No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Scan to download the app

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

New Stuffed Animal Reindeer New Stuffed Animal Reindeer $6Toledo, OHStuffed Animal Lamb Very Cute Stuffed Animal Lamb Very Cute $4Toledo, OHUsed Stuffed Bunny Used Stuffed Bunny $5Toledo, OH CURRICULUM ASSOCIATES iREADY '" ROCKIE " BULLDOG PLUSH ANIMAL TOY CURRICULUM ASSOCIATES iREADY '" ROCKIE " BULLDOG PLUSH ANIMAL TOY $19Lynwood, CAUsed Stuffed Doggy That Says Cutie On It Used Stuffed Doggy That Says Cutie On It $5Toledo, OHUsed Stuffed Llama Very Colorful Used Stuffed Llama Very Colorful $5Toledo, OHDisney Winnie The Pooh Disney Winnie The Pooh $10Toledo, OHNew A Pocket Hug New A Pocket Hug $5Toledo, OHTeam Varsity Bear (Ohio State)Team Varsity Bear (Ohio State)$30Northwood, OHHuge Stuffed Animal Dog/Puppy! Excellent Shape! Huge Stuffed Animal Dog/Puppy! Excellent Shape! $200Toledo, OHHuge stuffed Standing Deer! Melissa & Doug * New W/Tag Huge stuffed Standing Deer! Melissa & Doug * New W/Tag $95Toledo, OH1986 Alf Tv Series Plushie 1986 Alf Tv Series Plushie $60Northwood, OHKelly Toy! Stuffed Unicorn Baby Lay Down Pillow! NEW! Kelly Toy! Stuffed Unicorn Baby Lay Down Pillow! NEW! $25Toledo, OHplushies plushies $20Las Vegas, NVVintage Care Bear Villain Professor Cold HeartVintage Care Bear Villain Professor Cold Heart$20Maumee, OHNascar Crew Chief Stuffed Dog! Like New Shape! Nascar Crew Chief Stuffed Dog! Like New Shape! $15Toledo, OHBuild A Bear Stuffed Unicorn! My Little Pony! Excellent Shape!Build A Bear Stuffed Unicorn! My Little Pony! Excellent Shape!$15Toledo, OHBrownie, squishy.Brownie, squishy.$5Toledo, OHPets Alive Lil Paw Paw Walking Puppy! Brand New! Pets Alive Lil Paw Paw Walking Puppy! Brand New! $30Toledo, OHItty Bittys Peanuts Charlie Brown Plush Itty Bittys Peanuts Charlie Brown Plush $10Toledo, OHValentine teddy bears LED Light 2 Per Order Valentine teddy bears LED Light 2 Per Order $35Ottawa Lake, MIMudonna Stuffed 2003 Mud Hens Mascot! Like New!Mudonna Stuffed 2003 Mud Hens Mascot! Like New!$30Toledo, OHSquishmallows Chuck The Chick by KellyToy NEW! Squishmallows Chuck The Chick by KellyToy NEW! $20Toledo, OHOnesie My Melody PlushOnesie My Melody Plush$10Tulare, CADotd Squishmallow Dotd Squishmallow $45Toledo, OHRandom Baby/toddler ToysRandom Baby/toddler Toys$10Northwood, OHTY Beanie Babies Collectors Card Boxed SetTY Beanie Babies Collectors Card Boxed Set$40Toledo, OHSmall Boo Hollow Car Plush NWT Small Boo Hollow Car Plush NWT $10Toledo, OHChoice of group of stuffed animals for your dogChoice of group of stuffed animals for your dog$5Oregon, OHTeddy BearsTeddy Bears$25Toledo, OHDisney Plush BearDisney Plush Bear$10Toledo, OHSMALL MICKEY MOUSE PLUSH TOYSMALL MICKEY MOUSE PLUSH TOY$11Northwood, OH SIX FLAGS GREY PUPPY DOG SOFT PLUSH ANIMAL TOY SIX FLAGS GREY PUPPY DOG SOFT PLUSH ANIMAL TOY $9Lynwood, CAORIGIONAL AUTHENTIC DISNEY MINNIE MOUSE 18" PLUSHORIGIONAL AUTHENTIC DISNEY MINNIE MOUSE 18" PLUSH$16Northwood, OHPLUSH [ STUFFED ] MICKEY MOUSEPLUSH [ STUFFED ] MICKEY MOUSE$13Northwood, OHBuild A Bear Workshop Bearemy Bear Retired!Build A Bear Workshop Bearemy Bear Retired!$10Toledo, OHFrozen Elsa plush doll Disney backpackFrozen Elsa plush doll Disney backpack$10Toledo, OHBeanie Babies Beanie Babies $50Toledo, OHBeanie Babies Beanie Babies $50Toledo, OHTy Disney Sparkle Micky And Minnie SetTy Disney Sparkle Micky And Minnie Set$10Toledo, OHShrek Forever After The Final Chapter Shrek Forever After The Final Chapter $10Northwood, OHBuild A Bear Full Doctor Outfit With Sparkly ShoesBuild A Bear Full Doctor Outfit With Sparkly Shoes$25Temperance, MISuper Mushroom PlushieSuper Mushroom Plushie$10Denver, COLeto StuffLeto Stuff$50Toledo, OHVintage 1999 Tiger Electronics Hollywood Squares Electronic Handheld GameVintage 1999 Tiger Electronics Hollywood Squares Electronic Handheld Game$10Toledo, OH(2) Build A Bear Bears! High School Musical & Bearemy! Retired, Hard To Find!(2) Build A Bear Bears! High School Musical & Bearemy! Retired, Hard To Find!$25Toledo, OH(6) Emoji splat balls* new in sealed pk.(6) Emoji splat balls* new in sealed pk.$12Toledo, OH(5) pk of play balls for pets* brand new**(5) pk of play balls for pets* brand new**$4Toledo, OHAeropostale stuffed bear - $6Aeropostale stuffed bear - $6$6Toledo, OHOriginal Vintage Care Bear.Original Vintage Care Bear.$95Toledo, OH