No results found
Use the down arrow to enter the dropdown. Use the up and down arrows to move through the list, and enter to select. To remove the current item in the list, use the tab key to move to the remove button of the currently selected item. Use Escape to close the dropdown and return to the search box.
Search For Sale
Navigate Categories by tabbing to the major areas. Use the Down key to navigate the sub categories and once on the subcategory you are interested in. Use the Enter key to navigate to that page.
The simpler way to buy and sell locally!

Scan to download the app

Stuffed animals

Sub categories

Selected filters

Current listings

Kawaii Stuffed AnimalKawaii Stuffed Animal$7New York, NYBambi Stuffed AnimalBambi Stuffed Animal$10New York, NYDisney Mickey And Minnie Mouse Christmas 2019PromotedDisney Mickey And Minnie Mouse Christmas 2019$45Queens, NYFrog Stuffed AnimalFrog Stuffed Animal$8New York, NYTeddy Bear Keychain Teddy Bear Keychain $20Lawndale, CATiny Nibble 8" Bunny | Stuffed Animal | Gray Bunny Plush - Bunnies By The Bay$21.95Tiny Nibble 8" Bunny | Stuffed Animal | Gray Bunny Plush - Bunnies By The BayBunnies by the BayAdStuffed Animal Puppy ToysStuffed Animal Puppy Toys$25Clifton, NJDoggie Stuffed Animal (Pair)Doggie Stuffed Animal (Pair)$15New York, NYBeanie babies by TYPromotedBeanie babies by TY$750Bloomfield, NJStuffed Animals & ToysStuffed Animals & Toys$2The Bronx, NYDespicable Me Minions Kevin Plush 11" Yellow Stuffed Animal Toy IlluminationDespicable Me Minions Kevin Plush 11" Yellow Stuffed Animal Toy Illumination$14Floral Park, NYLot of 38 Stuffed Animals including Several Build a BearsLot of 38 Stuffed Animals including Several Build a Bears$40Bergenfield, NJGarden Blossom Bunny | Stuffed Bunny Plush Doll$44.95Garden Blossom Bunny | Stuffed Bunny Plush DollBunnies by the BayAdRare Beanie BabysPromotedRare Beanie Babys$400Galesburg, ILBag Of Plushies Stuffed Animals Bag Of Plushies Stuffed Animals $25Queens, NYMickey Mouse and Vintage Pink Polka-Dot Minnie Mouse Stuffed AnimalsMickey Mouse and Vintage Pink Polka-Dot Minnie Mouse Stuffed Animals$20Bergenfield, NJTomy Pokemon Squirtle the Turtle Plush 7" Stuffed Animal 2017Tomy Pokemon Squirtle the Turtle Plush 7" Stuffed Animal 2017$12New York, NYCat in The Hat by Dr. Seuss Plush Stuffed Animal Kohl's CaresCat in The Hat by Dr. Seuss Plush Stuffed Animal Kohl's Cares$14Floral Park, NYEwok PlushPromotedEwok Plush$40North Bethesda, MDPiper The Sandpiper | Bird Stuffed Animal$22.95Piper The Sandpiper | Bird Stuffed AnimalBunnies by the BayAdBig Plush Stuffed Red Bull 46 Inch Huge Animal NICE GoffaBig Plush Stuffed Red Bull 46 Inch Huge Animal NICE Goffa$60Clifton, NJCarter's Elephant 11" Musical Plush Stuffed Animal YOU ARE MY SUNSHINECarter's Elephant 11" Musical Plush Stuffed Animal YOU ARE MY SUNSHINE$15Floral Park, NYDisney Parks Finding Nemo (Clown Fish) Orange White Plush Stuffed Animal 9.5"Disney Parks Finding Nemo (Clown Fish) Orange White Plush Stuffed Animal 9.5"$7New York, NYReversible Octopus Plush ToyPromotedReversible Octopus Plush Toy$14Orlando, FLStuffed Plush Animal Lot Assorted With TagsStuffed Plush Animal Lot Assorted With Tags$25Lynbrook, NYPete the Cat Kewl Blue Guitar Pete 12" Plush Stuffed Animal ToyPete the Cat Kewl Blue Guitar Pete 12" Plush Stuffed Animal Toy$14Floral Park, NYTiny Skipit 8" Puppy Stuffed Animal | Bunnies By The Bay$19.95Tiny Skipit 8" Puppy Stuffed Animal | Bunnies By The BayBunnies by the BayAdGund Supergirl Yvette Puppy Dog Plush DC Comics Pink 12 Inch Stuffed AnimalGund Supergirl Yvette Puppy Dog Plush DC Comics Pink 12 Inch Stuffed Animal$14Floral Park, NYBuild A Bear Batman Plush 16" Black & Yellow Logo DC Comics Stuffed Animal BabBuild A Bear Batman Plush 16" Black & Yellow Logo DC Comics Stuffed Animal Bab$22Floral Park, NYDisney Store Moana Sitting Pua The Pig 9" Plush Authentic Stuffed Animal PiggieDisney Store Moana Sitting Pua The Pig 9" Plush Authentic Stuffed Animal Piggie$14Floral Park, NYWalt Disneryworld 14" Winnie the Pooh Bear Plush Stuffed Animal VVG ConditionWalt Disneryworld 14" Winnie the Pooh Bear Plush Stuffed Animal VVG Condition$10Staten Island, NYTy 1995 Vintage Panda Bear Beanie BabyTy 1995 Vintage Panda Bear Beanie Baby$10New York, NYPAW Patrol Cat Pack Plush SHADE Nickelodeon Cat Pack Stuffed AnimalPAW Patrol Cat Pack Plush SHADE Nickelodeon Cat Pack Stuffed Animal$15Floral Park, NYBig Nibble 20" Bunny | Stuffed Animal | Pink Bunny Plush - Bunnies By The Bay$64.95Big Nibble 20" Bunny | Stuffed Animal | Pink Bunny Plush - Bunnies By The BayBunnies by the BayAdMerry Makers Pete the Cat By James Dean 12" Plush Stuffed AnimalMerry Makers Pete the Cat By James Dean 12" Plush Stuffed Animal$15Floral Park, NYBig Apple Beanie Baby (2004) Ty collectible Big Apple Beanie Baby (2004) Ty collectible $10New York, NYBeanie Baby Husky (Ty) 1994 Classic Beanie Baby Husky (Ty) 1994 Classic $15New York, NY2019 Hallmark Peanuts Snoopy Graduation 2019 Plush Stuffed Animal Graduate Gift2019 Hallmark Peanuts Snoopy Graduation 2019 Plush Stuffed Animal Graduate Gift$13Floral Park, NYRabbit Plush Rabbit Plush $5Brooklyn, NYMelissa & Doug Burrow Bunny Brown Rabbit Stuffed Animal Sitting 9” Toy NewMelissa & Doug Burrow Bunny Brown Rabbit Stuffed Animal Sitting 9” Toy New$20Floral Park, NYOcho The Octopus | Stuffed Animal | Octopus Plush - Bunnies By The Bay$36.95Ocho The Octopus | Stuffed Animal | Octopus Plush - Bunnies By The BayBunnies by the BayAdLots Of 8 Stuffed Animals And Plush Lots Of 8 Stuffed Animals And Plush $18The Bronx, NYJellycat Perry Polar Bear Small 8" tall Plush Stuffed Animal NWTJellycat Perry Polar Bear Small 8" tall Plush Stuffed Animal NWT$33Floral Park, NYNWT Vintage 2000 Y2K Sanrio Hello Kitty Plush Pink Dress Flower 9”NWT Vintage 2000 Y2K Sanrio Hello Kitty Plush Pink Dress Flower 9”$25Ontario, CAPrissy & Pop Mini Pig Plush GUND Stuffed Animal Blue Shirt Gift Farmhouse BarnPrissy & Pop Mini Pig Plush GUND Stuffed Animal Blue Shirt Gift Farmhouse Barn$13Floral Park, NYGarfield And Friends Beanie BabiesGarfield And Friends Beanie Babies$50Queens, NYHello Kitty Greeter💕🥹☀️❤️Hello Kitty Greeter💕🥹☀️❤️$30The Bronx, NYFoxy The Fox | Stuffed Animal | Fox Plush - Bunnies By The Bay$32.95Foxy The Fox | Stuffed Animal | Fox Plush - Bunnies By The BayBunnies by the BayAdPokemon Pikachu 32” Giant PlushiePokemon Pikachu 32” Giant Plushie$80Clifton, NJSquishmallows Gavi The TurkeySquishmallows Gavi The Turkey$30Teaneck, NJ