Stuffed animals
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
Vintage 2002 Sesame Street Cookie Monster 12" Plush Stuffed Animal $36Eastlake, OH
Playmakers Teddy Bear Collectors Series Tag Label Fully Jointed Adorable $28Eastlake, OH
Webkinz Ganz Mountain Goat. No code. Size 10” $33Eastlake, OH
hello kitty key chain $16Medina, OH
Giant Teddy Bear$45Cleveland, OH
Ty Rocket The Blue Jay Bird Beanie Baby Plush 6” Stuffed Animal Toy $22Eastlake, OH
Ty Beanie Baby Tucker The German Shepherd Dog MINT 2015 in Hand $25Eastlake, OH
Ty MYSTIC the UNICORN Beanie Babies baby plush horn 1(contact info removed). NWT $40Eastlake, OH
Vtg Velveteen Bean bear 8" Palace Yeoman Tower London Guard Beefeater GB UK $21Eastlake, OH
Gund Love Peach Gund Brendall Bear. Size 16” $39Eastlake, OH
Squishmallows$35Chippewa Lake, OH
Halloween Stuff $25Cleveland, OH
Dopey$25Strongsville, OH
Pouting Face Vintage 1950s Plush Bear$50Northfield, OH
Squishmallows! $225Parma, OH
Rare Mint Ty Millennium the Bear $200Westlake, OH
Energizer Bunny Stuffed Toy $60Cleveland, OH
Dory Finding Nemo Stuffed Toy Plush $40Cleveland, OH
labubu$75Cleveland, OH
Dottie Ty Beanie Baby $9Sheffield Lake, OH
Spangle Ty Beanie Baby $9Sheffield Lake, OH
Hand crocheted snake approximately 26" long. $8 each$8Brunswick, OH
Bear Break Metallic$25Lakewood, OH
Bulk Bear Squishmillow N More Only 20$ $20Parma, OH
Vintage victorian bear with smaller bear$16Eastlake, Ohio
Stuffed Animals$30Cleveland, OH
Pink Labubu$80Garfield Heights, OH
Supreme ty Beanie Baby Multicolor $40Willoughby, OH
Stuffed animals$5North Olmsted, OH
Penguin Jules$50Cleveland, OH
⟡COMPLETE⟡ Hawaiian Monk Seal Set (no original box)$35Parma Heights, OH
STARBUCKS Red Apron Bearista Bear Limited Edition 2016 Collectible Plush Toy $30Cleveland, OH
Jazzwares PEPPA PIG in red dress Plush Stuffed Toy 7" 2003$25Cleveland, OH
Pokemon Chimchar LARGE 22" Character Plush Toy Factory 2022 Nintendo Hangable$30Cleveland, OH
Folkmanis Realistic Grey White Wolf Plush Full Body Hand Puppet 2898 With Tags $65Cleveland, OH
Folkmanis Porcupine Hand Puppet Brown Fur Animal Plush Kids Educational Toy $40Cleveland, OH
NEW BUILD A BEAR MCDONALDS HAPPY MEAL PLUSH TOY$12Cleveland, OH
HTF Sing 2 Ash Porcupine Plush 9” Red Jacket Black Plaid stuffed Toy New$60Cleveland, OH
Official Licensed Pokemon Pikachu Plush Stuffed Toy Kids Large 24" Authentic New$35Cleveland, OH
Vintage UNIPAK Aunt Ginnie’s Antique Bear Collection Style #2146-10 EUC NWT 10” $50Cleveland, OH
Vintage Original Ty Beanie Baby Ears the Brown and White Rabbit Good Used Cond… $25Cleveland, OH
Vintage Mattel Eeyore Stuffed Animal from Winnie the Pooh Excellent Condition $40Cleveland, OH
Vintage Wrinkles Plush Puppy Dog Hand Puppet Grey Beige Stuffed Animal Toy 16” $40Cleveland, OH
Vintage Wrinkles The Dog Hand Puppet Plush Stuffed Ganz Chocolate Brown 1981 18" $70Cleveland, OH
Vintage Warner Bros Inc Daffy Duck Stuff Plush Toy 1990 Looney Tunes Characters $45Cleveland, OH
RARE 1997 Teddy TY Mint Condition W/ ERROR’S$1Olmsted Falls, OH
National Geographic Arctic Tale Polar Bear 12” long Excellent Used Condition $35Cleveland, OH
NASCAR MATT KENSETH Team Caliber TEDDY BEAR Plush Stuffed Toy 8" Yellow GUC $35Cleveland, OH
NASCAR Jeff Gordon The Intimidator Teddy Bear by Boyd’s Bears 1(contact info removed) Vintage $45Cleveland, OH
Mr. the Groom Bear with sparkles 2001 Vintage NWT Excellent Condition 9” $35Cleveland, OH