No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Plushies

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

PlushiePlushie$30Brooklyn, NYTriceratops PlushieTriceratops Plushie$10Red Bank, NJPikachu Plushy Backpack 🫶🏼PromotedPikachu Plushy Backpack 🫶🏼$12Claremont, CAAmerica TY Beanie Baby 2001 Red Cross with tush tag errorAmerica TY Beanie Baby 2001 Red Cross with tush tag error$25Toms River, NJHello Kitty plushies Hello Kitty plushies $10Arrowhed Farm, CABluey, Talking Bingo Plush, Toddler Toy$19.97Bluey, Talking Bingo Plush, Toddler ToyWalmartAdMum TY Beanie Baby 2001 - tush tag errorMum TY Beanie Baby 2001 - tush tag error$10Toms River, NJClover TY Beanie Baby 2001 RARE with tush tag errorClover TY Beanie Baby 2001 RARE with tush tag error$500Toms River, NJPurple Gengar Plushie PromotedPurple Gengar Plushie $30Santa Clarita, CASizzle TY Beanie Baby 2001 tush error tagSizzle TY Beanie Baby 2001 tush error tag$50Toms River, NJhello kittyhello kitty$10Brooklyn, NYMARIO BROS & FRIENDS PLUSHIESMARIO BROS & FRIENDS PLUSHIES$40Woodlynne, NJ8Pcs Set 7" Fnaf Five Nights At Freddy's Plushie Toy Plush Bear Foxy$81.938Pcs Set 7" Fnaf Five Nights At Freddy's Plushie Toy Plush Bear FoxyeBayAdBeanie Babies Ty(includes Patti The Platypus And Chocolate The Moose)PromotedBeanie Babies Ty(includes Patti The Platypus And Chocolate The Moose)$499Buckeye, AZPlushie ToysPlushie Toys$10Feasterville-trevose, PAHELLO KITTY VALENTINE PLUSHIE HELLO KITTY VALENTINE PLUSHIE $30New Brunswick, NJPokemon Plushy Riolu Pokemon Plushy Riolu $20Brooklyn, NYTMNT Fugglers Set OF 2 Funny Plushy Monsters Leonardo And Donatello Pizza - NEWTMNT Fugglers Set OF 2 Funny Plushy Monsters Leonardo And Donatello Pizza - NEW$40Edison, NJIron Man Crochet PlushiePromotedIron Man Crochet Plushie$45San Diego, CA2024 Horror Catnap Smiling Critters Plushie Doll Hoppy Hopscotch$48.822024 Horror Catnap Smiling Critters Plushie Doll Hoppy HopscotcheBayAdFive Nights At Freddy’s Plush BundleFive Nights At Freddy’s Plush Bundle$45Burlington, NJJOJO SIWA DRESS (4/5) BLANKET, PLUSHIEJOJO SIWA DRESS (4/5) BLANKET, PLUSHIE$20Woodlynne, NJMcDonalds Beanie Boos | 3” | 15 plushiesMcDonalds Beanie Boos | 3” | 15 plushies$20Burlington, NJPlushies Pillow Plushies Pillow $1Staten Island, NYHello Kitty Ty Beanie Babies Sanrio | 6” | 2 PlushiesHello Kitty Ty Beanie Babies Sanrio | 6” | 2 Plushies$20Burlington, NJCute Flower PlushyCute Flower Plushy$5Brooklyn, NYMini Multicolored Assorted Stuffed Animal Toy$8.00Mini Multicolored Assorted Stuffed Animal ToyFaireAdPlush care bear - yellow happy birthday carebears plushie - party hat / cupcakePlush care bear - yellow happy birthday carebears plushie - party hat / cupcake$8Burlington, NJVtg McDonald's TY Beanie Baby Liberty the Bear 2000 SealedVtg McDonald's TY Beanie Baby Liberty the Bear 2000 Sealed$10West Deptford, NJTy Beanie Babies Platinum Edition Club KitTy Beanie Babies Platinum Edition Club Kit$15West Deptford, NJSquishmallows-Style 12" Pikachu Soft PlushieSquishmallows-Style 12" Pikachu Soft Plushie$20Springfield, PAOfficially Licensed Classic Mickey & Minnie PlushiesOfficially Licensed Classic Mickey & Minnie Plushies$30Las Vegas, NVSamezu Pink Shark 15" PlushSamezu Pink Shark 15" Plush$15Rosemead, CAThe Rock Just Bring It Plush Bleacher Creature Size:No Size$22.99The Rock Just Bring It Plush Bleacher Creature Size:No SizeWWE ShopAdStill Sealed Vtg 1999 Tyco Green Beanie Baby Erin The Bear St Patrick’s Day Plush Doll NEW RareStill Sealed Vtg 1999 Tyco Green Beanie Baby Erin The Bear St Patrick’s Day Plush Doll NEW Rare$5Toms River, NJDUCK DYNASTY PLUSHIES & HEADGEARDUCK DYNASTY PLUSHIES & HEADGEAR$25Audubon, NJMaruchan PlushieMaruchan Plushie$15Philadelphia, PAFnaf 🔥five Nights At Freddie’s Plushie Toys Lot 7Fnaf 🔥five Nights At Freddie’s Plushie Toys Lot 7$65Ridley Park, PAHello Kitty Collectors Plushies Hello Kitty Collectors Plushies $80Perth Amboy, NJMINION PLUSHIE BUNDLEMINION PLUSHIE BUNDLE$30Woodlynne, NJHandmade Crochet Plushies Stuffed Animal$149.99Handmade Crochet Plushies Stuffed AnimaleBayAdMINION PLUSHIES-$10 eaMINION PLUSHIES-$10 ea$10Woodlynne, NJPlushies for salePlushies for sale$5Philadelphia, PAPlush care bear - pink / purple unicorn doll carebears plushiePlush care bear - pink / purple unicorn doll carebears plushie$8Burlington, NJValentine Mickey & Minnie PlushiesValentine Mickey & Minnie Plushies$40Brooklyn, NYMINION BACKPACK, BUILD A BEAR & PLUSHIEMINION BACKPACK, BUILD A BEAR & PLUSHIE$15Woodlynne, NJClassic Mickey & Minnie PlushiesClassic Mickey & Minnie Plushies$40Brooklyn, NYWhite Buffalo Plush Stuffed Animal North American Plushie$30.00White Buffalo Plush Stuffed Animal North American PlushieFaireAdCuphead And Mug Man PlushiesCuphead And Mug Man Plushies$45Burlington, NJHello Kitty And Friends x Care Bears Plushie SetHello Kitty And Friends x Care Bears Plushie Set$40Brooklyn, NY