No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Scan to download the app

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Peter Rabbit Stuffed Animal. New With Tags OnPeter Rabbit Stuffed Animal. New With Tags On$9Rochester, NYBuild a Bear Super Mario Bowser King Koopa Plush 2018 Stuffed Animal NintendoBuild a Bear Super Mario Bowser King Koopa Plush 2018 Stuffed Animal Nintendo$30Canandaigua, NYFuzz Beanie Baby Misprinted PromotedFuzz Beanie Baby Misprinted $60Horn Lake, MSBuild A Bear Pikachu Pokemon Plush 18" 2017 Stuffed Animal Soft Toy working talkBuild A Bear Pikachu Pokemon Plush 18" 2017 Stuffed Animal Soft Toy working talk$25Canandaigua, NYTeam Varsity Bear (Ohio State)Team Varsity Bear (Ohio State)$30Northwood, OHAudubon Ii American Robin Stuffed Animal 5.5"$10.00Audubon Ii American Robin Stuffed Animal 5.5"FaireAdPokemon Talking Light Up Pikachu Plush WCT Wicked Cool Toy Stuffed Animal 2018Pokemon Talking Light Up Pikachu Plush WCT Wicked Cool Toy Stuffed Animal 2018$15Canandaigua, NYSquishmallows Zero ,8'' Nightmare Before Christmas. New With TagsSquishmallows Zero ,8'' Nightmare Before Christmas. New With Tags$20Canandaigua, NYSafari Stuffed AnimalsPromotedSafari Stuffed Animals$20Bellflower, CATy Beanie Babies Daisy the Cow RetiredTy Beanie Babies Daisy the Cow Retired$45Westgate, NYTy Beanie Baby Kicks The Soccer Bear Ty Beanie Baby Kicks The Soccer Bear $1,200Westgate, NYTy Beanie Baby 1999 Signature Bear Ty Beanie Baby 1999 Signature Bear $200Westgate, NYArmadillo Neck Pillow Plush Stuffed Animal$30.00Armadillo Neck Pillow Plush Stuffed AnimalFaireAdCurious GeorgePromotedCurious George$20Kenner, LATy BEANIE BABIES THE END Ty BEANIE BABIES THE END $100Westgate, NYTy Beanie Babies Valentino 1994 Ty Beanie Babies Valentino 1994 $1,000Westgate, NYTy Beanie Babies Valentina Bear 1999 Rare Ty Beanie Babies Valentina Bear 1999 Rare $1,000Westgate, NYTyco 1999 Magic Talking Kermit The Frog Plush 30th AnniversaryTyco 1999 Magic Talking Kermit The Frog Plush 30th Anniversary$35Canandaigua, NYPersonalized Emotional SUPPORT DOLLPromotedPersonalized Emotional SUPPORT DOLL$39Walnut Creek, CAMini Multicolored Assorted Stuffed Animal Toy$8.00Mini Multicolored Assorted Stuffed Animal ToyFaireAdThe Simpsons Maggie Vintage Plush Toy Matt Grogning 9 "The Simpsons Maggie Vintage Plush Toy Matt Grogning 9 "$15Westgate, NYCare Bears Care Bears $1,000Fairport, NYAmerican Bears Teddy Bear 100 Th Anniversary LenoxAmerican Bears Teddy Bear 100 Th Anniversary Lenox$16Gates-north Gates, NYDisney Mickey And Minnie Mouse Christmas 2019PromotedDisney Mickey And Minnie Mouse Christmas 2019$45Queens, NYBuild a Bear Workshop Scooby Doo Plush Stuffed Animal 14" Sounds pjs collarBuild a Bear Workshop Scooby Doo Plush Stuffed Animal 14" Sounds pjs collar$100Canandaigua, NYBulbasaur squirtle Plush TOMY 2017 Pokemon Nintendo 6" Tall Bulbasaur squirtle Plush TOMY 2017 Pokemon Nintendo 6" Tall $15Canandaigua, NYRicky The Maine Coon | 16 Inch Stuffed Animal Plush$22.00Ricky The Maine Coon | 16 Inch Stuffed Animal PlushFaireAdBuild A Bear How To Train Your Dragon Toothless, Stormfly & Light Fury BABWBuild A Bear How To Train Your Dragon Toothless, Stormfly & Light Fury BABW$45Canandaigua, NYLarge Shrek 2 Shrek Soft Plush Toy DreamWorks Animation 2004 Play By Play 18”Large Shrek 2 Shrek Soft Plush Toy DreamWorks Animation 2004 Play By Play 18”$35Canandaigua, NYFamily Guy Stewie Griffin Plush 15" 2014 Toy FactoryFamily Guy Stewie Griffin Plush 15" 2014 Toy Factory$15Canandaigua, NYBouncy Pals Unicorn Wrist Pal PlushBouncy Pals Unicorn Wrist Pal Plush$5Greece, NYBuild-A-Bear Pokémon Eevee Plush, BAB, 2017, 16 inch, Standard (no cape/sound)Build-A-Bear Pokémon Eevee Plush, BAB, 2017, 16 inch, Standard (no cape/sound)$25Canandaigua, NYMelissa And Doug Plush Winged Dragon _ 4 Ft TallMelissa And Doug Plush Winged Dragon _ 4 Ft Tall$45Greece, NY8" Long Leg Plush Assortment LLB Plush Toys$8.008" Long Leg Plush Assortment LLB Plush ToysFaireAd2000 Righty Beanie Baby Elephant 2000 Righty Beanie Baby Elephant $45Gates-north Gates, NY16” My Little Pony Build a Bear Orange Yellow/Apple Jack Plush 16” My Little Pony Build a Bear Orange Yellow/Apple Jack Plush $20Canandaigua, NYStar Wars M&M's World 12" Plush Yellow M&M Darth Vader w/ Lightsaber lot of 2Star Wars M&M's World 12" Plush Yellow M&M Darth Vader w/ Lightsaber lot of 2$25Canandaigua, NYStrawberry Patchwork Glass Teddy BearStrawberry Patchwork Glass Teddy Bear$25Victor, NYRocking Horse: 23” L X 18” H to Seat, 26” H From Floor to the Top of the Horses Head, EC, NewRocking Horse: 23” L X 18” H to Seat, 26” H From Floor to the Top of the Horses Head, EC, New$45Rochester, NYHello kitty stuffed animalHello kitty stuffed animal$0Rochester, NYStuffed Animal The Beluga Big Freckled$189.00Stuffed Animal The Beluga Big FreckledFaireAdCorgsky Stuffed Animal FAO SchwarzCorgsky Stuffed Animal FAO Schwarz$15Webster, NYCute Valentine's Stuffed ToyCute Valentine's Stuffed Toy$5East Rochester, NYBruce Walrus Squishmallows NWTBruce Walrus Squishmallows NWT$9El Monte, CAStuff AnimalStuff Animal$5Westgate, NYBeanie BanyBeanie Bany$5Westgate, NYStuffed Animal Stuffed Animal $1Rochester, NYArmadillo 22" Plush Realistic Stuffed Animal$30.00Armadillo 22" Plush Realistic Stuffed AnimalFaireAdHEART TO HEART TEDDY BEAR HEART TO HEART TEDDY BEAR $15Gates-north Gates, NY2010 CHRISTMAS SNOWFLAKE TEDDY BEAR 2010 CHRISTMAS SNOWFLAKE TEDDY BEAR $15Gates-north Gates, NY