Stuffed animals
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
Baby Goofy$50Meriden, CT
Vintage TY Beanie Babies Baby Retired RARE 1998 Zero Penguin Santa Hat.
$28New Haven, CT
Ty Beanie Baby Stripes Tiger 1995 NO TAG Plush Stuffed Animal Toy$19New Haven, CT
Homerbest Girl Plush Soft Doll Blonde Pony Tail Blue Eyes Tie Dye & Leopard Print Outfit$19New Haven, CT
Aurora World Dreaming of You Plush mythical creature Unicorn and with single silver and purple glittery horn , Purple, 14"$19New Haven, CT
Ty Beanie Boos - Buttons The Snowman winter Christmas Plush$25New Haven, CT
TY Beanie Boo “Ellie” the Adorable Pink Elephant$19New Haven, CT
Webkinz Brown Cheeky Monkey 9" No
Code
$21New Haven, CT
Leonardo Stuffed Animal$12Southbury, CT
Donatello Stuffed Animal$12Southbury, CT
Scooby-doo Stuffed Animal$12Southbury, CT
Michelangelo Stuffed Animal$12Southbury, CT
Kohl's Cares Jeffers Penguin Black and White Plush for all ages .
$30New Haven, CT
Best Made Toys Stuffed Plush medium size Teddy Bear Valentines Hearts XOXO Love$28New Haven, CT
Teddy Bear $50Hartford, CT
Great Wolf Lodge Fiesta Shiny Dragon Plush 18" Stuffed Animal Red Shiny $18New Haven, CT
Reeces Peanut Butter Cups Plush Bear
$18New Haven, CT
Rare Millennium Beanie Baby mispelled "Millenium" mint with errors$150Stratford, CT
RARE "Fuzz" Ty Beanie Baby w/tag errors and specialties$75Stratford, CT
TY Beanie Baby 1998 “Sammy” the Bear *RARE* w/ errors. *Retired*$225Stratford, CT
Ty Beanie Babie Curly the Bear Retired and VERY RARE with 8 ERRORS!!! Ty Beanie$250Stratford, CT
Ty Beanie Babies 1995 Derby the Horse Rare Retired with Tag Errors$125Stratford, CT
PECAN (THE GOLD BEAR) APRIL 15, 1999 (“RETIRED”) “RARE-VINTAGE” (1999)$150Stratford, CT
Original Ty Beanie Baby Glory 1997 - MINT Condition- WIth Tag Errors.$100Stratford, CT
RARE VINTAGE TY Beanie Baby "Pugsly The Pug" Style 4106 ERRORS$85Stratford, CT
Ty Beanie Baby Spunky The Cocker Spaniel 1997 Retired W/ Tag errors new$150Stratford, CT
Pouch the Kangaroo Rare TY Beanie Baby Style #4161 Mint Condition$15Stratford, CT
Ty Beanie Babies Mooch Beanie Baby Tag Errors$75Stratford, CT
RARE TY BEANIE BABY "TRACKER" BORN IN 1997 WITH TAG ERROR AUTHENTIC AND RETIRED$75Stratford, CT
Russ Husky Small Dog Doll Toy Plush
$15New Haven, CT
Ty Beanie Baby Original. MILLENNIUM bear. Born January 1, 1999. #4226. Retired$150Stratford, CT
Ty Beanie Babies Prance The Grey Cat EXTREMELY RARE$75Stratford, CT
Ty Beanie Baby Ants Retired RARE Errors 1997 - MINT CONDITION$150Stratford, CT
Ty Beanie Baby Hissy the Snake 1997 Rare$250Stratford, CT
Zuru Rainbowcorn Blue Parrot Unicorn Plush Pink Heart Stuff Toy Glitter Eyes 10"
$17New Haven, CT
Ikea Stufted Elephant Animal very floppy ear Realistic Plush Sewn Eyes, soft Tusks
$28New Haven, CT
Teddy Grahams Chunky chocolate Teddy Bear Beanie Stuffed 7” Plush Animal$19New Haven, CT
Kinder Plush Unicorn Toy 12" White Pink Scarf Soft Plush$28New Haven, CT
The World of Beatrix Potter Peter Rabbit Plush Stuffed Animal 2017$20New Haven, CT
Squishmallows Katsla the Cat 10" moon pj Stuffed Plush$47New Haven, CT
Squishmallows Official Kellytoys Plush 8 Inch Fifi the Fox in Pajamas Plush$50New Haven, CT
Disney Stuffed Animals $15Cheshire, CT
Mooch Monkey Ty Beanie Baby (Original w/errors$50Stratford, CT
NEW!! Super cute, extra rare “pouch” beanie baby. PVC pellets.$125Stratford, CT
Webkinz Striped Alley Cat and Pink Funky Flower Carrier - By Ganz$10Stratford, CT
Ganz Webkinz Rabbit$14Stratford, CT
Ganz Webkinz Pinto the Horse$11Stratford, CT
Ganz Webkinz Domino Cat-Retired$13Stratford, CT
Ty Beanie Babies Nanook RARE with tag. $50Stratford, CT
Ty Beanie Babies Swirly The Snail$100Stratford, CT