No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

7 Beanie Babies Incl Picadilly 3rd Edition7 Beanie Babies Incl Picadilly 3rd Edition$40Billerica, MALot Of 24 Plush / Stuffed Animals Lot Of 24 Plush / Stuffed Animals $30Lowell, MASafari Stuffed AnimalsPromotedSafari Stuffed Animals$20Bellflower, CATy Beanie Baby KnucklesTy Beanie Baby Knuckles$20Concord, NHSquishmallow Squishmallow $20Phoenix, AZBoston Red Sox Wubbanub Bear Plush And Pacifier$19.99Boston Red Sox Wubbanub Bear Plush And PacifierMLB ShopAdTy Beanie Baby SpongeBob Ty Beanie Baby SpongeBob $30Concord, NHTy Beanie Baby SnifferTy Beanie Baby Sniffer$20Concord, NHMake Me An OfferPromotedMake Me An Offer$50Las Vegas, NVVintage 26” Curious George ‘70’sVintage 26” Curious George ‘70’s$30Londonderry, NHVintage Lot Of 24 Plush & Stuffed Animals Vintage Lot Of 24 Plush & Stuffed Animals $30Lowell, MADisney Pixar Wall E Robot Plush Cute! Disney Pixar Wall E Robot Plush Cute! $10Methuen, MA4Pcs-Mini Animal Plush Toy Assortment,Bulk Stuffed Animals Party Favors , Small Animals Plush Keychain Decoration, Carnival Prizes, Valentine's Day Party Favors,Backpack Pendants, Graduation Gifts, Holiday Gifts,4Pcs$1.924Pcs-Mini Animal Plush Toy Assortment,Bulk Stuffed Animals Party Favors , Small Animals Plush Keychain Decoration, Carnival Prizes, Valentine's Day Party Favors,Backpack Pendants, Graduation Gifts, Holiday Gifts,4PcssheinAdHugging BunniesPromotedHugging Bunnies$60Murphy, NCGund Teddy Bear Millennium 2000 Hope Gund Teddy Bear Millennium 2000 Hope $30Londonderry, NHSuper Soft Plushie Learning BookSuper Soft Plushie Learning Book$20Gardner, MAHello Kitty CupHello Kitty Cup$20Bedford, MA20 Ty Mini Babies Most With With Tags 20 Ty Mini Babies Most With With Tags $35Hudson, NHFuzz Beanie Baby Misprinted PromotedFuzz Beanie Baby Misprinted $60Horn Lake, MSLos Angeles Dodgers Wubbanub Bear Plush And Pacifier$19.99Los Angeles Dodgers Wubbanub Bear Plush And PacifierMLB ShopAdDisney’s Doc McStuffins Toy Lot Findo Whispers Dog Cat Plush Set & Carrier ToolsDisney’s Doc McStuffins Toy Lot Findo Whispers Dog Cat Plush Set & Carrier Tools$20Haverhill, MAArthur And Sister DW Aardvark Plush Toy Lot PBS KIDS Arthur And Sister DW Aardvark Plush Toy Lot PBS KIDS $15Methuen, MAEaster Bunny Ballerina Rabbit Knit Plush Stuffed Animal Girls Easter Bunny Ballerina Rabbit Knit Plush Stuffed Animal Girls $10Methuen, MAHandmade crocheted dragon lampPromotedHandmade crocheted dragon lamp$180Placentia, CAGarcia Bear Beanie Baby - 1993 ModelGarcia Bear Beanie Baby - 1993 Model$550Hudson, NHPrincess Diana Beanie Baby - Original - 1st editionPrincess Diana Beanie Baby - Original - 1st edition$1,000Hudson, NH1-800-Flowers Gifts Delivery Sea Sparkle Mermaid Sea Sparkles Mermaid$19.991-800-Flowers Gifts Delivery Sea Sparkle Mermaid Sea Sparkles Mermaid1800Flowers.comAdSteiff Teddy Bear. 8 Inches Tall. Original.Steiff Teddy Bear. 8 Inches Tall. Original.$125Kensington, NHLarge Pete The Cat Classic Plush Toy Stuffed Animal Large Pete The Cat Classic Plush Toy Stuffed Animal $10Methuen, MASquishmallow Penguin and Snowman Plush Lot Squishmallow Penguin and Snowman Plush Lot $10Haverhill, MAPillowfort Plush White Unicorn Throw Pillow Sparkle Braid Stuffed Animal TargetPillowfort Plush White Unicorn Throw Pillow Sparkle Braid Stuffed Animal Target$10Methuen, MA2 Squishamallow Clip On Plush Stuffed Toys2 Squishamallow Clip On Plush Stuffed Toys$10Haverhill, MALos Tremblors Los Tremblors $900Manchester, NHSUPER Premium 100% Generic Plush 12in-15in 2$199.98SUPER Premium 100% Generic Plush 12in-15in 2Gumball.comAdLand of B. Dog Fluffy Doos Woofer Blue Baby Toddler Child Toy Soft Plush https://offerup.com/redirect/?o=Qi5Ub3lzLand of B. Dog Fluffy Doos Woofer Blue Baby Toddler Child Toy Soft Plush https://offerup.com/redirect/?o=Qi5Ub3lz$10Methuen, MACare Bears Wish Bear Stuffed Plush 14” Aqua Green Shooting Stars Vintage 2000sCare Bears Wish Bear Stuffed Plush 14” Aqua Green Shooting Stars Vintage 2000s$10Methuen, MABuild A Bear DinosaursBuild A Bear Dinosaurs$20Manchester, NHGiant Teddy Bear Giant Teddy Bear $20North Andover, MAPoop Emoji Stuffed PillowPoop Emoji Stuffed Pillow$10Laconia, NHCare Bears Grumpy Bear Blue Rain Cloud Belly 13" Stuffed Plush Care Bears Grumpy Bear Blue Rain Cloud Belly 13" Stuffed Plush $10Methuen, MANew York Yankees Wubbanub Puppy Plush And Pacifier$19.99New York Yankees Wubbanub Puppy Plush And PacifierMLB ShopAdBrand New Hallmark Hoppy Easter Dancing BunnyBrand New Hallmark Hoppy Easter Dancing Bunny$15Concord, NHSquishmallows And PicsSquishmallows And Pics$15Nashua, NHcare bears x hello kitty badtz maru 9” plushcare bears x hello kitty badtz maru 9” plush$30San Diego, CASquishmallows Squishmallows $15Nashua, NHFur Real PonyFur Real Pony$45Methuen, MAPlush Fuzzy Bunny Rabbit Lot Set In Linen Dress Spring Easter Lovey 13”Plush Fuzzy Bunny Rabbit Lot Set In Linen Dress Spring Easter Lovey 13”$10Methuen, MASUPER Premium 100% Generic Plush 12in-15in 5$199.98SUPER Premium 100% Generic Plush 12in-15in 5Gumball.comAdOriginal Squishmallows Kelly toy Mickey Mouse Disney Easter Plush 10”Original Squishmallows Kelly toy Mickey Mouse Disney Easter Plush 10”$15Methuen, MABuild A Bear Workshop Tie Dye Bunny Rabbit Easter Rainbow Purple Blue Pink BABWBuild A Bear Workshop Tie Dye Bunny Rabbit Easter Rainbow Purple Blue Pink BABW$10Methuen, MA