Stuffed animals & Plush
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
Rare TY Beanie Baby (best Offer)$20Meriden, CT
Rare TY Beanie Baby Blackie The Bear (best Offer) $20Meriden, CT
Rare TY Beanie Baby ECHO (best Offer)$20Meriden, CT
Rare TY Beanie Baby Lizzy (best Offer) $20Meriden, CT
Rare TY Beanie Baby Stinger (best Offer) $20Meriden, CT
Rare TY Beanie Baby INCH (best Offer) $20Meriden, CT
Disney Parks Finding Nemo 9" Plush Stuffed Animal Orange Clown Fish 9in$22New Haven, CT
Pikachu Stuffed Animal$10New Haven, CT
Large Disney Stuffed Animals$25Bridgeport, CT
Vintage 1999 Limited Edition of 6000 Gund - Barton's Creek Collection "Nadine" Fashionable Little Sweetie Hard Faced Stuffed Bear 12"$25Stratford, CT
A Mart Big Cats Tiger The Jungle 10” Plush Soft Toy Stuffed Animal$28New Haven, CT
Kelly Toy Fantasy Pets Unicorn Pegasus Plush Multicolor Stuffed Animal Toy 13"$30New Haven, CT
TY Whopper Elephant 5.5in Plush Toy Sparkle Eyes$17New Haven, CT
Wish Pets ELLIMO Soft Gray Plush Elephant Stuffed Animal Toy 17in floppy ear 17in$26New Haven, CT
Pink Poodle Dog Puppy Plush Stuffed Animal Rinco Floppy 12in$22New Haven, CT
Brand New Stuffed Animals $40New Britain, CT
TeeTurtle Reversible Plushies Black Gray Octopus Plushie Snowflake Cloud Fidget$16New Haven, CT
TY Beanie Baby 2.0 “Cricket” the Grey and White Cat bean bag Plush! *Rare* (6 inch)
$21New Haven, CT
Wembley Ultra-soft Stuffed Push Toy Christmas Elephant Wearing Santa Hat 8in$36New Haven, CT
Disney Store PLUSH 14" THUMPER with blue ribbon Rabbit Bambi Movie! RARE!!!$44New Haven, CT
Poopy Brown Emoji Expressions Plush Stuffed Throw Pillow, Soft
$23New Haven, CT
Rosie O’doll Plush $18West Haven, CT
Squishable Comfort Food Avocado Cute Green Soft Fuzzy Plush
9in$31New Haven, CT
Bei Jing 2008 Children's Plush Animal Panda Bear Backpack Travel Buddy Bag 15in$22New Haven, CT
Squishmallow Leopard/Cheetah Plush Chelsea Hart love Stuffed Animal 8"$23New Haven, CT
The Pokey Little Puppy Book Character stuffed animal plush Yottoy Kohl's 9.5"$22New Haven, CT
Squishmallow mini Maui the Pineapple plush 6 inches squishy Plush$22New Haven, CT
Plushies $50Hartford, CT
VTG Plush Creations Inc Blue Dinosaur Hand Puppet Full Body Glove$22New Haven, CT
Disney Stitch Plush from Lilo and Stitch Stuffed Animal Toy 9in$36New Haven, CT
Unicorn Stuffed Animal $20Meriden, CT
Hallmark Teddy Bear Kissing Bear$20New Britain, CT
Stain glass grinder.$45Shelton, CT
Ty Beanie Ballz Tumbles Pink White Kitty Cat Plush Round Bean Bag 5"
$19New Haven, CT
Aurora Great Horned Owl 9" Realistic Stuffed Animal Plush$22New Haven, CT
Tiger Tale Toys Skunk skunky black and white Plush standing soft toy $28New Haven, CT
Peter Rabbit Dan Dee Bunny Small 8in Soft Keychain Plush$11New Haven, CT
Black & white penguin by Wildlife Artist realistic Plush$20New Haven, CT
Walmart Kissing magnetic Lips Monkeys Plush Beanbag Stuffed Animal Toy Valentine's$25New Haven, CT
Squishmallow 8” - "Archer the Green Textured Alligator" Plush Toy - KellyToy$21New Haven, CT
Kohls Cares Put Me in the Zoo Plush 18" Dr. Seuss Toy Yellow & Colorful Polka Dot Dog Plush$28New Haven, CT
Ty Beanie Ballz - Avalanche the Penguin$18New Haven, CT
Ty Beanie Boo 'Posy' the Pink Chick (9 inch) Purple tush tag *Rare*
$19New Haven, CT
Jellycat London Cordy Roy Bunny Rabbit Pink Plush Floppy Corduroy Med 12" Lovey $38New Haven, CT
TY BEANIE BALLZ BONSAI THE PANDA BEAR 5" PLUSH STUFFED ANIMAL ROUND$15New Haven, CT
Build-A-Bear The Child $40New Haven, CT
Wild Republic Grey Plush koala bear Wristlet Slap Bracelet
Plush$20New Haven, CT
Kellytoy Triceratops Dino 8" plush stuffed animal green, yellow soft$16New Haven, CT
Goffa Cute Husky Dog Plush stuffed animal Soft Toys 7in$15New Haven, CT
2021 TY Squish-a-Boos FANTASIA Pink Unicorn Cushion Pillow Plush TY No Tags$19New Haven, CT