Stuffed animals
Sub categories
Selected filters
Current listings
NEW IN DISPLAY CASE 1996 Ty "SNOWBALL" The Snowman 7" Beanie Baby #4201$10Niles, MI
Pink Lamb DAN DEE COLLECTORS CHOICE Plush, White Feet & Nose, Pink Ribbon, EUC$12Niles, MI
NEW DAN DEE Christmas Animated Puppy, Dances, Plays Jingle Bells, New W/Tags$20Niles, MI
Squishmallows Minnie Mouse Plush$5Vancouver, WA
VINTG PAPA SMURF 1979 PEYO WALLACE-BERRIE 10" SITTING PLUSH VGUC$20Niles, MI
DAN DEE 17" WHITE ALPACA LLAMA FLUFFY SOFT PLUSH WITH PINK BOW EUC$20Niles, MI
Animal Adventure Jumbo Dinosaur Stuffed Animal 21.5$20Granger, IN
Build A Bear Workshop Kangaroo and Joey Baby 16" Nice Gift$20Mishawaka, IN
DISNEY Mickey Mouse Plush 24" Stuffed Animal Toy Jumbo Large Figure$8Mishawaka, IN
Ty Beanie Baby: Truly the Bear | Stuffed Animal$10South Bend, IN
1984 LOTSA HEART ELEPHANT CARE BEAR COUSIN 13" PINK PLUSH $24Niles, MI
13 TSUM TSUM DISNEY STORE 3.5" PLUSH StarWarsMickeyMinnieDumboPlutoMrsPotts MORE$24Niles, MI
13" Disney Store Exclusive Soft Pink Purple Stuffed-Stitch$30Mishawaka, IN
Super Soft High Quality Turtle Plush$6Vancouver, WA
!!RARE!! VINTAGE Thérèse of Lisieux AURORA PLUSH$25Mishawaka, IN
Stitch Weighted Stuffed Plush Toy 15"$20Mishawaka, IN
Build A Bear Hearts 'n' Hugs Teddy Bear 16"$15Mishawaka, IN
Plush Chicken Chuck E Cheese Helen Henny 28" Girl Mascot 2014 All Ages$15South Bend, IN
Ty Teenie Beanies Millennium Bear ERRORS$100South Bend, IN
Vintage FRIEND BEAR CARE BEAR 1983 Plush 13" Kenner EUC$26Niles, MI
Vintage CARE BEAR COUSINS BRIGHT HEART RACCOON 13" Plush 1984 Kenner EUC$49Niles, MI
Vintage CARE BEAR BEDTIME BEAR Plush 6" 1983 Kenner EUC$15Niles, MI
Vintage BABY HUGS CARE BEAR 1983 Plush Kenner 11" EUC$24Niles, MI
Squishmallows Kitty Cat I Don't Sweat I Sparkle$5Vancouver, WA
Vintage BABY TUGS CARE BEAR 11" Plush Kenner Blue W/Diaper EUC$22Niles, MI
Vintage "LOVE-A-LOT" CARE BEAR 13" Plush 1983 Kenner EUC$26Niles, MI
Vintage "GRAMS BEAR" CARE BEAR 16" Plush With Shawl Kenner 1983 EUC$53Niles, MI
(3) VNTG 1983 Care Bears:Yellow Suitcase + 6" Plush Cheer & Funshine(Match Case)$68Granger, IN
Squishmallows Oleta Multicolor Tye-Dye Heart Octopus Walgreens Exclusive 18"$20Mishawaka, IN
DISNEY Mickey Mouse Plush 24" Stuffed Animal Toy Jumbo Large Figure$15Mishawaka, IN
Rocky & Bullwinkle and Friends Lot of 7x$25Mishawaka, IN
CARE BEARS BABY CHEER BEAR TALKING FRIEND 2002 NEW BATTERIES 2025 WORKING!$22Granger, IN
‼️Labubus & Crybabys‼️$35Brownsville, TX
Kelly's Kids Toys Plush Baby Animal Chair, 23" Uni-Elephant$10South Bend, IN
Build A Bear Rainbow Splatter Cow Pastel 17"$25Mishawaka, IN
Small Stuffed Animal Hand Made$6Niles, MI
Hand Sewn Small Stuffed Animal $15Niles, MI
Build-A-Bear Workshop Sea Splash Dolphin 17” Purple, Pink, Blue$15Mishawaka, IN
Build A Bear 16” Teddy Tie Dye Rainbow Plush Hippie Bear$20Mishawaka, IN
Disney Store Genuine Pink Cheshire Cat Alice In Wonderland 18" Plush Toy$20Mishawaka, IN
Collector’s Dan Dee Smiley Plush Singing Graduate "Who Let The Grads Out"$5Mishawaka, IN
Disney Minnie Mouse Graduation Plush Kcare$12Mishawaka, IN
Rainbow Friends Plush $40Phoenix, AZ
Blues Clues & You! Big Hugs Magenta 16” Inch Plush Super Soft Plush$20Mishawaka, IN
Stitch Weighted Stuffed Plush Toy 15"$20Mishawaka, IN
My Lucky Cubs Baseball Troll Doll - Blue Hair$20Mishawaka, IN
Pokemon DETECTIVE PIKACHU 15" Movie Stuffed Plush$15Mishawaka, IN
Elephant Plush Heatable Microwaveable With Relaxing Lavender New In Box$15Mishawaka, IN
Disney Build A Bear Exclusive High School Musical Graduate Bear W/ Tag$20Mishawaka, IN
NEW 12" Plush Bear CLOUD PETS Bluetooth Jay A Play As Seen On TV Stuffed Lovey$15Mishawaka, IN