No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Stuffed AnimalsStuffed Animals$35Denville, NJEnglish Bulldog Stuffed Animal English Bulldog Stuffed Animal $1Copiague, NYPlush Stuffed Animal CatPlush Stuffed Animal Cat$5South Brunswick Township, NJcrochet plushie eyescrochet plushie eyes$5Tracy, CA24" Large Plush Christmas Rocky Bullwinkle Stuffed Animal Toy Moose 1996 Macy's24" Large Plush Christmas Rocky Bullwinkle Stuffed Animal Toy Moose 1996 Macy's$20Oceanside, NYGanz Webkins Rooster Plush Stuffed Animal No CodeGanz Webkins Rooster Plush Stuffed Animal No Code$14Hopatcong, NJBig Plush Stuffed Red Bull 46 Inch Huge Animal NICE GoffaBig Plush Stuffed Red Bull 46 Inch Huge Animal NICE Goffa$60Clifton, NJLot of 38 Stuffed Animals including Several Build a BearsLot of 38 Stuffed Animals including Several Build a Bears$40Bergenfield, NJPokémon Stuffed Animals Both For 10 Bucks Pokémon Stuffed Animals Both For 10 Bucks $10Lindenhurst, NYWalt Disney World Stitch Stuffed Animal Plush 12 InchWalt Disney World Stitch Stuffed Animal Plush 12 Inch$10Greystone Park, NJSea Otter and Starfish Stuffed Animal - Wild Republic - New York AquariumSea Otter and Starfish Stuffed Animal - Wild Republic - New York Aquarium$10Jersey City, NJAdorable Pig Collection of 6 Stuffed Animals and One Pillow All in Very Nice ConditionAdorable Pig Collection of 6 Stuffed Animals and One Pillow All in Very Nice Condition$18Bergenfield, NJBarbie Dream House, Stuffed Animals, Bag Of ToysBarbie Dream House, Stuffed Animals, Bag Of Toys$35Morristown, NJStuffed SnakesStuffed Snakes$10Menifee, CAMake Believe Ideas Aqua Blue Rhinocorn Rhino Plush Stuffed Animal ToyMake Believe Ideas Aqua Blue Rhinocorn Rhino Plush Stuffed Animal Toy$12Hopatcong, NJMelissa & Doug Pegasus Horse Stuffed Animal LargeMelissa & Doug Pegasus Horse Stuffed Animal Large$20Freehold, NJChewbacca Star Wars Plush Toy Stuffed Animal 22 Inches Felt Pouch TagsChewbacca Star Wars Plush Toy Stuffed Animal 22 Inches Felt Pouch Tags$24Hopatcong, NJOfficial Sanrio Vintage SugarBunnies Mintusa Heartland Small PlushOfficial Sanrio Vintage SugarBunnies Mintusa Heartland Small Plush$60Oceanside, NYTeddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Hand PuppetTeddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Hand Puppet$12Byram Township, NJTim Burton Nightmare Before Christmas Jack Skellington and Sally Plush DuoTim Burton Nightmare Before Christmas Jack Skellington and Sally Plush Duo$13Oceanside, NYGenshin Impact Fanmade Fanart Kpop Doll PlushGenshin Impact Fanmade Fanart Kpop Doll Plush$70Oceanside, NYBoku No Hero Academia My Hero Academia Izuku Midoriya Deku Kimi to Friends School Uniform PlushBoku No Hero Academia My Hero Academia Izuku Midoriya Deku Kimi to Friends School Uniform Plush$10Oceanside, NYBoku no Hero Academia My Hero Academia Ochako Uraraka Medium Mochi Mascot PlushBoku no Hero Academia My Hero Academia Ochako Uraraka Medium Mochi Mascot Plush$10Oceanside, NYMiniature Stuffed HorsesMiniature Stuffed Horses$20Menifee, CA Hello Kitty CINNAMOROLL Side Stepper Animated Plush Patriotic July 4th New Hello Kitty CINNAMOROLL Side Stepper Animated Plush Patriotic July 4th New$38North Babylon, NY Smiling Critter Plush Lot Of 4 Smiling Critter Plush Lot Of 4$30Tinton Falls, NJStuffed Plushy Toys Stuffed Plushy Toys $15Bronx, NY4 mario plushies4 mario plushies$60Queens, NYStuff For SellStuff For Sell$1Passaic, NJLarge Bin Of Miscellaneous Stuffed Animals And MoreLarge Bin Of Miscellaneous Stuffed Animals And More$1Holbrook, NYSuper Cute Like New Cream and Brown Colored Build a Bear Teddy Bear with BackpackSuper Cute Like New Cream and Brown Colored Build a Bear Teddy Bear with Backpack$15Bergenfield, NJCute And Cuddly Octopus Stuffed AnimalCute And Cuddly Octopus Stuffed Animal$10Westwood, NJBack To The Future Plush Marty, Doc Chibi 7” Toy Factory NWT Lot For 2Back To The Future Plush Marty, Doc Chibi 7” Toy Factory NWT Lot For 2$20San Diego, CALanie's Beach Hammock American Girl Retired 2010 For 18” Doll and American Girl Ice Cream Cart Lanie's Beach Hammock American Girl Retired 2010 For 18” Doll and American Girl Ice Cream Cart $40Belleville, NJVintage Stuffed Animals (Disney, Marvel, SpongeBob, More)Vintage Stuffed Animals (Disney, Marvel, SpongeBob, More)$75Syosset, NYLife Size White Tiger Stuffed AnimalLife Size White Tiger Stuffed Animal$60Brooklyn, NY3 stuffed animals3 stuffed animals$10Wood-ridge, NJHuge Rainbow Pastel Stuffed Animal With Baby BearHuge Rainbow Pastel Stuffed Animal With Baby Bear$20Deer Park, NY4ft Teddy Bear4ft Teddy Bear$50Huntingtn Sta, NYHello Kitty Care, Bear Target Exclusive Set Of 2.Hello Kitty Care, Bear Target Exclusive Set Of 2.$75Sayreville, NJHello Kitty Valentines Greeter Hello Kitty Valentines Greeter $35Brooklyn, NYCute And Cuddle, Large Cat Stuffed Animal HomemadeCute And Cuddle, Large Cat Stuffed Animal Homemade$50Westwood, NJMadagascar Plush Collection New With Tags Lot Of 5 Dreamworks Animation 6” RareMadagascar Plush Collection New With Tags Lot Of 5 Dreamworks Animation 6” Rare$40San Diego, CAWailord 57” Pokémon Plush - Sold Out OnlineWailord 57” Pokémon Plush - Sold Out Online$499Milltown, NJDisney Store Christmas Carol Minnie Mouse Animated Plush And Mickey Mouse Holiday Christmas Caroler Plush Toy Disney Store Christmas Carol Minnie Mouse Animated Plush And Mickey Mouse Holiday Christmas Caroler Plush Toy $15Oceanside, NYDisney Winnie the Pooh Christmas Singing Musical Plush MotionetteDisney Winnie the Pooh Christmas Singing Musical Plush Motionette$12Oceanside, NYKermit the Frog Jim Henson Plush Macy's Exclusive 27" Removable Jacket MUPPETKermit the Frog Jim Henson Plush Macy's Exclusive 27" Removable Jacket MUPPET$30Oceanside, NYMelissa & Doug Giraffe Melissa & Doug Giraffe $70North Massapequa, NYLOT of Melissa & Doug Stuffed Animals - Various prices LOT of Melissa & Doug Stuffed Animals - Various prices $75Wayne, NJMelissa And Doug Stuffed Sting Ray Melissa And Doug Stuffed Sting Ray $10Merrick, NY