Stuffed animals & Plush
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
Holiday Mini Squishmallow $3 Each All For $20$3Mishawaka, IN
Wonder, woman$5South Bend, IN
Piglet$5South Bend, IN
Build a Bear Marvel Guardians of The Galaxy Talking Plush Groom Doll 18" $20Mishawaka, IN
Disney Store Tigger Plush Beanie Bottom Doll 20 inch Stuffed Animal$20Mishawaka, IN
Mickey Mouse$10South Bend, IN
Soft Back Books Peppa Pig$7South Bend, IN
Beanie babies and others$10South Bend, IN
Nintendo animals$20South Bend, IN
Build A Bear Dory and book$10South Bend, IN
Mickey Mouse and cards$7South Bend, IN
Elmo build a bear$10South Bend, IN
Jazmine build a bear$10South Bend, IN
Powerpuff girl$5South Bend, IN
Stuffed Animals$10South Bend, IN
Build a bear reindeer in book$7South Bend, IN
Clifford and books$10South Bend, IN
Build a bear unicorns$15South Bend, IN
Stuffed animals$5South Bend, IN
Sally$10South Bend, IN
Post Office Bears$10South Bend, IN
2021 Build A Bear 17" Pikachu Plush$15Mishawaka, IN
Chicago Cubs Baseball MLB Mascot Bear Study Buddies Plush Fan Souvenir Game Nerd$10Mishawaka, IN
Beanie Babies 76 And There's More Items To Go With It And$60Mishawaka, IN
Squishmallow Laura The Pink Tabby Cat$25South Bend, IN
NEW IN DISPLAY CASE 1996 Ty "SNOWBALL" The Snowman 7" Beanie Baby #4201$10Granger, IN
VINTG PAPA SMURF 1979 PEYO WALLACE-BERRIE 10" SITTING PLUSH VGUC$20Niles, MI
Pink Lamb DAN DEE COLLECTORS CHOICE Plush, White Feet & Nose, Pink Ribbon, EUC$12Niles, MI
DAN DEE 17" WHITE ALPACA LLAMA FLUFFY SOFT PLUSH WITH PINK BOW EUC$20Niles, MI
Animal Adventure Jumbo Dinosaur Stuffed Animal 21.5$20Granger, IN
Build A Bear Workshop Kangaroo and Joey Baby 16" Nice Gift$20Mishawaka, IN
1984 LOTSA HEART ELEPHANT CARE BEAR COUSIN 13" PINK PLUSH $24Granger, IN
13 TSUM TSUM DISNEY STORE 3.5" PLUSH StarWarsMickeyMinnieDumboPlutoMrsPotts MORE$24Niles, MI
13" Disney Store Exclusive Soft Pink Purple Stuffed-Stitch$20Mishawaka, IN
Stitch Weighted Stuffed Plush Toy 15"$20Mishawaka, IN
Vintage CARE BEAR COUSINS BRIGHT HEART RACCOON 13" Plush 1984 Kenner EUC$40Granger, IN
Vintage CARE BEAR BEDTIME BEAR Plush 6" 1983 Kenner EUC$13Granger, IN
Vintage BABY HUGS CARE BEAR 1983 Plush Kenner 11" EUC$24Niles, MI
Vintage BABY TUGS CARE BEAR 11" Plush Kenner Blue W/Diaper EUC$22Niles, MI
Vintage FRIEND BEAR CARE BEAR 1983 Plush 13" Kenner EUC$24Granger, IN
Vintage "LOVE-A-LOT" CARE BEAR 13" Plush 1983 Kenner EUC$26Niles, MI
💰 Buying Old Toys, Plush, Electronics & Games! CASH Paid 💾🧸🎮$0Osceola, IN
CARE BEARS BABY CHEER BEAR TALKING FRIEND 2002 NEW BATTERIES 2025 WORKING!$18Granger, IN
(3) VNTG 1983 Care Bears:Yellow Suitcase + 6" Plush Cheer & Funshine(Match Case)$65Granger, IN
Build A Bear Rainbow Splatter Cow Pastel 17"$25Mishawaka, IN
Squishmallows Oleta Multicolor Tye-Dye Heart Octopus Walgreens Exclusive 18"$20Mishawaka, IN
Build A Bear Hearts 'n' Hugs Teddy Bear 16"$15Mishawaka, IN
DISNEY Mickey Mouse Plush 24" Stuffed Animal Toy Jumbo Large Figure$8Mishawaka, IN
Stuffed Bunnies$5Elkhart, IN
Rocky & Bullwinkle and Friends Lot of 7x$25Mishawaka, IN