No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Scan to download the app

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Stuffed Animals Vintage-Huckleberry Hound Stuffed Animals Vintage-Huckleberry Hound $100River Hills, WIHug Me Stuffed Dinosaurs Lot 2Hug Me Stuffed Dinosaurs Lot 2$30Milwaukee, WIChewbacca Backpack PromotedChewbacca Backpack $7Buena Park, CASt. Bernard Dog StuffySt. Bernard Dog Stuffy$8Muskego, WIHello Kitty Hawaiian Key Chain 4 Inch Hello Kitty Hawaiian Key Chain 4 Inch $25Monterey Park, CANew England Patriots Plush Unicorn$25.00New England Patriots Plush UnicornNFL ShopAdSet of 4 - M & M World Embroidered Plush CharctersSet of 4 - M & M World Embroidered Plush Charcters$10Milwaukee, WIThanksgiving Set Of Beenie BabiesThanksgiving Set Of Beenie Babies$15Mequon, WITy beanie Babies.cubby Bears Issued To Club Members In 1997 Perfect Condition. Never Played WithPromotedTy beanie Babies.cubby Bears Issued To Club Members In 1997 Perfect Condition. Never Played With$10Mesa, AZSet Of Holiday Teddy BeeniesSet Of Holiday Teddy Beenies$40Mequon, WISet Of Patriotic BeeniesSet Of Patriotic Beenies$25Mequon, WIClubby 1-3 Beenie BabiesClubby 1-3 Beenie Babies$30Mequon, WINew York Mets Bear Plush And Pacifier$19.99New York Mets Bear Plush And PacifierMLB ShopAdHello kitty 50th Anniversary PlushPromotedHello kitty 50th Anniversary Plush$80Los Angeles, CA3 Different Decade Beenie Babies3 Different Decade Beenie Babies$30Mequon, WIOwl Graduation Beenie BabiesOwl Graduation Beenie Babies$70Mequon, WISet Of 3 Spangle Beenie BabiesSet Of 3 Spangle Beenie Babies$30Mequon, WISet Of 3 Liberty Beenie BabiesSet Of 3 Liberty Beenie Babies$30Mequon, WIPikachu Plushy Backpack 🫶🏼PromotedPikachu Plushy Backpack 🫶🏼$12Claremont, CALos Angeles Rams Plush Unicorn$25.00Los Angeles Rams Plush UnicornNFL ShopAdSet Of 3 Sam Beenie BabiesSet Of 3 Sam Beenie Babies$30Mequon, WIPrincess Diana Beenie Baby & BuddyPrincess Diana Beenie Baby & Buddy$125Mequon, WINOT FREE!!! OFFER! Sanrio Plushies NOT FREE!!! OFFER! Sanrio Plushies $1Milwaukee, WIHello Kitty Rimestone CupPromotedHello Kitty Rimestone Cup$65Oceanside, CAPrincess Diana Beanie Baby Princess Diana Beanie Baby $200Milwaukee, WIKidro Bot Care Bears X Julie West Funshine Bear 6 Inch Vinyl FigureKidro Bot Care Bears X Julie West Funshine Bear 6 Inch Vinyl Figure$15West Allis, WINew York Yankees Wubbanub Bear Plush And Pacifier$19.99New York Yankees Wubbanub Bear Plush And PacifierMLB ShopAdRare TY beanie Baby Ronald McDonald BearRare TY beanie Baby Ronald McDonald Bear$45Muskego, WIVintage TY beanie Baby Hamburgler Bear McDonaldsVintage TY beanie Baby Hamburgler Bear McDonalds$45Muskego, WILot Of 3 TY 2000 McDonald’s Beanie Babies: Righty, Lefty, Liberty - NEW SealedLot Of 3 TY 2000 McDonald’s Beanie Babies: Righty, Lefty, Liberty - NEW Sealed$10Vernon, WITMNT Plush BASKET TMNT Plush BASKET $10Waukesha, WICute Cosmic Whale Plushie Cute Cosmic Whale Plushie $35Milwaukee, WIPlushie Plushie $25Milwaukee, WIFOCO New England Patriots 9'' Sequin Unicorn Plush Toy$18.99FOCO New England Patriots 9'' Sequin Unicorn Plush ToyNFL ShopAdValentines Day Gloomy Bear Plushie Valentines Day Gloomy Bear Plushie $128Milwaukee, WIOwl Plushie Owl Plushie $35Milwaukee, WIGloomy Bear Plushie XL Gloomy Bear Plushie XL $10Milwaukee, WIAxoloto Plushie/ToyAxoloto Plushie/Toy$15Milwaukee, WIPlushie Plushie $25Milwaukee, WICinnamon Roll Plushie XLCinnamon Roll Plushie XL$143Milwaukee, WIHuge Giant Teddy Bear 93" High Quality Plush Life Size Stuffed Animal$8,802.00Huge Giant Teddy Bear 93" High Quality Plush Life Size Stuffed AnimaleBayAdCow Plushies For Sale Cow Plushies For Sale $52Milwaukee, WIVermont Teddy Bear Like New!Vermont Teddy Bear Like New!$25Muskego, WILalaloopsiesLalaloopsies$35Nashville, TNVintage ALF / Alien From 1986 Sitcom StuffyVintage ALF / Alien From 1986 Sitcom Stuffy$80Muskego, WILilo and Stitch 15 3/4 inch plushLilo and Stitch 15 3/4 inch plush$25Milwaukee, WIPops Build-A-Bear Toy For SalePops Build-A-Bear Toy For Sale$123Milwaukee, WIVIAHART Baxter The Boston Terrier - 12 Inch Stuffed Animal Plush Dog - By Tiger Tale Toys$16.99VIAHART Baxter The Boston Terrier - 12 Inch Stuffed Animal Plush Dog - By Tiger Tale ToysAmazon.comAdStitch In SpaceStitch In Space$14Brown Deer, WIBeanie Babie-Early The Robin Beanie Babie-Early The Robin $10Milwaukee, WI