I went through and tested each one (Started them on my Xbox. Did not test the whole game). Each one has small scratches, but seem to work fine (other than those specified below). Starting up worked on each one, and the games should run without issues (other than those specified below). This bundle comes with the following games: Darksiders (pretty big crack in the center. Surprisingly still started up, not sure if the whole game works. Case is in great condition) Darksiders 2 Gears of War (there is a crack in the middle. Not sure how it affects the game) Grand Theft Auto IV Assassin's Creed III Iron Man NHL 12 Call of Duty World at War (UNREADABLE. disc says unreadable, cleaning might fix, it opened the first time I tested it) Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six Vegas 2 (there is a small crack in the middle. Not sure how it affects the game) Batman Arkham Asylum Marvel Ultimate Alliance Halo 4 (UNREADABLE. Disc 1 Isn't Working. Disc 2 opened fine. The case has some damage)