No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Beanie Baby Seaweed, Happy Hippo, Purple Gold Fish Beanie Baby Seaweed, Happy Hippo, Purple Gold Fish $1Green Bay, WIGarfield Happy Birthday plushGarfield Happy Birthday plush$20Oneida, WISafari Stuffed AnimalsPromotedSafari Stuffed Animals$20Bellflower, CAVintage Jumbo Garfield plushVintage Jumbo Garfield plush$100Oneida, WIWarner Bros.bugs bunny looney tunes soft plush with bendable ears - 15 inchesWarner Bros.bugs bunny looney tunes soft plush with bendable ears - 15 inches$15Miami, FLBoston Red Sox Wubbanub Bear Plush And Pacifier$19.99Boston Red Sox Wubbanub Bear Plush And PacifierMLB ShopAdBuild a bear military plush teddy bearBuild a bear military plush teddy bear$10Oneida, WIFive Nights at Freddys Springtrap Tie-Dye plushFive Nights at Freddys Springtrap Tie-Dye plush$20Oneida, WIHello Kitty Strawberry Plush PromotedHello Kitty Strawberry Plush $30Rialto, CANintendo plush lot Luigi, Toad, Shy Guy Super MarioNintendo plush lot Luigi, Toad, Shy Guy Super Mario$100Oneida, WILemur Plush Lemur Plush $5Oneida, WIDespicable Me Fluffy Unicorn plush backpackDespicable Me Fluffy Unicorn plush backpack$5Oneida, WIGiant Teddy Bear Stuffed Animals Plush Toy Cute Life Size Big Plush Teddy Bear For Kids Girlfriend, Soft Stuffed Bear Animals,Grey,All-New,By Temu$50.49Giant Teddy Bear Stuffed Animals Plush Toy Cute Life Size Big Plush Teddy Bear For Kids Girlfriend, Soft Stuffed Bear Animals,Grey,All-New,By TemuTemu-US-LocalAdRare Vintage Beanie Baby “Glory” PromotedRare Vintage Beanie Baby “Glory” $1,000Cambria, CAAurora winter teddy bear plushAurora winter teddy bear plush$5Oneida, WIHello Kitty pillow Universal StudiosHello Kitty pillow Universal Studios$5Oneida, WIAgnus TY cuddly beanie plush toyAgnus TY cuddly beanie plush toy$5Oneida, WIFNAF Cupcake plush Youtooz Five Nights at Freddys 1ftFNAF Cupcake plush Youtooz Five Nights at Freddys 1ft$40Oneida, WIHugging BunniesPromotedHugging Bunnies$60Murphy, NCPlush Pals Stuffed Animals Atico Excellent$74.99Plush Pals Stuffed Animals Atico ExcellenteBayAdHello Kitty Hello Kitty $22Kaukauna, WIStuffed AnimalStuffed Animal$2Green Bay, WIStuffed Animal Stuffed Animal $2Green Bay, WI2000 TY Beanie BabiePromoted2000 TY Beanie Babie$10Seattle, WAStuffed Nascar Beanie Car And ToysStuffed Nascar Beanie Car And Toys$20Green Bay, WIBuild A Bear Snowy OwlBuild A Bear Snowy Owl$18Kaukauna, WICoyote 12-Inch Stuffed Animal$19.95Coyote 12-Inch Stuffed AnimalNature NicheAdHello Kitty And Cinnamon Roll Plushes Hello Kitty And Cinnamon Roll Plushes $36Green Bay, WIHouston Astros PlushHouston Astros Plush$10Green Bay, WIVintage Looney Tunes PlushVintage Looney Tunes Plush$15Kaukauna, WIThe Secret Life Of Pets MAX Plush Stuffed animal 12" with movieThe Secret Life Of Pets MAX Plush Stuffed animal 12" with movie$25Krakow, WIBuild A Bear PlushBuild A Bear Plush$15Kaukauna, WIMills Fleet Farm 2021 Rhinoceros 13" Stuffed Animal Plush New With Tags GoffaMills Fleet Farm 2021 Rhinoceros 13" Stuffed Animal Plush New With Tags Goffa$35Krakow, WIVintage Lot 19 Small Animal Fair Henry Plush Collector Stuffed Animals$226.99Vintage Lot 19 Small Animal Fair Henry Plush Collector Stuffed AnimalseBayAdAurora Plush Black Gorilla Ape Monkey Realistic Stuffed Animal Toy Bean BagAurora Plush Black Gorilla Ape Monkey Realistic Stuffed Animal Toy Bean Bag$18Krakow, WIToy Factory The Secret Life Of Pets Max Dog NEW 12" Plush Stuffed AnimalToy Factory The Secret Life Of Pets Max Dog NEW 12" Plush Stuffed Animal$15Krakow, WIPac-Man Orange Ghost ClydePac-Man Orange Ghost Clyde$25Kaukauna, WIVintage Louie Vintage Louie $12Green Bay, WIGomez Addams Plush Gomez Addams Plush $12Green Bay, WIDeer &Dolphin Deer &Dolphin $2Green Bay, WIFawn 8-Inch Stuffed Animal$10.95Fawn 8-Inch Stuffed AnimalNature NicheAdTim Burton’s, The Nightmare Before You For Christmas, Jack Skellington, PlushTim Burton’s, The Nightmare Before You For Christmas, Jack Skellington, Plush$4Kaukauna, WIVintage 1996 Olympic Games Atlanta Mascot Izzy Collectible Stuffed Plush ToyVintage 1996 Olympic Games Atlanta Mascot Izzy Collectible Stuffed Plush Toy$40Krakow, WIHello KittyHello Kitty$20Whittier, CAPink Pig Rainbow Wings Cast Of Characters Spencer Gifts Inc. Plush ToyPink Pig Rainbow Wings Cast Of Characters Spencer Gifts Inc. Plush Toy$25Krakow, WIIDEAL Toys Plush Monkey Multi ColorIDEAL Toys Plush Monkey Multi Color$10Krakow, WINemo Clown Fish from In The Ocean BookNemo Clown Fish from In The Ocean Book$15Krakow, WINew York Yankees Wubbanub Puppy Plush And Pacifier$19.99New York Yankees Wubbanub Puppy Plush And PacifierMLB ShopAdDisney Winnie the Pooh Bear Plush - Christopher Robin Disney Winnie the Pooh Bear Plush - Christopher Robin $30Krakow, WIToy Factory White POLAR BEAR w/Pink Plaid Scarf 9" Plush Stuffed Toy SOFTToy Factory White POLAR BEAR w/Pink Plaid Scarf 9" Plush Stuffed Toy SOFT$15Krakow, WISuper Soft White Fur Easter Bunny plush toySuper Soft White Fur Easter Bunny plush toy$15Krakow, WINickelodeon Paw Patrol Plush Lot Of 2 Skye Zuma Floppy Rescue Pups ToysNickelodeon Paw Patrol Plush Lot Of 2 Skye Zuma Floppy Rescue Pups Toys$28Krakow, WITalking tigger clock kids will love itTalking tigger clock kids will love it$15Green Bay, WITickle me Elmo extra specialTickle me Elmo extra special$250De Pere, WIToy plush Elephant Grey BigToy plush Elephant Grey Big$20Dallas, TXBoyed and friends lucky rabbitBoyed and friends lucky rabbit$15Green Bay, WITeddy Ruxpin and Other Vintage ToysTeddy Ruxpin and Other Vintage Toys$0Green Bay, WIPiglet. Hand. PuppetPiglet. Hand. Puppet$10Green Bay, WIBig Binni Boos Big Binni Boos $10Green Bay, WI