No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Scan to download the app

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Plush GiraffePlush Giraffe$20Fall River, MADisney 100th Anniversary Simba Plush Disney 100th Anniversary Simba Plush $18Burrillville, RIGummy BearsPromotedGummy Bears$120Oxnard, CAVintage Mcdonalds Beanie Baby Ty REXVintage Mcdonalds Beanie Baby Ty REX$100Warwick, RIVintage 1981 Garfield Plush Cat Dakin & Company 12”preowned Vintage 1981 Garfield Plush Cat Dakin & Company 12”preowned $22Big Pine Key, FloridaValentines Giant Teddy Bear Heart Pillow Plush Stuffed Animal (7 Styles) 80cm-100cm Brown Scarf 100cm$99.99Valentines Giant Teddy Bear Heart Pillow Plush Stuffed Animal (7 Styles) 80cm-100cm Brown Scarf 100cmFrom The Heart RosesAd1998 Miami Dolphins Plush Bear Collectibles1998 Miami Dolphins Plush Bear Collectibles$30Cranston, RIDisney 100 Exclusive SquishmallowsDisney 100 Exclusive Squishmallows$28Burrillville, RINessie Crochet Stuffed AnimalPromotedNessie Crochet Stuffed Animal$275Skokie, ILSonic Everything Sonic Everything $30Providence, RIRoblox Pet Simulator X Cat Big Games Plush Toys Soft Stuffed Plush No Tags Roblox Pet Simulator X Cat Big Games Plush Toys Soft Stuffed Plush No Tags $10North Providence, RIThree Plush Toys (age 1-3)Three Plush Toys (age 1-3)$10South Easton, MAValentines Giant Teddy Bear Heart Pillow Plush Stuffed Animal (7 Styles) 80cm-100cm 100cm Brown Cloth$99.99Valentines Giant Teddy Bear Heart Pillow Plush Stuffed Animal (7 Styles) 80cm-100cm 100cm Brown ClothFrom The Heart RosesAdWarmies Lion PromotedWarmies Lion $7Hanover, MDsnorlax plushsnorlax plush$25Providence, RITY Beanie Babies Mcdonalds International Bears Set Of (4) With Errors RARE CollectibleTY Beanie Babies Mcdonalds International Bears Set Of (4) With Errors RARE Collectible$35North Smithfield, RI4ft Teddy Bear4ft Teddy Bear$100Providence, RIPlush Teddy Bear 53 InchPlush Teddy Bear 53 Inch$20Providence, RIIron Man Crochet PlushiePromotedIron Man Crochet Plushie$45San Diego, CAValentines Giant Teddy Bear Heart Pillow Plush Stuffed Animal (7 Styles) 80cm-100cm 100cm White Red$89.99Valentines Giant Teddy Bear Heart Pillow Plush Stuffed Animal (7 Styles) 80cm-100cm 100cm White RedFrom The Heart RosesAdSquishmallow LotSquishmallow Lot$50Warwick, RIManhattan Toy Floppies Baby Fawn Stuffed AnimalManhattan Toy Floppies Baby Fawn Stuffed Animal$10Woonsocket, RI50 Lot plush Stuffed Animals Bulk Assortment50 Lot plush Stuffed Animals Bulk Assortment$80Providence, RI2000 TY Beanie BabiePromoted2000 TY Beanie Babie$10Seattle, WATsum Tsum Stitch Plush Set - Disney Cuddle Buddies!Tsum Tsum Stitch Plush Set - Disney Cuddle Buddies!$30South Attleboro, MAAlive - White Tiger Cub Interactive Plush Toy Alive - White Tiger Cub Interactive Plush Toy $20Providence, RI1-800-Flowers Gifts Delivery Sea Sparkle Mermaid Sea Sparkles Mermaid$19.991-800-Flowers Gifts Delivery Sea Sparkle Mermaid Sea Sparkles Mermaid1800Flowers.comAdSmiling Nibbly the Rabbit: Ty Beanie Baby 1998 Tag ERRORSmiling Nibbly the Rabbit: Ty Beanie Baby 1998 Tag ERROR$8Mendon, MAEARS the Rabbit, TY Beanie Baby 1995, swing tag ERROR PVC pelletsEARS the Rabbit, TY Beanie Baby 1995, swing tag ERROR PVC pellets$8Mendon, MANibbler the Smiling Rabbit, TY Beanie Baby 1998, Swing tag ERRORNibbler the Smiling Rabbit, TY Beanie Baby 1998, Swing tag ERROR$8Mendon, MALiberty BearLiberty Bear$15Middleborough, MATickle Me ElmoTickle Me Elmo$75Boston, MAFive Nights At Freddy’s Help Wanted Pirate Foxy PlushFive Nights At Freddy’s Help Wanted Pirate Foxy Plush$15Providence, RI1-800-Flowers Everyday Gift Delivery Animated Get Well Fever Frog | Happiness Delivered To Their Door$39.991-800-Flowers Everyday Gift Delivery Animated Get Well Fever Frog | Happiness Delivered To Their Door1800Flowers.comAdFive Nights At Freddy’s: Pizza Simulator Rockstar Freddy PlushieFive Nights At Freddy’s: Pizza Simulator Rockstar Freddy Plushie$10Providence, RIFive Nights At Freddy’s Bonnie PlushieFive Nights At Freddy’s Bonnie Plushie$10Providence, RIDaken The Dragon Stuffed Animal Plush3 Ft Tall Brand New With Tags 30 DollarsDaken The Dragon Stuffed Animal Plush3 Ft Tall Brand New With Tags 30 Dollars$30Portsmouth, RIMelissa & Doug Giant Jumbo Plush Unicorn Stuffed Animal *LOCAL PICKUP ONLY*Melissa & Doug Giant Jumbo Plush Unicorn Stuffed Animal *LOCAL PICKUP ONLY*$50Hopkinton, MAAngry Birds Common Wealth Rovio Brand 2011 Bomb The Loon BackpackAngry Birds Common Wealth Rovio Brand 2011 Bomb The Loon Backpack$25Portsmouth, RIClubby 2 Platinum Edition Beanie Baby Official Club Platinum MembershipClubby 2 Platinum Edition Beanie Baby Official Club Platinum Membership$40Portsmouth, RINew York Mets Bear Plush And Pacifier$19.99New York Mets Bear Plush And PacifierMLB ShopAdWebkin Koala Webkin Koala $7Dedham, MASquishmello Squishmello $25Providence, RIBeanie Babies Toys Beanie Babies Toys $10Vero Beach, FLDisney Parks Plush - 2015 Mickey Mouse PlushDisney Parks Plush - 2015 Mickey Mouse Plush$33Ashland, MAHello Kitty Plushie Hello Kitty Plushie $15Providence, RIBeanie Baby GLORY -MAKE OFFERBeanie Baby GLORY -MAKE OFFER$35Seekonk, MASymbolically Adopt A Giant Elephant Plush$250.00Symbolically Adopt A Giant Elephant PlushWWF GiftsAdBeanie Baby TyBeanie Baby Ty$40Abington, MASmall Peep Plush Small Peep Plush $6Westport, MA