Butch the dog has a date of birth of October 2, 1998 that’s listed on its ear tag. However on the tush tag the year is listed as 1999. In addition there is punctuation missing and a space before the exclamation point. All these things making this Butch super rare.  beanie babies with errors like this makes them more valuable than those without. Maybe you want to invest in a collectible or gift this to someone you know who has a similar date of birth.