No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Ty Stuffed Animals Bunnies Duck, Lamb Ty Stuffed Animals Bunnies Duck, Lamb $5Elizabethtown, PA18 inches tall Pikachu Pokémon18 inches tall Pikachu Pokémon$35Cornwall Borough, PASally Plush Bag Clip - newSally Plush Bag Clip - new$20Lebanon, PAPeanuts Snoopy 9” Flying Ace Aviator Merry Christmas Holiday Dog PlushPeanuts Snoopy 9” Flying Ace Aviator Merry Christmas Holiday Dog Plush$12Duluth, GAPeter RABBIT Plush Toy With HoppingPeter RABBIT Plush Toy With Hopping$15Lebanon, PAStrawberry Shortcake Plush Pet Animals VINTAGE Strawberry Shortcake Plush Pet Animals VINTAGE $1,500Lebanon, PABeanie BabiesBeanie Babies$25Brownstown, PA2 Ft Bear, Cute, Clean, Very Soft2 Ft Bear, Cute, Clean, Very Soft$16Salunga, PAVintage 1989 Kodak Kolorkins Plush Toys FLASH Red Stuffed AnimalVintage 1989 Kodak Kolorkins Plush Toys FLASH Red Stuffed Animal$18Elizabethtown, PA1995 TY Beanie Baby Babies Steg Dinosaur Plush Toy With Name Tag Error - Stey1995 TY Beanie Baby Babies Steg Dinosaur Plush Toy With Name Tag Error - Stey$200Elizabethtown, PAClean White Teddy BearClean White Teddy Bear$5Salunga, PATarget Plush Set Of 3 Exclusive Team Member DogsTarget Plush Set Of 3 Exclusive Team Member Dogs$50Lititz, PA1984 Furskins Bears Bee Keeper Boone Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Toy1984 Furskins Bears Bee Keeper Boone Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Toy$50Elizabethtown, PATy Beanie Babies Britannia, Erin, Maple The Bear McDonalds Set of 3/4 1997 - UNOPENED!Ty Beanie Babies Britannia, Erin, Maple The Bear McDonalds Set of 3/4 1997 - UNOPENED!$50Livermore, CAJust Play Safari Surprise Tiger Babies Cubs Plush Stuffed Animal ToysJust Play Safari Surprise Tiger Babies Cubs Plush Stuffed Animal Toys$12Elizabethtown, PABoyds Bears Plush Christmas Gingerbread TJS Best Dressed CC Peekers With TagsBoyds Bears Plush Christmas Gingerbread TJS Best Dressed CC Peekers With Tags$22Mount Joy, PABaby Gund Sing And Play Flora The BunnyBaby Gund Sing And Play Flora The Bunny$35Pine Grove, PAStuffed Animal Snoopy Stuffed Animal Snoopy $5Palmyra, PAYoda PlushYoda Plush$5Pine Grove, PAStuffed Animal Picachu Stuffed Animal Picachu $5Palmyra, PASquishmallowsSquishmallows$4Salunga, PANana Pillow 💖Nana Pillow 💖$7Ephrata, PAPerfectly Cute Baby Doll Set Perfectly Cute Baby Doll Set $22Ephrata, PAHello Kitty Squish Mellows Hello Kitty Squish Mellows $30Grand Terrace, CAUnicorn Stuffed Animal Assortment 🦄❤️Unicorn Stuffed Animal Assortment 🦄❤️$50Mount Joy, PARainbow Stuffed Animal Rainbow Stuffed Animal $5West Hanover Township, PAStuffed Animal Lot Stuffed Animal Lot $9West Hanover Township, PAPaw Patrol StuffiesPaw Patrol Stuffies$5Hummelstown, PAVintage Disney’s Tarzan Plush Stuffy Lot Of 3 CharactersVintage Disney’s Tarzan Plush Stuffy Lot Of 3 Characters$30Elizabethtown, PAChewbaka Angry Bird Chewbaka Angry Bird $9Palmyra, PAStuffed Animals Stuffed Animals $5Lebanon, PAExcellent condition bear stuffed animalExcellent condition bear stuffed animal$7West Hanover Township, PADomo PlushDomo Plush$10Sun City, AZBuild-A-Bear Workshop Hawaiian Golden Retriever Plush Stuffed Animal BAB ToyBuild-A-Bear Workshop Hawaiian Golden Retriever Plush Stuffed Animal BAB Toy$30Elizabethtown, PACotton candy colored soft stuffed animalCotton candy colored soft stuffed animal$5West Hanover Township, PA1984 Mattel Angel Bunny Plush, White With Wings Stuffed Animal Rabbit1984 Mattel Angel Bunny Plush, White With Wings Stuffed Animal Rabbit$25Elizabethtown, PAVintage 1991 Party Yum Yum Teddy Cakes Pink Bear Plush Stuffed Animal ToyVintage 1991 Party Yum Yum Teddy Cakes Pink Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Toy$150Elizabethtown, PAJumbo Axolotl squishmallow “clutch”Jumbo Axolotl squishmallow “clutch”$80Bernville, PA2004 Ty Beanie Baby SpongeBob PumpkinMask Plush2004 Ty Beanie Baby SpongeBob PumpkinMask Plush$11Elizabethtown, PAVintage Maybe Homemade Raggedy Ann & Andy Plush 18” DollsVintage Maybe Homemade Raggedy Ann & Andy Plush 18” Dolls$50Elizabethtown, PAVintage Piglet Jumbo Plush AnimalVintage Piglet Jumbo Plush Animal$20Swatara, PA2013 Pillow Pets Glow Pets Pink Camo Dog Jumbo Size With LED Lights Inside2013 Pillow Pets Glow Pets Pink Camo Dog Jumbo Size With LED Lights Inside$25Elizabethtown, PABeanie BabiesBeanie Babies$3Auburndale, FLBuild A Bear Workshop Rudolph The Red-Nosed Reindeer Jack In The Box CharlieBuild A Bear Workshop Rudolph The Red-Nosed Reindeer Jack In The Box Charlie$30Elizabethtown, PA2011 Ty Beanie Babies Looney Tunes Tweety Plush2011 Ty Beanie Babies Looney Tunes Tweety Plush$20Elizabethtown, PAStuffed Animal Blue Cat 24Stuffed Animal Blue Cat 24$10West Hanover Township, PAJumbo Sized Tigger Plush AnimalJumbo Sized Tigger Plush Animal$20Swatara, PAIf You Give A Pig A PancakeIf You Give A Pig A Pancake$3Salunga, PA2 Bearington Bears . Autumn Harvest And Victoria2 Bearington Bears . Autumn Harvest And Victoria$15Hershey, PASquishmallows & TY Squishmallows & TY $1Lebanon, PA