Twin Spotted Rattlesnake Plush$100Red Hook, NY(New) Life-like Black Lab Plush Doll(New) Life-like Black Lab Plush Doll$120Rhinebeck, NYThe Cutest Rabbit stuffed Miss matched misfit plushThe Cutest Rabbit stuffed Miss matched misfit plush$15Albany, NYBunch of Elmo fun talking doll slippers and stickersBunch of Elmo fun talking doll slippers and stickers$25Albany, NYJumbo Generic Plush 12in-14in Mix 4$183.98Jumbo Generic Plush 12in-14in Mix 4Gumball.comAdPlush White Tiger Plush White Tiger $35Albany, NYBUGS BUNNYBUGS BUNNY$45Saugerties, NYJack-o’-lantern build a bear plushJack-o’-lantern build a bear plush$30Burlington, NJRARE Priscilla Blue Peacock Squishmallow 16” New With TagsRARE Priscilla Blue Peacock Squishmallow 16” New With Tags$60Rensselaer, NY2023 Squishmallow 8” CILLIAN the PASTEL BLUE EASTER COW NWT VERY RARE BRAND NEW2023 Squishmallow 8” CILLIAN the PASTEL BLUE EASTER COW NWT VERY RARE BRAND NEW$25Rensselaer, NYSquishmallow Harrison the Dog 10” Stuffed PlushSquishmallow Harrison the Dog 10” Stuffed Plush$30Rensselaer, NYSteiff Urs Riding Bear Stuffed Rocker - Premium Soft Woven Plush Animal Ride-On With Wooden Base And Handles - For Kids Ages 4 And Up$442.18Steiff Urs Riding Bear Stuffed Rocker - Premium Soft Woven Plush Animal Ride-On With Wooden Base And Handles - For Kids Ages 4 And UpAmazon.comAdRaggedy Andy dollRaggedy Andy doll$2Feura Bush, NYPokémon Center 30cm Legendary Plush Lot Hard To Find! Make me a reasonable Offer!Pokémon Center 30cm Legendary Plush Lot Hard To Find! Make me a reasonable Offer!$300Lee, MABig bearBig bear$100Slingerlands, NY"Rescue". Original FDNY Beenie Baby. 911"Rescue". Original FDNY Beenie Baby. 911$30Phoenicia, NYTy Beanie Babies Ballz Gumdrop Rainbow Pink Caterpillar Ladybug Plush Toy 5inchTy Beanie Babies Ballz Gumdrop Rainbow Pink Caterpillar Ladybug Plush Toy 5inch$20Glenmont, NYTy Beanie Boos - NACHO the 6" Chihuahua Dog MINT with MINT TAGTy Beanie Boos - NACHO the 6" Chihuahua Dog MINT with MINT TAG$50Glenmont, NYReshma The Strawberry Cow Squishmallow Clip 3.5”Reshma The Strawberry Cow Squishmallow Clip 3.5”$14Mulberry, FLBearBear$60Rensselaer, NY