Stuffed animals & Plush
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
Call of duty zombie bunny$60Penfield, NY
Custom Stuffed Animal Hammock $25Rochester, NY
TY Teenie Beanie Babies (entire lot)$100Greece, NY
Safari Pluto (Disney)$20Greece, NY
Paw Patrol Skye Stuffie & Airplane$15Elba, NY
Unicorn Bouncy Pals Horse Plush Hopping Animal Ride On$10Greece, NY
Ty "Princess" Beanie Baby bear$10Bloomfield, NY
Monster Inc.. Crochet $25Rochester, NY
12 inch Pink Monochorme Hello Kitty$15Rochester, NY
Hello Kitty X Care Bear My Melody $15Rochester, NY
Hello Kitty X Care Bear$30Rochester, NY
Plushies$10Rochester, NY
Cat In The Hat Plush Toy Like New$5Westgate, NY
TY collectible Stuffed Animals $7Canandaigua, NY
Full TY set $60Canandaigua, NY
Teddy Bear Ride On Rocker $35Rochester, NY
BROWN Bear FIFA SOCCER RARE Find. Size 15” $55Wadsworth, NY
Groovy Girls DREAMTASTIC Doll Plush Toy 15”. Manhattan Toys 2005 $31Wadsworth, NY
Ty Classic Tall Giraffe Plush Hightops 2003 Beanie Stuffed Animal Soft 16" $49Wadsworth, NY
Hershey Park Chocolate silver shiny Plush Stuff toy. 2016 $36Wadsworth, NY
Vintage Ty Beanie Buddy Humphrey The Camel 1998 Retired . With Ear Tag $48Wadsworth, NY
TY Pluffies “Tiptop” the Giraffe Plush (9.5 inch) without ear tag $50Wadsworth, NY
Pick Ford Bear "Cody" The Brass Button Bear collection vintage american Flag $73Wadsworth, NY
Ty "B.B. Bear" the Birthday Bear Beanie Baby, Vintage, Rare and Retired $43Wadsworth, NY
Vintage Coca-Cola Polar Bear 1993 Plush Red Scarf . Size 11” $28Wadsworth, NY
2021 Super Mario Stuffed Plush Figure White Hat Red Overalls Nintendo $27Wadsworth, NY
Green Frog- Animal Adventure- Size 13” Plush $25Wadsworth, NY
Gund Penguin Vintage Plush Christmas Pals Large 14” Stuffed Animal Xmas … $43Wadsworth, NY
WILD REPUBLIC Baby Polar Bear Cub 14”WWF Adoption Plush ADORABLE $35Wadsworth, NY
The Toy Factory Dreamworks Trolls 2016 Plush Blue Hair Doll Stuffed Toy … $41Wadsworth, NY
TY Beanie Babies Collection Ears The Rabbit April 18,1995 Rare - Great Condition $39Wadsworth, NY
Baby Yoda$25Mendon, NY
Vintage Bravo! Hand Puppet Plush by Applause With Tags Hilda the Cow 13913 11.5"$40Wadsworth, NY
Vintage Boyds Bears Bee Happy Brown Teddy in Bee Dress Excellent Used Condition $35Wadsworth, NY
Vintage Athens 2004 FIFA World Cup Coca-Cola White Polar Bear w Soccer Ball $35Wadsworth, NY
Vintage Applause Disney Pluto 14” Plush Excellent Used Condition Vintage Disney $45Wadsworth, NY
Vintage Animal Playthings Dog Puppet 1986 Brown Puppy Dog Excellent Used Con… $75Wadsworth, NY
Sesame Street Elmo Plush Toy Stuffed Animal 2020 Excellent Condition 12” Red $35Wadsworth, NY
Sesame Street Beanie Cookie Monster 39369 TYCO The Jim Henson Company EUC 8” ‘98 $45Wadsworth, NY
Sequoia the Brown Bear 2001 Ty Original Beanie Baby NWT Excellent Condition $35Wadsworth, NY
September the Birthday Bear 2001 Ty Beanie Baby in Mint Condition with all tags $35Wadsworth, NY
Sears Christmas Bear KRINGLE 2000 Exclusive 8" tall Plush & Beans NWT EUC teddy $35Wadsworth, NY
scurry the beetle Ty beanie baby 2000 excellent condition with all tags attached $35Wadsworth, NY
Classic Gund Style Beautiful Teddy Bear in White Excellent Used Condition Tan $30Wadsworth, NY
Cinnamon Made Specially for Bath & Body Works Excellent Condition w Soft Bow $35Wadsworth, NY
Cinders the Black Bear (RETIRED) 2000 Original Beanie Baby Ty Inc. NWT EUC 5” $35Wadsworth, NY
Chrisha Playful Plush Apricot Large Bear Excellent Condition 12” tall sitting $55Wadsworth, NY
Vintage Gund Black Bear with Red & Black Plaid Bow Excellent Condition 6" tall$45Wadsworth, NY
Vintage Lil Peepers by Russ Berrie Ally the Ant Yellow and Brown Ant Good Used C$35Wadsworth, NY
Vintage Ganz 1996 Billy Bunny Item #HE2188 Brown Bunny with Bow Excellent Cond...$45Wadsworth, NY