Stuffed animals & Plush
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
Wild Republic Cuddlekin Plush Turtle - 14” Long, NWT$10Vernon, WI
Natnat Squishmallow $15West Bend, WI
Ty Beanie Babies Platinum Club Membership Kit + Beanie Bear Lot – Vintage 1999 Collector Set$55Waukesha, WI
Beanie Babies $100West Bend, WI
Lot of 21 TY Beanie Babies - Retired Collectibles - Holiday, Patriotic, Animal$45Waukesha, WI
“Loverboy Baby Boy” Teddy Bear – NEW with Tag$25Waukesha, WI
Kellytoy Squishmellow Plush Super Soft Stuffed Characters $15Milwaukee, WI
Mario Beanie $3Milwaukee, WI
peter griffin plushie$34Milwaukee, WI
Star Wars The Mandalorian The Child 11 inch Plush Toy$16Milwaukee, WI
Lilo Stitch Keychains Clips For Back Pack Set $6Milwaukee, WI
THE MONSTERS Let's Checkmate Series-Vinyl Plush Doll "labubu"$330Mukwonago, WI
Squishmallow 8"inch Riba Jack O Lantern Pumpkin & Casey Candy Corn Bat plush toy 2 set NWT 2022 $20$20Milwaukee, WI
Vintage 1983 Alvin And Simon Plush Toys$25Milwaukee, WI
DISNEY STITCH 16 INCHES TALL$45Milwaukee, WI
TY Beanie Babies Marvel set of 2 Spiderman & Miles Morales 6"inch plush toys NWT stuffed animal $10$10Milwaukee, WI
Vintage 1992 Arotoys Disney Raja the Tiger from Aladdin plush toy 10"inch Like New $5 Firm$5Milwaukee, WI
Panda $80Milwaukee, WI
VINTAGE GIANT BEAR$200Milwaukee, WI
Mischievous Monkey $15Brookfield, WI
Horror Plush Set $30Milwaukee, WI
Cabbage Patch Kids$75Milwaukee, WI
Unipak 13"inch Coco pink Unicorn with baby stuffed animal New plush toy Home Goods 2018 $10 Firm $10Milwaukee, WI
Build A Bear Fairy Friends Pink Unicorn 15"inch stuffed animal Like New plush toy $15 Firm$15Milwaukee, WI
Kellytoy Fantasy Pets Tie Dye Rainbow Unicorn 11"inch stuffed animal 2021 plush toy Like New $10$10Milwaukee, WI
Vintage Zangeen Huggable Honeys 5"inch Purple Unicorn plush toy stuffed animal 1996 NWT Rare $3 $3Milwaukee, WI
TY Beanie Babies Zodiac Horoscope Lavender Tie Dye Purple Rat 6"inch plush toy 2000 NWT Vintage $3$3Milwaukee, WI
Kohl's Cares Little Critter Brother Mercer Mayers 14"inch plush toy stuffed animal NWT $5$5Milwaukee, WI
Vintage 1998 Nascar Beanie Racers Dale Earnhardt Goodwrench plush toy Racecar Beanbag PJ Toys 7"inch $5$5Milwaukee, WI
Vtg Commonwealth Of Pennsylvania Plush Stuffed Rabbit - 15” Tall$12Waukesha, WI
Beanie Baby Tag Error Lot$20Milwaukee, WI
Beanie Baby Lot$10Milwaukee, WI
Beanie Baby Lot$20Milwaukee, WI
Kobe Reverse grinch $450Milwaukee, WI
Leap frog Stuffed Animal$15Milwaukee, WI
Fisher-price Learning Stuffed Animals$15Milwaukee, WI
St. Bernard Dog Stuffy$8Muskego, WI
Hug Me Stuffed Dinosaurs Lot 2$30Milwaukee, WI
Clubby 1-3 Beenie Babies$30Mequon, WI
3 Different Decade Beenie Babies$30Mequon, WI
Princess Diana Beenie Baby & Buddy$125Mequon, WI
Rare TY beanie Baby Ronald McDonald Bear$45Muskego, WI
Vintage TY beanie Baby Hamburgler Bear McDonalds$45Muskego, WI
Vermont Teddy Bear Like New!$25Muskego, WI
Vintage ALF / Alien From 1986 Sitcom Stuffy$80Muskego, WI
"Tender Bunny" Vintage 1985 Gund Stuffed Bunny$15Muskego, WI
Pound Puppy Stuffed Vintage 1986$23Muskego, WI
Vintage 1990 Kermit The Frog Fireman Teaches How To Get Dressed EDUCATIONAL$23Muskego, WI
Vintage 1990s Dalmation Dog$22Muskego, WI
1971 Vintage Bugs Bunny Stuffie$20Muskego, WI